<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Deep Code - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Unreasonable Thoughts - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/deep-code?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 01:50:08 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/deep-code" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sensemaking in 2025: Trump Tariffs Edition]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/sensemaking-in-2025-trump-tariffs-edition-7e43e5564b68?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e43e5564b68</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Apr 2025 15:38:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-11T15:38:03.252Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/453/1*oSA7vj9ytvflhkcVYEqU9Q.png" /></figure><p>Over the past few weeks I’ve had a number of people coming to me to see if I could help them make sense of what was going on in the world. As a result, I decided to write some things down and share them — and thereby save time as well as perhaps help a few more people.</p><p>In particular, the events of the last few weeks (the “Trump Tariffs”) have been highly disorienting. Most interpretative frameworks (“frames”) can’t make good sense of them at all.</p><p>I can’t make good sense of the Trump Tariffs either. This is for two reasons:</p><ol><li>There is, in fact, a whole lot going on and the Tariffs must be understood in this larger context.</li><li>Our legacy sensemaking institutions are basically defunct, regurgitating a small number of narrow and often idiotic frames that are barely functional.</li></ol><p>What I can do, then, is discuss a variety of powerful but apparently not broadly known frames for understanding “what is going on”. None explain everything and in fact, all of them together don’t explain everything — but if you have them you’ll have a better view of the larger picture.</p><p>Note the first — I’m not going to be spending any time on frames that are already commonly available. These have been quite thoroughly squeezed and my perspective would add little.</p><p>Note the second — I’ll not be trying at all to mind read or model President Trump. I’ve seen many efforts in this direction (it seems to be a favorite pundit pastime) but when put to the test, none provide predictive value.</p><p>Note the third — I’m not writing this for you. This is some quick thinking intending to help out those who are interested. If what you see here confuses or angers you, I apologize and recommend that you wisely go elsewhere and find more fruitful places to spend your attention.</p><p><strong>Frame One: The End of Neoliberalism</strong></p><p>Liberalism is intrinsically unstable. It is essentially incoherent and is fundamentally parasitic. While it definitely provides a variety of super-salient goods, it does so by means of an extractive process that undermines its own integrity. As a consequence, it must either terminate or continuously expand its domain of extraction — either by going deeper (“stripmining”) or by going broader (“colonizing”). By example, it takes “community” (human groups connected by real and intimate relationships) as a feedstock and releases certain kinds of value (largely material) by converting community into society (human groups coordinated by formal abstractions) — but it cannot produce community. Therefore when it runs out of community, it has to either dig deeper (into family for example) or wider (e.g., going global).</p><p>Neo-liberalism is the “final form” of liberalism and over the past several decades it has gone deep and broad to what appears to be a terminal limit. Consequently, like a car running out of gas (👀) it is starting to cough and sputter. It is coming to an end and is in the process of collapse, one way or another.</p><p>This fact is not lost on a critical mass of global elites (though it *is* lost on the more midwit portion of that class!) and a decent fraction of what is going on has to do with the strategic effort to use the leverage they have, which is declining over time, to shape the transition from the neoliberal global system to something that is maximally to their advantage.</p><p>This may or may not be to <em>your</em> advantage, of course, and I don’t know enough about the intimate details of who is doing what or where to say anything precise about that. But the good news is, because the final, decrepit stage of neoliberalism has been largely to the disadvantage of most for a long time in the areas that are most meaningful (e.g., “meaning” itself!) the net result is likely to be a general improvement.</p><p>So we may very well see a really significant increase in the price of consumer goods (aka bullshit) at Walmart or perhaps the end of Walmart as an economic entity, we will also generally see trends towards things like an increase in “true wealth.”</p><p><strong>Frame Two: The Fourth Industrial Revolution</strong></p><p>It very much appears to be the case that “industrial revolutions” come and go in waves. Our understanding of these things is all a bit rough, but as a way of thinking, the 20th Century was dominated (and largely defined) by our increasingly intense application of things like oil, electricity and steel to produce a society of (centralized) mass production, mass distribution (cars, planes and really big boats), and mass communication (radio and television).</p><p>Starting in the 70’s the next big wave began to build and gave us things like computers, increasingly automated industry and global telecommunications (e.g., the Internet).</p><p>We are now entering into a new and potentially very big phase. Some see this as the “second phase” of the 3rd Industrial Revolution, others as the emergence of a 4th Industrial Revolution, a distinction about which I care little. The key insight is that things are changing and we are just about to enter into the acceleration phase of that change.</p><p>This phase includes things like the Internet of Things, very advanced biotechnology and synthetic biology, very advanced and increasingly agentic robotics, a variety of decentralized manufacturing processes, quantum computing, blockchain and (of course) AI (more on this in its own frame).</p><p>I’m not going to go into details here but, for example, where in the past 100 years “t-shirt” manufacturing became a function of gigantic mass production centers combining low cost human and automated labor with global distribution chains, as we move into this new phase, t-shirts might be “printed” (or grown using synthetic biology) in one off bespoke fashion at local centers and transported (by flying drones?) to your house. Consider how printing moved from centralized industrial presses to millions of desktop printers in homes and offices.</p><p>This kind of shift portends massive consequences for the current global order. For example, China’s rise over the past quarter century was largely founded on the techniques and premises of the waning last industrial form. Right now the shape and trajectory of the coming wave is wide open and (once again) a slice of global elites, some of whom are part of the above post-neoliberalism cohort and some of whom aren’t, have been looking at this transition closely and are making moves to shape this big transition to their advantage.</p><p>Note — given the implications of this shift, you can be sure that anyone who is sending you videos like this:</p><p><a href="https://video.twimg.com/ext_tw_video/1909287794624937984/pu/vid/avc1/768x576/P-3ufZ3c7TzWdiQd.mp4?tag=12">https://video.twimg.com/ext_tw_video/1909287794624937984/pu/vid/avc1/768x576/P-3ufZ3c7TzWdiQd.mp4?tag=12</a></p><p>is either lying to you or outing themselves as a useful idiot.</p><p><strong>Frame Three: The End of Post-WWII American Hegemony</strong></p><p>From 1945 and then with a step function at the collapse of the U.S.S.R., the United States entered into a historically singular moment as the global hegemon. That period is also coming to an end. China has quite successfully emerged as a peer competitor and with the recent surge in BRICs it is clear that the future is multi-polar.</p><p>I should point out that this is even true militarily. While it is at least arguable that the United States still has the military power to win any particular fight it chooses, it is also arguable that this is no-longer true — and moreover the rate of change is going towards the latter. A big part of this has to do with the aforementioned fourth industrial revolution — while the US spends a lot more than anyone else, the metric of war is not how much you spend but how much effective lethality you produce. We might very well be spending 10X as much to get the same amount of punching power as our various adversaries as a result of late-stage corruption and the hollowing-out of our innovation base.</p><p>[Note — yes, I know it’s possible that we have a stable of sci-fi superweapons sitting in some DARPA warehouse that no-one knows about. Maybe.]</p><p>This is a big-old realignment and has a lot of consequences. One of which is that the US’s ability to shape the world according to its preferences is also coming to an end. Interestingly, because the United States was one of the first conquered by neoliberalism, a large part of the American Hegemony was put to the service of neoliberalism (facilitating the global spread and intensification of neoliberalism). This had the somewhat confounding consequence of using American power in a fashion that harmed Americans (e.g., the rust belt) to the benefit of (for example) China and (much more so) globalists.</p><p>Another major part of the American Hegemony was put to the service of the class of elites who were able to control and deploy it to their ends. While we can and should give Pax Americana credit for a pretty good overall historical showing in terms of global peace and prosperity, broadly speaking, the top .1% of political and economic elites (not at all necessarily American) have increasingly been using their ability to control the American hegemony to extract value from the world. An egregious example of this was the exploitation of the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan to line the pockets of a very small number of military and energy interests who were able to leverage the mechanisms of the American hegemony to benefit themselves.</p><p>The end of a major hegemony is always a dangerous transition. The last time this happened (the end of Pax Britannia) we had two world wars until the dust had settled. A non-trivial part of what is going on is a complex dance of diverse interests trying to move pieces on the current board in a fashion that threads the needle between shaping the coming multi-polar order to their advantage and avoiding a catastrophic military conflict.</p><p><strong>Frame Four: The Civil War</strong></p><p>Yes, I know that there aren’t folks running around in grey and blue uniforms shooting at each-other. As it turns out, that isn’t how war works. By sheer strategic necessity, the next war looks very little like the last war — and we are currently in a “5th Generation” Civil War.</p><p>Fifth generation warfare is a form of conflict that is largely <strong>non-kinetic, decentralized, and psychological</strong> — a war of <strong>narratives, perceptions, and influence</strong> rather than bullets, bombs, or battalions. It is insidious, obscure and we are immersed in it. By definition it is impossible to have certainty about who is on what team and what, exactly, they are doing, but for illustrative purposes, let’s carve out something of a game board to make some sense of things.</p><p>Right now in the US we have something of a coalition on the right that includes MAGA, MAHA and the DOGE cohorts. Notice that even within this coalition there are myriad fissures and wars within wars. Arrayed against them are:</p><ul><li>The legacy left (aka the Democrats)</li><li>Big chunks of the legacy institution order (media, the academy, and most of establishment government — the IC in particular)</li><li>Big chunks of the legacy right — (aka the Republicans)</li><li>Globalists</li><li>China</li><li>etc.</li></ul><p>Maneuvering in this environment is . . . complex. You have to “doge” and weave, disorienting your adversaries, taking and giving territory, terraforming the landscape in a fashion that serves your advantage and disadvantages your adversaries — but having to watch out for changes in the balance of power in your own fluid coalition.</p><p>A meaningful portion of “what is happening” is this dodge and weave.</p><p><strong>Frame Five: The Rise of AI</strong></p><p>You’ve probably noticed that AI has become a thing. What you *might* not know is that an increasing portion of the elites (particularly the technology elites) have concluded that it is <em>the</em> thing. There is a building consensus at the top of that hierarchy that we’re close, meaningfully close, to crossing a tipping point where AI is good enough (particularly millions of AI running in parallel) to provide a categorically unique strategic advantage to whoever possesses it.</p><p>Moreover, within this frame whoever gets pole position on that point, particularly when you consider the feedback loop of intelligence on intelligence, starts to get something like escape velocity in power.</p><p>From their point of view, literally all of the above frames are relatively unimportant. Once you’ve seen the AI take off everything else starts to look like trivial in the light of this new radical phase transition.</p><p>As a consequence, for these elites, every move in the above frame is a means to an end: establish dominion in AI.</p><p>Notably, there is really only a handful of players in that game. You’ve got the OpenAI and the Stargate Bloc. You’ve got the House of Musk/Thiel complex that includes Palantir, Grok, Twitter, SpaceX, Starlink, Tesla. You’ve got the Googleplex, which was in the lead, but is now seems to be falling behind. And you’ve got China. Perhaps that big Saudi initiative or Anthropic is in the mix. Maybe a few others that are doubleplus secret. But that’s about it.</p><p>So those (increasingly powerful and influential) players are trying to figure out how to maneuver things to their advantage and if you use this lens to look at everything that’s going on, you can begin to see the Tariffs as a way to (a) slow down China’s AI progress and (b) force next gen chip fabrication farther from Chinese control.</p><p>I’m going to stop here. There are, of course, many frames that are also perfectly useful. This is by no means an attempt to provide a comprehensive nor even a sufficient model. Rather, as I said to begin, to hand out a few useful and not-broadly-enough understood frames.</p><p>Notice that these are not at all mutually exclusive. In fact most of them are highly entangled. That is how reality works — a lot is going on all at once and it’s all really happening.</p><p>The way I do this is I hold all of these frames at once and I peer at the world through this kaleidoscope curiously. Sometimes something pops out as pretty clearly true (e.g., COVID was a lab-leak). Sometimes all I get is a rough heuristic to help make choices (e.g., let’s wait on that whole COVID vaccine thing). Sometimes it’s all just very unclear.</p><p>Well, I hope that was helpful. If so, not a bad way for me to spend a few hours on a Friday!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e43e5564b68" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/sensemaking-in-2025-trump-tariffs-edition-7e43e5564b68">Sensemaking in 2025: Trump Tariffs Edition</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From City to Civium]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/from-city-to-civium-5838e0cdfe31?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5838e0cdfe31</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Sep 2023 17:11:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-22T21:53:48.733Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HYY3H0tMDyhVEGGxN0k8Zw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In my long contemplation of that thing sometimes called “civilization,” one insight has come through that seems significant enough to write down and share. It concerns what I suspect might be the core driver behind all variations on “the city” and, by extension, civilization itself.</p><p>Below, I will endeavor to compactly convey the central idea and then make the argument that we are now (for the first time in history) at a moment where that core driver is beginning to break down. The implication is that we are at a pivot point in history.</p><p>Note: I’ve previously shared much of this in videos. My friend Nick Redmark created a nice compilation (with pictures using MidJourney for extra irony) for those who prefer that medium: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9oeVtWFOXU">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9oeVtWFOXU</a></p><p>Now, a bit of background.</p><p><strong>Scaling Laws</strong></p><p>In his book “<em>Scale</em>” theoretical physicist Geoffrey West tells of an investigation into the underlying principles that govern the growth and life spans of everything from plants and animals to companies and cities.</p><p>The researchers discovered a remarkably consistent dynamic: a relationship called “sublinear scaling”. For example, if you increase the mass of a mouse you don’t increase its energetic needs at the same rate. Instead, if you increase the mass by a factor of 10 (from 1 to 10 for example) you increase the metabolic rate by only about 5.6. Keep doing this and you can end up with an animal with the mass of an elephant (10 million grams), but with a metabolic rate of only 177,000. The ratio of mass to metabolic rate went from 1:1 to 56:1.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KQdwunr2YmOp2e9iqtEJ4A.png" /></figure><p>The folks working on this project looked at all kinds of systems and they kept noticing this sublinear scaling. They noticed it in cells; in different kinds of animals; in plants; in forests and ecosystems. It was ubiquitous and played a major role in how life operates and grows.</p><p>Then they looked at cities.</p><p>At first, cities showed the same kind of dynamic. Double the population of the city and you increase infrastructure like roads and electrical lines by around 85%. That same old sublinear scaling. But then a new kind of scaling relationship showed up.</p><p>When they looked at things like innovation, productivity and wages, they noticed a <em>completely different</em> kind of scaling relationship: superlinear scaling. In the case of these characteristics, if you double the population of a city, you increase the productivity of the city by <em>more</em> than double (roughly 115%). Double the population, increase the productivity by 115%. Double the population, increase innovation by 115%.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/542/1*gcK3CYp5_NzLuJ5R2z82tA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Cities and superlinear scaling</strong></p><p>Here is my first proposition: superlinear scaling is <em>the</em> generator of cities. The city is, in its essence, the solution to the problem of how to grow the population of a place as large as possible so as to maximally benefit from superlinear scaling.</p><p>Consider: if you double the population of a city, you increase several important characteristics like wealth and innovation superlinearly. Move from a village of 10,000 to a town of 20,000 and per capita wages increases by 15%, sort of “automagically”. Double it again and those wages increase by 15% again. After a few doublings, the wealth and innovation gap between the “tiny village” and the “big city” is quite large.</p><p>Notably, West and team looked at cities across many periods of time, a wide variety of cultures and across many different levels of population. More or less, none of the particulars mattered that much. The dynamic was there in India, Japan, England and the United States and in cities from the 800’s through to the current age. The key was simply the relationship between population and superlinear scaling.</p><p>Notice the implicit feedback loop. Wealth and innovation are profound attractors. Merely by moving from the village to the city, you can participate in this increase and the various qualities of life that stem from increased wealth and innovation (including things like fancy architecture, fashionable restaurants and the like). All things being even vaguely equal, many people will choose to move to the city. This increases the population — which then increases the wealth and innovation.</p><p>Left to its own devices, this attractor would pull everyone into the city. However, the increase in population isn’t unconstrained. If you want to add more people into a city, you have to find some way to provide food, water and housing, to remove waste, to enable people to move around, etc. If you can’t solve for these constraints, you can’t increase the population of the city.</p><p>How do you solve for these constraints? You take advantage of the wealth and innovation produced by superlinear scaling, of course! Having a hard time feeding people? Invent irrigated agriculture. Have a hard time housing people? Invent the elevator and deploy wealth to construct skyscrapers to radically increase the vertical potential of housing.</p><p>Thus we have a dynamic tension. Increasing population produces superlinear wealth and innovation. It also produces a variety of new pressures. To the degree that the people of the city can craft and implement solutions to those pressures, the city can continue to grow and produce superlinear results. To the degree that they can’t, stagnation and even collapse.</p><p><strong>Cities as the essence of civilization</strong></p><p>I propose that this dynamic tension at the center of cities is also at the center of civilization.</p><p>Consider one of the core innovations discovered early in the history of urbanization: the conversion of complex nature into <em>functional territory</em>. Near the center of the city, the function of land is as a place for business and population density. Fields and forests and streams (complex ecology) are cleared to make room for these specific functions. Near the periphery, the function shifts to lower density residential and perhaps industry. Farther from the center you enter the territory of food production and waste disposal.</p><p>The logos of civilization is simply the expansion of the idea of “functional territory” over a large space. “All roads lead to Rome.” In a crucial sense, <em>every</em> aspect of a civilization is, ultimately, a piece of the technical solution of increasing the population of the Capital. Secondary and tertiary cities and the “outlying territories” are simply part of the extended body of The City. Agricultural, industrial and even cultural centers producing material for the Capital.</p><p>Of course, this account makes it seem like the citizens of Alexandria (or Chicago or Birmingham) are somehow subordinate to or less than the citizens of Rome (or New York or London). While the inhabitants of the Capital might very well agree with that assessment, I think it is not quite that simple. But this takes us deeper into the inquiry.</p><p><strong>Ephemeralization</strong></p><p>My second thesis is that the superlinear scaling observed by West is very closely related to the similarly shaped scaling observed by Metcalfe (e.g., Metcalfe’s law or the “network effect”). Per Metcalfe’s law, adding <em>n</em> nodes to a network increases the ‘influence and value’ of the network by something like <em>n^2.</em> In other words, it is superlinear.</p><p>Economists and folks in the tech industry have studied this phenomenon thoroughly over the past few decades. We notice that in a wide variety of domains, once a network gets to a “critical mass” of users, it indeed begins to experience a positive feedback loop where more users makes the network more attractive which brings more users. Interestingly, while the value of the network (as measured in revenue, market cap and attractiveness/growth rate) increases, we don’t see superlinear scaling in innovation. The obvious explanation is that cities are built by the people in the cities — while networks often are built by a (sublinear) corporation. The implication, of course, is that an open source network that gets to critical mass should be able to outcompete closed rivals. Perhaps a topic for another day.</p><p>My argument here is that what we are observing in the superlinear scaling of cities is a consequence, not of cities themselves, but of the nature of information and communication networks. At the most fundamental level, in order to get superlinear scaling, we don’t need people to “live” next to each-other, we need them to <em>communicate with</em> (and collaborate with) each-other.</p><p>Of course, for the majority of human history, “collaborating with” and “living near” amounted to the same thing. But here we notice that while a tremendous part of the work of civilization has been to reshape physical reality so as to facilitate getting as many human bodies as possible into proximity, there has always been another solution: ephemeralize communication. Rather than solving the problem of collaboration by bringing bodies into proximity, innovate new ways to afford communication that are not bound to physical proximity.</p><p>If we are looking at population through the lens of networking, the question of “who is in the same city” ultimately amounts to the question of “who can potentially come into communication”? Physically, this might be afforded by my walking from my home across the street to your home. Or by riding a bike down the road to the local coffee shop. Or by taking a bus across town. Or a train between towns. Or a plane across the country.</p><p>Transportation affords a solution to increasing population along the direction of ephemeralization. The “population of a city” is some rough accounting of the total number of people with whom any given person can come into communication. It therefore includes, to a greater or lesser degree, everyone who can physically travel into face to face encounter.</p><p>Roads and triremes enabled “all of Rome” to be <em>in some degree</em> connected and part of the same population. In the 19th century, trains connected the populations of nation-states. In the more recent era, planes have produced a physical network for the planet.</p><p>Transporting people has greatly solved otherwise impossible problems for increasing the population of the city. But the bigger possibility has been afforded by technologies for facilitating communication entirely separately from the body, aka “telecommunication”. First the oral messenger (“tell your father to come to the field”). Then the written message. Then the telegraph and the telephone. Then a whole proliferation of different media that ephemeralize the means of communication.</p><p>The advantages and disadvantages of telecommunication are well-known. By allowing bodies to “stay where they are,” they radically change the energetic and temporal costs of communication. But, by removing the full context of embodiment, they lose an enormous amount of collaborative capacity and raise entirely new problems for both mind and culture.</p><p>Until recently, this tradeoff has relegated telecommunications to a secondary role. To be sure, the innovation of the printing press massively increased the communicative capacity of Western civilization and radically rebalanced the psychocultural sensibility of the West. But, even then, the majority of communication was face to face and the center of collaboration was grounded in physical proximity.</p><p>Until recently. But since the introduction of the Internet and increasingly since 2020, we have been swiftly moving towards a tipping point where the technologies of communication are providing an adequately rich possibility of relationship that the center of collaboration has or soon will move from the physical to the virtual.</p><p>My third thesis: the invention and development of “the digital” brings an end to the cultural logic of the city that has been driving civilization since the beginning. We are now exiting the epoch of the city and entering the epoch of a new relationship. The civium.</p><p><strong>From city to civium</strong></p><p>Let’s take a moment to examine the nature of “the digital.” When Andreesen pointed out that “software is eating the world,” he wasn’t kidding around. Digital represents the absolute essence of ‘mediation’. Consider: writing mediates some aspects of language while the telephone mediates other aspects. The telegraph still others. A photograph mediates some aspects of image, a moving picture still others. But digital can (and does) perform *all* of these functions. Digital can express any particular form of mediation.</p><p>What this means is that this notion of the ephemeralization of communication will reach its ultimate extension somewhere in the domain of the digital. I’m old enough to remember when video calls were as SciFi as flying cars. Now they are a staple of collaboration and provide a richness of relationship *far* beyond a phone call or an email. Are Zoom and FaceTime the nail in the coffin of the city? Perhaps, perhaps not, but they are also not the end of the road for digital. Apple’s “VisionPro” represents a major effort to move the state of the art and this is not the final form of digital either.</p><p>Barring a significant social collapse of our technological civilization (which <em>is</em> entirely plausible!) it is just a matter of time. The helter skelter endeavor to solve the problem of how to get more and more people into communication by means of innovation and wealth finds its end point somewhere in the digital.</p><p>And if the power of superlinear scaling is as I suggest, then the driver moving the history of civilization will continue to do its work. But, with the center of superlinear scaling moved from the physical to the virtual, the balance of power between these two regimes will begin to shift. While the territorial powers will do their best to hold onto their populations, and may succeed for quite some time, ultimately the dynamo of superlinear scaling will subordinate them, just as the city subordinated the indigenous modes of humanity that preceded it.</p><p>In the end, this attractor will seek to bring everyone into a single “network”. But, instead of a giant megalopolis, the forces of superlinear scaling will turn their attentions towards the formation of a planetary network connecting, in principle, all minds.</p><p>The story of this planetary network, the dangers it poses, and the diverse forces that will govern its shape and trajectory is interesting, but will have to wait for another telling. The point of focus for <em>this</em> essay is that the shift we are witnessing portends a tremendous change in the winds for our <em>physical</em> lives.</p><p>For one thing, the city (as we know it) will begin to fade from the earth. With wealth and innovation increasingly found in the virtual, rather than in the urban, those people who are most lightly connected to the city will begin to go elsewhere. And this produces a feedback loop in the opposite direction: as the population of cities *decrease* their wealth and innovation also will decrease — superlinearly.</p><p>Already we have witnessed much of the “cool factor” of culture has moved into the virtual. And even that which is intrinsically physical, has been much more widely distributed by the virtual ability to transmit technique and sensibility: even relatively small rural towns these days have coffee shops just as good as the biggest cities. As the initial migration of people initiates a superlinear decline, we might expect a series of interlocking feedback loops that could accelerate the evaporation of cities. What took thousands of years to create might fade in centuries or even generations.</p><p>Of course as people leave cities, they will go somewhere. But where? My thesis is that with the superlinear scaling attractor no longer driving people into cities, the new dominant attractor will become the oldest dominant attractor: we will begin to return to wholesome, human-scale, ‘indigenous’ contexts.</p><p>As the earliest pioneers of this new world leave cities in search of a new way of living together, they will begin to congregate around places guided by deep values. Values that guided human choice for hundreds of thousands of years and which have been subordinated by the logic of urbanization for only a brief (ten thousand year) moment.</p><p>Liberated from the allure of the city we might expect people to be <em>naturally</em> attracted to places that are physically beautiful, that are safe and clean. Places that are rich in community and make raising a family as easy as it can be. Where meaningful life is most fully supported.</p><p>In most cases, of course, we will have to re-build these kinds of places. In most cases, in fact, we will need to re-learn how to live in this way.</p><p>Civium is the name that I am giving to a hypothesis: that the most powerful form of network is a properly architected planetary virtual network populated by wholesome, healthy humans who are in intimate relationship with place and each-other.</p><p>The transition from city to civium will involve re-building humane places, re-learning how to live properly with each other and our environment, coming into symbiotic relationship with the virtual and re-grounding in the sacred.</p><p>We should be mindful that this transition is not one simply of architecture and urban design. Everything is implicated. Governance at human scale is an entirely different kind of problem than the mass governance that we have become used to. Our approaches to food production, physical manufacturing and waste have been entirely defined by the needs and capacities of the city. We will need to invent entirely new economies in the new context of distributed human-scale civium.</p><p>Perhaps even more importantly, family and all of the interpersonal elements of life (education, health care, religion) will undergo a profound (and positive) change. In many ways the move to civium will represent a *restoration* of the personal in these areas rendered so impersonal and inhumane by the territorial logic of the city.</p><p>All of this is going to take time and, like it or not, a lot of trial and error experimentation. Civium will not be built in a day. But here are some things to consider that are a tailwind in our efforts:</p><ul><li>The fourth industrial revolution really is at hand — but the <em>WEF is completely wrong</em>. They are correct in recognizing that a massive technical wave is sweeping across our economic landscape, but they make the mistake of thinking that the city (and its nature) is an invariant. As a result, they have found themselves imagining “15 minute cities” of the future. But when you realize that the city is no longer the center and investigate the technologies underlying the fourth industrial revolution with new eyes, you notice how perfectly many of these technologies support a highly distributed and highly local economy.</li><li>More and more obviously the “ecological crisis” (sometimes narrowly grasped as “climate change”) requires a level of intimacy and sensitivity to entangled complex reality that the technocratic institutions (and technocratic mindsets) of civilization simply cannot produce. Civium, by contrast, is precisely the right instrument to reorient our physical and spiritual relationship with our environment. A people who are intimately connected to their local water and local land, who are intimately connected with each-other and with themselves, <em>and</em> who are buttressed by the innovative capacity of a superlinear planetary network are properly positioned to take full and proper stewardship of the world.</li><li>The challenge of changing demographics (sometimes identified as “demographic collapse”) might only be addressable by something like civium. If we look at the underlying causation of collapsing birthrates throughout the world, it is a very complex affair. On one hand education and a real change in the necessity of large families (due both to decreased child mortality and a changed economy) have played a role. But on the other hand, things like the precipitous decline in testosterone and sperm count; increase in microplastics and myraids of other toxins; and the dramatic decline in mental health (especially in the West) have played a much less healthy role. To put it simply, it just doesn’t make sense to have and raise children in the city. The opposite is true in every way in civium. (Re)connection to the meaningfulness of wholesome family will be a powerful attractor into civium, and as the people of the city dissolve into below-replacement rate demographics, the people of the civium will naturally replace them over the generations.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5838e0cdfe31" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/from-city-to-civium-5838e0cdfe31">From City to Civium</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The DAO Moment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/the-dao-moment-5d6aa8e6f5e7?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d6aa8e6f5e7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Jan 2022 04:18:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-28T04:18:22.636Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The new Alchemists</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ASzdXfTiTyKimP58.png" /></figure><p>We have reached a long awaited point in the unfolding evolution of the Bitcoin/blockchain/crypto/Web3 (“Web3”) ecosystem: the <em>DAO moment</em>.</p><p>In its simplest form, the DAO moment is the point at which the Web3 ecosystem turns its full attention on the problem space sometimes known as “governance” or “coordination.” More esoterically, it is the moment when the evolution of Web3 shifts from an unconscious, game theoretic, causal, “biological” process to a <em>conscious evolutionary process</em>.</p><p>The timing of this moment is fortunate as we (humanity as a whole) are currently beset by a pantheon of “wicked problems.” Problems like ecosystem collapse, the accelerating breakdown of social and political coherence, and the event horizon of exponential technology. These are “wicked” both because they represent world-historical risk (i.e., they are very important) and because they are strictly insoluble using our current “problem solving” toolkit (i.e., are very bad news).</p><p>Historically, humanity has made use of three different tools (and their various admixtures) to solve problems. The first, oldest and primary, is our indigenous form of collaboration. We might call it the group, tribal or “team” mode. It involves a relatively small group of people working together closely, combining their different perspectives, knowledge and capacities to become capable of solving problems much greater than any could have individually. This tool is powerful and forms the foundation of all human problem solving. However, thus far it has been limited in its ability to scale. As anyone who has built a team knows, as you add more people, things get more and more complex. Keeping five people coherent is much harder than keeping two in real collaboration. And even world class teams tend to break down somewhere between forty and one hundred and fifty people.</p><p>The other two tools more or less emerge to help us scale coordination: institutions and markets. Institutions are formal, hierarchical and bureaucratic. They can (usefully) scale to tens of thousands of people and have tremendous capacities for solving and managing many different kinds of “complicated” problems like sending a man to the moon and back and extracting, refining and distributing gasoline around the world. They also have a set of known limitations, most notably that they become bloated and corrupt as they age and that they cannot perceive or address “complexity” (and, therefore, invariably produce many “externalities” in their operation). [<a href="https://samoburja.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Great_Founder_Theory_by_Samo_Burja_2020_Manuscript.pdf">Samo Burja has been thinking and writing lucidly about institutions</a>.]</p><p>Markets make use of simple signaling mechanisms (i.e., money) to scale enormously (perhaps without limit) and unlock the vast “computational” capacity of whole populations. This allows them to solve problems far beyond the scope of institutions, most famously steering the economic activities of national populations. They are equally subject to a number of known failure conditions, some of which have been very well tagged by <a href="https://www.slatestarcodexabridged.com/Meditations-On-Moloch">‘Slatestarcodex’ as “Moloch.”</a></p><p>These three tools have been combined and refined over the centuries to help humans address our problems (and, of course, to create entirely new ones). But we are now reaching the limit of their possibility. Try as we might, we cannot take responsibility for ourselves, come into right relationship with our technology and occupy our proper position as “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PZMGYPqs0Q">custodial species” of the whole of the natural world</a> using teams/tribes, institutions or markets. If we are to navigate the 21st Century in any orderly fashion, we need to find a new tool. It is possible that DAOs are the solution.</p><p>Possible, but by no means certain. Despite the enormous success of primordial DAOs like Bitcoin and Ethereum (yes, these are DAOs), we are still in the stone knives and bearskin phase. Hence the “DAO Moment.”</p><p>Now is the time to become Promethean. To refine the essence of all that we have learned and hoped for and combine this in a crucible of conscious intent. In a word, to become <em>DAO Alchemists</em>. As the chill of “crypto winter” begins to descend upon us, the season for “going inward” comes again. As winter kills off the parasites and quiets the frenzy, we begin what might be the final and most important phase of this evolutionary journey. The moment when Web3 becomes consciously self-governing in service of the whole.</p><p>For the critics: a rebuke. We are not designing an Nth generation messaging app or yet another new way to separate humanity from its soul (I’m looking at you Web2), we are endeavoring something extraordinary. We are trying to innovate an entirely new form of human coordination. And we are doing so in the degeneracy and tyranny of a dying civilization. We need all of the help we can get. If you can help, by all means do so. Otherwise, get the fuck out of the way.</p><p>By my read of the stars, we have, perhaps, two years before the rumble and shake of the larger context raises yet another octave. There is much to do and little time. I’m hard at work with my eyes on the Hunter’s Moon. More on that in due course. As for the rest of the “Invisible College,” good luck! I look forward to seeing what emerges.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/0*l5GCO2tD-havkJvT.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d6aa8e6f5e7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/the-dao-moment-5d6aa8e6f5e7">The DAO Moment</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the future of the blockchain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/on-the-future-of-the-blockchain-c2da7fcfd2ef?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2da7fcfd2ef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[collective-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 May 2021 02:31:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-09T02:31:33.308Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>And the continuing adventures of SOCI</p><p>Hi everyone. Last year (or maybe the year before), Medium censored one of my posts with effectively no explanation or process. So I no longer feel called to post here. If you’d like to follow my work (such as it is), my new home is at Substack.</p><p><a href="https://deepcode.substack.com/p/on-the-future-of-the-blockchain">https://deepcode.substack.com/p/on-the-future-of-the-blockchain</a></p><p>“In February of 2016, I <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/lets-get-this-straight-bitcoin-is-an-experiment-in-self-organizing-collective-intelligence-52d78212c5e6">wrote an essay concerning the nature and potential of Bitcoin</a>. With now five years of water under the bridge, and the price of Bitcoin increasing a hundredfold, I figured it would be worth returning to the topic and reexamining the landscape. In the present essay, I broaden the scope to include the whole of the broader blockchain as a complex but coherent ecosystem.”</p><p>I promise I’ll never charge money or create any kind of subscription. I can’t promise that I’ll be at substack for the long term — they took VC money and could easily enough also break integrity with the simple premise of providing a platform for collective conversation. But we can always hope.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2da7fcfd2ef" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/on-the-future-of-the-blockchain-c2da7fcfd2ef">On the future of the blockchain</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Rise and Fall of Networks]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/the-rise-and-fall-of-networks-be504049927?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/be504049927</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Jul 2020 20:34:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-01T20:34:23.228Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*NXwXYx-px-rz3Fv821pB_A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The following has long struck me as obvious, but it occurred to me yesterday that it might not be. So I share it herein.</p><p>We are aware of the phenomenon called “Metcalfe’s Law.” Roughly that the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of users connected to the system. This “network effect” is perhaps the most important value driver in the world today. Because the value of the network increases with the number of people on the network, there is a self fulfilling prophecy. Past a critical point the biggest network is more attractive than any other competing network. Which means that it gets more users. Which means that it gets more valuable. Which means that it is more attractive.</p><p>It can be a pretty quick ride to monopolistic vastness. Just ask Facebook, YouTube and Twitter.</p><p>OK. Lets call this feedback loop the “network attractor.” Once you have achieved some critical point, your platform is like a black hole that sucks in everything and makes escape increasingly impossible.</p><p>Now I would like to introduce a new concept. Perhaps even a new law.</p><blockquote>“Any for-profit entity that is founded on the value of network effects must maximally extract that value to the limit of the network attractor. This produces an ‘extractive repulsor’ force. As the limit is approached, the network becomes poised at fragility.</blockquote><p>Note that the extraction of value does not necessarily come in the form of “optimizing for profit.” To be sure, much of it does — things like increasing the number and intrusiveness of ads often shows up — but a lot of the ‘extraction’ comes in other forms. Things like reduced customer service. Or increasing use of the platform to accomplish goals that are anti-valued by the users. Of particular note is the increasing intrusiveness of the platform itself — sucking value out of the whole of the user’s life and into the platform.</p><p>The specific form of the extraction is up to the specific platform. But the rule is general: the camel will be loaded with straw until the last.</p><p>And then we have the final piece of this new law: Metcalfe’s law cuts both ways. If the value of a network increases exponentially as you add new users to the system, it also *decreases* exponentially as users leave the system.</p><p>But on this side of the ride the network has a problem: it is now burdened with the ‘extractive repulsor.’ So unless the folks in charge of the platform can figure out a way to reduce the extraction at an exponential rate, even a small number of people leaving the network will quickly lead to a torrent.</p><p>Through the relentless carelessness of value extraction, the system has become “hollowed out.” All surface area, no volume.</p><p>As quickly as systems built by Metcalfe’s law can grow, by Halls’ law, they can even more quickly collapse.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=be504049927" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/the-rise-and-fall-of-networks-be504049927">The Rise and Fall of Networks</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Defund (and redesign) everything.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/defund-and-redesign-everything-d1b9d674a45d?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1b9d674a45d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jun 2020 20:42:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-10T03:36:14.206Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1020/1*6VeZOSOnHbmhLGIjEXuAnQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>from <a href="http://laurengary.deviantart.com/art/Zen-Garden-117505415">http://laurengary.deviantart.com/art/Zen-Garden-117505415</a></figcaption></figure><p>We have now reached a very interesting point. At least at the narrative level we have reached the point that “defunding the police” is a real proposition. It even seems plausible that some jurisdictions (most notably Minneapolis) will do it. Of course, it remains to be seen how much actions meet words, but nonetheless this is quite a change.</p><p>I would like to propose that this idea is very good in two ways and very bad in one. And I would like to suggest how to get the best out of it.</p><h4>Moving beyond corrupt and obsolete institutions</h4><p>Broadly speaking, “policing” in the United States has become a bad combination of corrupt and obsolete. This is not, however, a problem that is either exclusive or unique to policing. Quite the opposite.</p><p>When I say corrupt here, I do not necessarily mean things like bribery, brutality and self dealing (though to be sure these are widely present). Corruption at its most fundamental is the simple consequence of time and entropy working at things. An old rubber hose left out in the sun becomes corrupt and unable to hold water. Our vascular system becomes caked with plaque. Our institutions become self-serving, bloated, out of touch, and inhumane. Time is corrosive and the forces that tend to push all institutions into corruption have been hard at work across every aspect of our social field for decades.</p><p>At the same time, the context in which those institutions were born is also far in our past. Both the problems and possibilities of 2020 are very different to those of 1960. What was a good car, phone or computer in 1960 is now a relic. Our social institutions are likewise relics of a past remembered by only the eldest among us. Designed by and for a different age.</p><p>It is not stretching the truth to say that <em>effectively all</em> of our social institutions are a bad combination of corrupt and obsolete. Our education system. Our healthcare system. Our food production systems. Our banking and finance systems. Our journalism and science systems. Our political systems.</p><p>They are all beyond the pale and they all should be defunded and redesigned.</p><h4>Moving to Local Experimentation</h4><p>One extremely good aspect of “defund the police” is that it appears to be substantially increasing the consciousness of what should be (and to a significant extent used to be) a strength of the United States: different approaches for different people in different places. The key principle here is called “subsidiarity”.</p><blockquote>Subsidiarity is a principle of social organization that holds that social and political issues should be dealt with at the most immediate level that is consistent with their resolution. The Oxford English Dictionary defines subsidiarity as “the principle that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed at a more local level”.</blockquote><p>Minneapolis can experiment with one model of policing and Atlanta and Dallas and Salt Lake City can experiment with others. This is a really healthy approach. First, we know that what works in one place (like pine trees growing in the mountains) might not work in another place (like the desert). Second, when it comes to things as complex as human society, we should always proceed with humility. We really don’t know how our best intentions will actually play out. Often the only way to learn is to try different approaches and then try and select the best while pruning away the worst.</p><p>This approach seems likely to be the de facto one used around policing in our near future. With luck this same principle will be applied across the social field. Schooling and healthcare and food and banking could and should all benefit from having as much responsibility held “at the edge” and only (carefully) managed at a higher level when it is strictly necessary to do so.</p><h4>Thinking about whole systems</h4><p>The primary risk that I see in the defund the police movement is that it (might) fail to take into consideration the intrinsic complexity of human systems. For example, one risk might be the naive notion that the right thing to do is to take money from police budgets and to (simply) move it into places like education and healthcare.</p><p>From my point of view, this is an error for two reasons.</p><p>1. The education and healthcare systems are just as broken as the policing system. Moving dimes from one broken place to another isn’t going to do much good.</p><p>2. The problem isn’t really that much about funding — the problem is that the institutions are corrupt and obsolete. On the one hand, taking money from the policing system doesn’t really address the deep question of how we might really go about radically upgrading the presence of lived justice. On the other hand, giving money to the education system doesn’t really address the deep question of how we might go about radically upgrading how we support healthy human development.</p><p>If we are going to do this, we should really try to do it well. Human systems are intrinsically whole systems and need to be taken as wholes. The effort to redesign policing should be an effort to really rethink (and re-live) our whole set of institutions. Unfortunately, failure to do so might actually lead to more harm than good as the unintended consequences of the choices we are making in one aspect of the system (e.g., policing) cascade throughout other aspects of the system (e.g., school or healthcare or . . . ).</p><h4>A modest proposal</h4><p>We are at one of those “big shift” points that seems to come around every few generations. The New Deal, Reconstruction and the Constitution happened back then and something of roughly equivalent magnitude wants and needs to happen now.</p><p>If we continue to move forward with can-kicking, partial solutions, we are likely to just continue to experience pain and destruction. The whole system is corrupt and obsolete. Therefore the whole system needs to be replaced. Not burnt down, but carefully and thoughtfully replaced. Redesigned. Regenerated. Local and wholesome.</p><p>Sound like a challenge? It will be. But while things like social media and smart phones can seem terrible (and in many ways they are), they also give rise to incredible potentials for coordination and auto-poesis. Simply put, we have largely been coasting on the work of our ancestors and we do not really know of what we are capable. Its high time for Generations X, Y and Z to step up and take responsibility. I think we are more than capable of this challenge.</p><p>So I suggest we begin. And if it is going to begin with the local experimentation around policing, so be it. But don’t stop there. This decade can, should, and, I think, must be one of the most creative, generative and optimistic ones in human history.</p><h4>Proposed principles for big change</h4><p>Below is the set of principles that I have collected around this purpose. It is unlikely that this collection is complete, but I hope (and imagine) that it could prove useful.</p><p><strong>The Principle of Choice</strong>. Designs should be oriented towards increasing the capacity for choice and building on top of that increasing capacity.</p><p><strong>The Principle of Wholeness</strong>. Designs should be mindful of creating and working with well integrated wholes.</p><p><strong>The Principle of Relationship</strong>. Designs should endeavor to place responsibility on real human relationships and endeavor to support the construction of strong, trusted relationships and infrastructure around relationships.</p><p><strong>Principle of Development. </strong>Designs should strive to build capacity from the ground up, rather than over-ride failures at the ground level with top-down capacity. Make people more capable of being responsible, rather than taking their responsibility away. Build structures at the human scale that can carry more responsibility, etc.</p><p><strong>The Principle of Subsidiarity</strong>. Designs should push as much responsibility and authority at the most immediate level that is consistent with their resolution.</p><p><strong>Principle of Unbundling</strong>. Designs should take care that no choice should be bound to any other choice, unless this binding is strictly required by the nature of the choice itself.</p><p><strong>Principle of Rights and Responsibilities</strong>. Designs should make rights symmetric with responsibilities. (e.g., the right to free speech should be replaced by the the right and responsibility of meaningful communication; the right to private property should be replaced with the right and responsibility of stewardship of property).</p><p><strong>The Principle of Fiduciary Responsibility</strong>. Designs should ensure that whenever a relationship is highly asymmetric (e.g. when AI is on one side of a relationship and not the other) that the relationship be returned to symmetry by establishing a fiduciary responsibility on the part of the stronger party.</p><p><strong>The Principle of Network Optimization for Collective Intelligence</strong>. Designs should strive to always promote the evolution of the human social network towards increasing collective intelligence. For example:<br>- All nodes (people, families, communities, etc.) should be resourced so as to provide minimum viable signal.<br>- Each node should be able to refuse an offered transaction without fear of privation.<br>- The generator functions of network topology should balance efficiency and resilience.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1b9d674a45d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/defund-and-redesign-everything-d1b9d674a45d">Defund (and redesign) everything.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Situational Assessment: Right Now]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/situational-assessment-right-now-7d9856b562f5?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d9856b562f5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[corona]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Mar 2020 17:47:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-15T20:50:13.191Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/1*x6y1LH1D5ONqwfIO8lP3Vw.jpeg" /></figure><p>[3.15.20]</p><p>The story of the unfolding meta-crisis that we have been watching for the last decade has become enormously more salient over the past few weeks. This is a moment of major risk along many different fronts. It is also a moment of singular opportunity.</p><p>Foremost among them is to learn.</p><p>The Deep Code hypothesis has been that the dynamic attractor of our current civilization (the set of institutions, structures, ideas, habits and feedback loops that keep things hanging together) is in the process of evaporation. Like a tornado that is turning back into wind.</p><p>At the same time, a new dynamic attractor is in the process of formation. We are in the middle of a Great Transition from one attractor to another. Meta-systemic dynamics like the 2008 Financial Crisis (and its child the European Debt Crisis), Brexit, the 2016 election and the present Covid-19 crisis are all examples of and symptoms of that Transition.</p><p>We may or may not manage to navigate the journey, but the journey is underway nonetheless.</p><p>The present crisis is significant. It is also only an example of more to come. We need to navigate this one and learn how to become exquisite at navigating this entire class of events.</p><h4>I. Major Threat Vectors.</h4><p>Let’s begin by looking at what are some of the major threat vectors in the unfolding meta-crisis right now. This is useful both for focusing attention on points of high risk as well as for getting a better sense of how meta-systemic dynamics implicate and intensify risks across systems. Note in particular, how all of the below feed-back on each other.</p><p><strong>Medical System Overwhelm</strong>. When the number of patients needing beds exceeds the number of beds (ventilators, doctors, etc), all harm metrics shift significantly to the worse and you get spillover effects into everything else that the medical system is otherwise managing (e.g., car wreck victims don’t have ER or ICU). Estimated time of arrival: this threat is happening now and is expanding quickly in both breadth (number of locations worldwide) and intensity.</p><p>Note that this risk occurs at hierarchical levels of organization. One hospital might be overwhelmed but the City it is in might not. Wuhan was overwhelmed, but China as a whole was not. Northern Italy was overwhelmed, but at least as of this writing, the EU was not. This allows portable resources to flow from the larger context into areas of local overwhelm. If we cross the point of <em>global</em> medical overwhelm, that will be a worrying development.</p><p><strong>Resource depletion</strong>. Panic buying (resource allocation issues) combined with shut down supply chains (quarantine) can lead to real or perceived threat (e.g., lack of food). This can lead to crime, escalating to civic unrest and beyond. ETA — two weeks. If supply chain / access disruption continues past three weeks this threat begins to move into the red.</p><p><strong>Cash depletion</strong>. 70% of the U.S. population lives paycheck to paycheck. Many will see income drop over the next few days (in many cases to zero), particularly in any sort of quarantine environment. If the disruption lasts four weeks (and certainly by six weeks) you will have tens of millions of people who can’t get access to resources even if the resources are otherwise available. [Special note — different resources are different. Rent and mortgage are subtle and important case likely requiring different approaches than food. Power, water, internet as well.] This cascades both into civil unrest and into deeper, longer term economic harm.</p><p>Note. Civil unrest here does not necessarily mean looting. A well organized “rent / mortgage” strike is a perfectly plausible (and possibly necessary) event. This will move cash depletion risk into financial system risk. Be careful lest the cure is also the poison.</p><p><strong>Supply chain overwhelm</strong>. A mix of these systemic dynamics put pressure on supply chains. The medical risk (for example) could weaken sensitive areas — either directly or indirectly. Grocery chains closing to protect their workers might exacerbate resource depletion issues as would truck drivers getting sick or choosing to socially distance. This threat area includes physical infrastructure (i.e., utilities). Normal interruptions of service might take longer to repair — and potentially much larger than normal use of services might overwhelm infrastructure.</p><p><strong>Civic infrastructure overwhelm</strong>. Reduction in capacity of police, EMS, fire leads to increasing gaps in civic infrastructure. More narrowly, prisons and the homeless are two major areas of concern. As effected populations, as vectors and as systemic risk accelerators. I am currently not aware of any coherent proposals to these two areas of risk.</p><p><strong>Pile-on and copycat events</strong>. Anyone who has been thinking about dropping an asymmetric attack (particularly biowarfare and cyberwarfare) might see this as a high leverage moment. Nature hitting us with another crisis (flood, fire, etc.) is part of this threat category.</p><p><strong>Continuity of governance</strong>. Iran has seen this. The relative balkanization and immaturity of the leadership system in the West (who have for the past decade preferred to squabble in inter-elite competition and virtue signaling) means that even small numbers of specific people getting sick could significantly reduce already contingent sense/choicemaking as the precarious balance of coordination devolves into power grabs.</p><p><strong>Financial System Collapse</strong>. 2008–2015 were never really healed and the global financial system is enormously fragile. The real economic effects of both the virus and the cure (e.g., quarantine) could push a number of fragile financial systems into collapse, potentially triggering a systemic collapse globally. Breakdown of global coordination capability since 2008 likely leads to substantially less effective collective response. Potential downward spiral.</p><p><strong>Authoritarianism</strong>. It is quite likely that a very significant and novel (to our experience) level of authoritarianism will be requested (‘required’) to address the many different aspects of the meta-crisis. Enforced quarantine is one obvious example. This creates a threat of both intentional/strategic (‘bad buy’) and unintentional/systemic transition into a significant (permanent) increase in authoritarianism at the political level across many different dimensions. As we have seen with 9/11 (Patriot Act) these things have a habit of becoming habit.</p><p><strong>Multi-Polar Traps [Political]</strong>. If Culture War 2.0 continues unabated amidst the meta-crisis a number of downward spirals can ensue. For example, a viral containment strategy that involves shutting down elections could (easily) be read as a politically motivated move and lead to a civil disobedience reaction. This, in turn, could ‘justify’ harder authoritarian means to enforce quarantine.</p><p><strong>Multi-Polar Traps [Geopolitical]</strong>. Crisis creates opportunity. Go players everywhere are looking to see how much of the board they can turn their color. Two primary risks: (1) Ordinary geopolitical strategic maneuvering might exacerbate or overwhelm systems in any / all of the above dynamics; (2) Geopolitical maneuvering might escalate out of control. The Saudi/Russia squabble that led to the oil crash might be seen as an example that certainly didn’t reduce the burden on the global financial system.</p><p><strong>Super-fragility [Whole]</strong>. A crucial insight is that the operating logic of our current civilization has been to trade resilience for efficiency (creating fragility). From childcare, family, education and mental health, to supply chains for food, water, material and medicine (watch out for depletion of psychmeds), we’ve been optimizing everything to their limits for half a century. This generates short term profits and long term risk.</p><p>The current situation is pushing on effectively all systems. Many of the vital systems of our civilization are at or near critical points and as the meta-crisis unfolds, small (ordinary) perturbations could break some or the many of these fragile systems. For example, while it might seem relatively trivial right now, large scale school closures and a massive shift to tele-work will not be without durable (and in many ways surprising) consequence.</p><h4>II. Opportunity</h4><p><strong>Learning.</strong> As mentioned at the top, this event provides a uniquely rich and salient opportunity for learning. We are all of us right now faced with making meaningful choices in the context of uncertainty. Did you buy food two weeks ago? Well, for good or for bad, the real situation has changed for millions of store shelves. Choices have real consequences.</p><p>Moreover, many of us are making choices in the context of competing ideological worldviews (see <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/on-thinking-and-simulated-thinking-5e434e92cf86">Thinking</a>). Is it “just the flu”? We are about to find out in a very real way.</p><p>Finally, we are now faced with increasingly intense consequences under growing complexity. And the dawning reality that the governance structures (see <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/understanding-the-blue-church-e4781b2bd9b5">Blue Church</a>) that have been making our choices for us for the past 70 years are not well designed to address these kinds of problems.</p><p>So what do we get to / need to learn?</p><p><em>Systemic Fragility</em>. Trading fragility for efficiency is a bad trade. It works great in the short term but will always collect in the end. We need to learn this lesson to the level that creates durable cultural habits like saying “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_bless_you#cite_note-Whiting1977-8">bless you</a>” when someone sneezes. It is possible to have <em>both</em> abundance <em>and</em> anti-fragility. Hopefully this year we will begin to learn how to get there.</p><p><em>Decentralized Sensemaking. </em>Many, <a href="https://twitter.com/johnrobb">John Robb</a> foremost among them, have noticed that networks have done a vastly better job of making sense of the unfolding meta-crisis than official channels (e.g, the “main stream media”). This isn’t surprising: those legacy channels simply weren’t cut out for this kind of event at their best — and they are very far from their best. The days of the Blue Church are in the rearview. At the same time, we are still in the early adolescence of decentralized sensemaking. There is an enormous potential here waiting to be realized.</p><p><em>Decentralized Agency</em>. Our legacy institutions are, for the most part, doing their level best to serve us. And in many cases they are succeeding. But as we saw in 2008, both the wisdom and integrity of their choices can often leave much room for improvement. The current crisis is much more complex and is unfolding quickly. We have now both an opportunity and, plausibly, necessity to upgrade our collective decentralized agency and to solve problems together.</p><p>The scope of our decentralized agentic capacity is enormous. Remember, at the base, all agency is grounded in individual people making their own choices. The more we learn how to quickly use our capacity for communicating with nearly anyone in the world in multiple modalities (text, audio, video, symmetric, asymmetric) to orient our attention to the right information, people and projects and then to support coordinated action, the more we can move that agency from the old 20th Century hierarchical bureaucracies that currently run the world to much more flexible, adaptive, nuanced and intelligent 21st Century “self-organizing collective intelligences” (SOCI) that can fully respond to meta-systemic dynamics.</p><p>How do we do this?</p><p><strong>Theory First</strong><br>In some sense, the path forward is surprisingly simple. Six Steps:</p><ol><li>Upgrade your Sovereignty. Increase your ability to make effective choices under a larger diversity and intensity of contexts. There is a lot of room between panic and denial. In the future, everyone counts and has to be able to take responsibility.</li><li>Upgrade your Discernment. Increase your ability to separate signal from noise. In particular, the noise of your own biases and projections. Learn to deal with reality before reality deals with you.</li></ol><p>3. Upgrade your Integrity.</p><p><a href="https://www.facebook.com/notes/yasuhiko-genku-kimura/to-be-a-leader/10156853666659856/">Yasuhiko Kimura</a>:</p><blockquote>The Japanese word “<em>toku </em>(徳)” (<em>teh </em>in Chinese), which is usually translated as “virtue,” also means “power” or “integrity.” <em>Toku</em> is the consciousness of the whole that makes your life coherent, consistent, and integral. Therefore, <em>toku</em> is integrity, and <em>toku </em>is also power because through <em>toku</em> your vision, action, and result become coherent and consistent. Success in life and business requires power to make your vision realized through action. Success thus requires integrity in the sense of <em>toku</em>.</blockquote><blockquote>The English term “integrity” is defined on three levels: (1) being true to your principles; (2) being true to your word or commitment; and (3) being true to your self. Integrity means being true to your principle, your word, and your self, and total integrity involves a total accord between these three levels of being true.</blockquote><blockquote>Men and women of integrity who have the power to sustain their commitment through to the end and achieve their objectives, sometime against all odds, are those in whom their principle, commitment, and self are all in accord. For we can sustain our commitment only when it is one that is in accord with our authentic self and with our deepest values and principles.</blockquote><p>4. Subject to your own Integrity, support others in their Sovereignty, Discernment and Integrity.</p><p>5. Orient your own and others attention to those who have shown (to your Discernment) the most Sovereignty, Discernment and Integrity and the most capacity in supporting others therein.</p><p>6. Build individual and collective skillfullness in all of these things. Note that this definitely includes building physical infrastructure like communications platforms, new economic models, etc. But the infrastructure must always follow and support human capacity and can never replace nor inhibit human development. Wisdom must precede power.</p><p><strong>From Theory To Practice</strong></p><p>Practical realtime solutions are being worked on by tends of thousands of people right now. First order is to try and point the right people to the right problems, then to point the right people to the right developing solutions, then to orient everyone to the resources they need.</p><p>Examples include <a href="http://germinfo.com">germinfo.com</a> and <a href="https://coronavirustechhandbook.com/?fbclid=IwAR2qbOgr057uFZ0KVJl2qhK_zQYLmQGc79O9q4mVWyh0jnFpt-vCQkSOS2o">The Coronavirus Tech Handbook</a>. Good solid projects that are entirely self-organized and providing significant value.</p><p>But there are also people like <a href="http://www.nanobiosym.com/our-team/">Dr. Anita Goel</a> whose team at Nanobiosym have highly innovative science and technology ready to bring to the crisis. Their Gene Radar diagnostics could <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&amp;v=rTZBmkvBbB0&amp;feature=emb_logo">potentially change the game</a> for C-19 (and all other future viruses). Does this kind of potential find its way to the front via legacy institutions, or emergent institutions come to the fore to save the day? Or do we drop the ball altogether? Time will tell. This is a moment of significant risk and opportunity.</p><p>These are just a few of the projects that I am personally aware of. There are many others and will be more on a daily basis. I’ll update this document as more structure emerges to share.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d9856b562f5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/situational-assessment-right-now-7d9856b562f5">Situational Assessment: Right Now</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The War on Sensemaking]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/the-war-on-sensemaking-900086bca636?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/900086bca636</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sensemaking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[syria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collective-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Sep 2019 23:05:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-15T17:11:41.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VOWHyoei6hGVIP2pE5JE2w.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’d like to propose that we are <em>already</em> fighting World War III. We are not merely getting perilously close or or waiting for the other shoe to drop. We are in it. We are in fact neck deep in the next “War to End All Wars.”</p><p>Allow me to explain.</p><p>In 1740, Jacob Dickert began experimenting with a long barreled musket with a groove in the barrel. They called this new innovation a “rifle”. Thus began the last war.</p><p>This war unfolded over centuries and phases, but was fundamentally about the deliberate and strategic use of industrializing technology to deliver escalating levels of destructive energy. Power during this era most certainly came from the barrel of a gun and the alliance between technology and industry proceeded from battle to battle to move us progressively higher and higher on the ladder of destruction. Until at Hiroshima we reached the final level and the beginning of the end of the last war.</p><p>In 1917, a young <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays">Edward Bernays</a> was asked to help the American war effort by applying his uncle Sigmund Freud’s theories of the unconscious to a new German technique called “propaganda”. Thus began the current war.</p><p>While we continued to fight the last war in trenches and hedgerows, a new form of war was developing <em>in medias res</em>. This war wasn’t one about destructive force in the energetic sense. This war was fought on an entirely different battlefield — sense and meaning. Guns, germs and steel began to give way to spies, lies, distraction and seduction.</p><p>By the 1970’s it was clear to anyone who was watching that the old way of waging war was over. It mattered little how many bombs were dropped on Vietnam. The real war was to be found in the battle for hearts and minds.</p><p>The technology of war moves quickly. In the span of one and a half centuries, the last war leapt from long rifles to repeating rifles to gatling guns all the way to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Boy">Little Boy</a>. The warfighters of the current war haven’t dawdled. The wars of culture, meaning and purpose have seen innovation on an “exponential technology curve.” The artisanal efforts of Bernays and Goebbels have been left far in the past by modern methods. Consider: concepts like “false flag” and “deep state” are now part of common vocabulary. Everyone is familiar with confirmation bias and psyops. We are all <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Jesus_Angleton">James Jesus Angleton</a> now.</p><p>By my estimation we are getting rather close to the Hiroshima of the current war. Perhaps we are in the moral equivalent of trench warfare, perhaps we are storming the beaches of Normandy. It’s hard to say. After all, the main thrust of the current war is that making any sense at all is getting harder and harder.</p><p>Take a look at Syria [2020 update — replace Syria with Coronavirus]. What exactly is happening? With just a little bit of looking, I’ve found at least six radically different and plausible narratives:</p><ul><li>Assad used poison gas on his people and the United States bombed his airbase in a measured response.</li><li>Assad attacked a rebel base that was unexpectedly storing poison gas and Trump bombed his airbase for political reasons.</li><li>The Deep State in the United States is responsible for a “false flag” use of poison gas in order to undermine the Trump Insurgency.</li><li>The Russians are responsible for a “false flag” use of poison gas in order to undermine the Deep State.</li><li>Putin and Trump collaborated on a “false flag” in order to distract from “Russiagate.”</li><li>Someone else (China? Israel? Iran?) is responsible for a “false flag” for purposes unknown.</li></ul><p>And, just to make sure we really grasp the level of non-sense:</p><ul><li>There was no poison gas attack, the “white helmets” are fake news for purposes unknown and everyone who is in a position to know is spinning their own version of events for their own purposes.</li></ul><p>Think this last one is implausible? Are you sure? Are you sure you know the current limits of the war on sensemaking? Of sock puppets and cognitive hacking and weaponized memetics?</p><p>All I am certain of about Syria is that I really have no fucking idea what is going on. And that this state of affairs — this increasingly generalized condition of complete disorientation — is untenable.</p><p>By the end of the last war, the world found itself face-to-face with the sobering realization that continuing progress in the art of killing had reached a terminal point. We had become so good at destruction that unless we were very, very careful, we would end up killing everyone.</p><p>If anything, the current war is even more dangerous. As our ability to make shared sense evaporates and as meaning and purpose are fragmented into so many shards, it becomes increasingly difficult to make good choices. In fact, it becomes increasingly difficult to even want to make good choices.</p><p>I suspect that we have a little ways to go. We have not yet hit “rock bottom.” But I hope that soon there will be a deeply shared acceptance that none of our current institutions are trust-worthy and a deeply shared conviction that we can and must (re)build trust ourselves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=900086bca636" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/the-war-on-sensemaking-900086bca636">The War on Sensemaking</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Situational Assessment 2019: AOC Edition]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/situational-assessment-2019-aoc-edition-b6e31897f35c?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6e31897f35c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Jan 2019 23:57:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-22T16:20:02.012Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/1*x6y1LH1D5ONqwfIO8lP3Vw.jpeg" /></figure><p>This post will be an extension and update to the model first shared in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/situational-assessment-2017-trump-edition-d189d24fc046">Situational Assessment: 2017</a>. Some familiarity with the concepts developed therein and continued in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/situational-assessment-2018-the-calm-before-the-storm-5a0bd014ec84">Situational Assessment: 2018</a> will be assumed. If you have not read those two posts, it will likely be useful to do so. As was noted in the past, please take this effort as a <em>lens</em> — not as an effort to tell the whole story. It is only one of many lenses, indeed, only one of the many lenses that I, myself<em>, </em>use to make sense of the world. It is not and cannot be complete nor meaningfully nuanced. If it is useful, it has done its job.</p><p>Before we dive in, it is important to keep the broader view. The last two posts focused on politics, particularly American politics. To be sure, the events of 2016 pushed politics to the front of the stage. But, to my view, politics are only an epiphenomenon of the much larger <a href="https://medium.com/emergent-culture/the-coming-great-transition-e50d62da77d4">Great Transition</a> that is continuing to move through the world. We should always be mindful of the bigger picture.</p><p>For example, another epiphenomenon (closely tied to politics) is finance. Since 2008, global finance has developed into the most expansive and fragile macro bubble that perhaps has ever existed. In 2015 it seemed (to me at least) that the popping of this bubble (temporarily held at bay by debt) was imminent. Instead the story moved “down” into the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNa8IIz3Kw8&amp;t=1s">political and thence into the cultural layers</a> and we watched fragility spread from finance into the whole of the human world.</p><p>It is now beginning to look like the financial layer is once again showing signs of significant risk. Wisdom would counsel keeping eyes as firmly on the financial and economic story this year as on the political-cultural story.</p><p>Moreover, of course, it is my considered perspective that the <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/foundational-assumptions-e81b5b55e3ff">scope of the bigger picture is enormous</a> and that the proper response is to <a href="https://medium.com/emergent-culture/we-interrupt-this-program-75214813bb54">interrupt the program</a> entirely; return to <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/on-thinking-and-simulated-thinking-5e434e92cf86">thinking</a> and (using <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/infinitesimal-courage-947f074d09f8">infinitesimal courage</a>) remember your own <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/on-jordan-peterson-and-the-future-51402a370d79">sovereignty</a>. This is certainly where I am turning all of my attention. More on this at the very end.</p><p>In the meantime, most of the energy and attention of the world is still captured by the spectacle. And so, let us peer into the abyss.</p><p>Over the past two years, we have examined the current political situation as developing along four different “fronts” in a new and important kind of war:</p><blockquote>In other words, while 2016 still formally looked like politics, what is really going on here is a revolutionary war. For now this is war using memes rather than bullets, but war is much more than a metaphor.</blockquote><blockquote>This war is about much more than ideology, money or power. Even the participants likely do not fully understand the stakes. At a deep level, we are right in the middle of an existential conflict between two entirely different and incompatible ways of forming “collective intelligence”. This is a deep point and will likely be confusing. So I’m going to take it slow and below will walk through a series of “fronts” of the war that I see playing out over the next several years. This is a pretty tactical assessment and should make sense and be useful to anyone. I’ll get to the deep point last — and will be going way out there in an effort to grasp “what is really going on”.</blockquote><p>From my perspective, the true center of this war is between different forms of collective intelligence. The 2016 election served as a notable inflection point in the conflict and, therefore, one might take the Trump Administration as the source and driver of the decentralized collective intelligence that John Robb called “the Insurgency”.</p><p>My sense is that the reality is precisely the other way around: decentralized collective intelligence is fundamental and, broadly speaking, not intrinsically aligned with any given policy or political philosophy. The Trump election was only an early example of something on the surface riding an upwelling from the depths.</p><p>As will be discussed below, in 2018, we began to see more examples of decentralized collective intelligence breaking through. Some, like #resist, represent a very different source and form than the Insurgency.</p><p>The four fronts of the war continue to command attention — but now the struggle is beginning to shift to its more dynamic phase. The Blue Church is breaking down. Increasingly, the story is less about the fight between the Insurgency and the Church and more about the efforts of decentralized collective intelligence to come into increasing levels of coherence and power and, ultimately, the struggles <em>between</em> these forms of collective intelligence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*81lDPbNMNFR5B-APPmWFoQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Front One: Communications Infrastructure.</h3><p>The first thesis is that we are witnessing a transition from one media infrastructure (broadcast and, specifically, television media) to another media infrastructure (decentralized and interactive digital media); and that this shift is driving a fundamental change in the very nature of how we go about forming effective “collective intelligence.”</p><p>For a deeper dive into the kind of collective intelligence optimized for broadcast-type media, you can take a look at <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/understanding-the-blue-church-e4781b2bd9b5">Understanding the Blue Church</a>.</p><p>From my perspective, 2018 was the year that the Blue Church died and that the center moved from the establishment mass media to the emergent new media.</p><p>Of course, sprawling events like the Blue Church die slowly and we should expect to see it continuing to impact the world for several years to come, particularly at the level of legacy institutional power. In 2018, it was able to eke out a barely acceptable level of performance in the mid-terms, although I expect that the bias towards the House and away from the Senate speaks precisely to the shift of power in Blue away from the Church and towards something new — but more on that later.</p><p>I would like to suggest that the events of the Ford/Kavanaugh complex represented the formal end of the era of the Blue Church the beginning of the interregnum.</p><p>During the confirmation hearing and subsequent vote on Supreme Court nominee Bret Kavanaugh, the leadership of the Democratic party made what I would consider to be a classic error. Understanding the importance of a Supreme Court seat in the larger political conflict, and exhausting their total portfolio of maneuvers to stop the Kavanaugh nomination, they activated the #resist collective intelligence.</p><p>Perhaps they believed that they could use and control #resist to their own ends. More likely, they weren’t meaningfully aware of what was really happening. In any event, they woke the dragon. And for the next two plus weeks, the American Zeitgeist exploded in a decentralized culture war between the Insurgency and #resist.</p><p>While the end result was ultimately cranked out through the usual turnings of the bureaucratic political sausage machine, the deep story is that during that entire time, the Establishment was <strong>completely out of control</strong>. They could not shape or frame the narrative and could barely keep up with reporting on it. Instead, the essential power of the frame had shifted from broadcast-type media to decentralized-type media.</p><p>It is my expectation that this is a one-way trip and, accordingly, the future will look less and less like Walter Cronkite and more and more like . . . ? Well, we don’t quite know how these new forms of collective intelligence will show up. But we are starting to get a sense. For example, in 2018 we were able to observe two major emergences of the type: the “Intellectual Dark Web” and “QAnon.”</p><p>While these two forms of decentralized collective intelligence are, of course, very different, I would suggest that they are on the same fundamental continuum. In both the Intellectual Dark Web and QAnon we are witnessing (and, perhaps actively participating in) decentralized collective intelligence undertaking the slow process of (re)membering the Logos.</p><p><strong>The Intellectual Dark Web</strong></p><p>Last year, in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/on-jordan-peterson-and-the-future-51402a370d79">On Sovereignty</a>, I suggested that 2018 might well be known as the year of Jordan Peterson. This seems to have been a fair assessment. For a solid part of the year, an all out firefight was being waged between the establishment mass media and the emerging collective intelligence (of which Peterson was a major part) that came to call itself the <a href="https://youtu.be/QOBa9sRn2zE">Intellectual Dark Web</a>.</p><p>By now the conflict has settled with the IDW as the clear victor. While the establishment mass media is now beginning its (slow?) slide into irrelevancy, the IDW is turning its attention inward: what, precisely, is going on here?</p><p>For now, this loose collection of thinkers is self-identifying as an emergent re-discovery of “how to have a good conversation.” As the ethos spreads, I expect that it will become increasingly embodied in a collective intelligence of both vast scale and significant variation. For what it is worth, my sense is that the next major threshold in the development of the IDW as collective intelligence is when their intention turns from ‘good’ conversation to ‘meaningful’ conversation.</p><p><strong>Making Sense of QAnon</strong></p><p>For many reasons, QAnon is much harder to make sense of and, indeed, in 2018, I put time into an <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/making-sense-of-qanon-220966667e8d">entire post on the subject</a>. It is a 16 minute read and for a deeper drive, you’ll need to spend that time. But the essence of the story is this: QAnon is an example of an decentralized collective intelligence endeavoring to “boil up” out of non-sense into sensemaking.</p><p>While we can see the character “Q” as the centralizing attractor of this event, from my perspective, it is both more true and more interesting to observe the coalescence of a global and enormously decentralized collective intelligence around the “transcendent attractor” of QAnon. If you watched slowly and carefully throughout 2018, you had a chance to witness the birth process of a decentralized collective intelligence in real time.</p><p>If you’ve ever watched a new born infant flailing and jerking while trying to pull her freshly minted body together in the context of the blooming buzzing confusion of life, you have a pretty good sense it. This a bottoms-up, evolutionary phenomenon, and, unlike the IDW that is starting from the legible frame of “rebel public intellectuals in conversation,” QAnon is coming into coherence directly from chaos. Expect it to proceed by punctuated equilibrium — almost certainly branching and mutating into entire different locations and sub-communities.</p><p>Again, my perspective is that the IDW and QAnon represent different aspects of the same story: decentralized collective intelligence crossing the adaptive valley to a new form of sensemaking. If you want to try your hand at decentralized collective intelligence on “hard mode,” start participating in the conversations in and around the IDW. Care to dive directly into “insane mode?” Wade in the Chans and “lurk moar.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/732/1*IQC81dkNH71Ed0yEZlzFQQ.png" /></figure><h3>Front Two: The Deep State</h3><p>The second front focused on the “Deep State” and its role as “primary antagonist” for the Insurgency.</p><p>Ah the Deep State. Can we still recall only a few years ago when the notion ‘Deep State’ was to be found only among a fringe of policy wonks and conspiracy types? These days it is as familiar as the Kardashians and anyone who has been following the various ebbs and flows of the Mueller Investigation has been ogling its inner workings.</p><p>From our current perspective, we might imagine the Deep State as representing the last great Roman legions struggling to maintain the Empire in the face of the surging barbarian hordes. Is Mueller a contemporary Flavius Aetius? Time will tell.</p><p>At one level, this front appears to have settled into a sort of trench warfare around the Mueller Investigation. Depending on which flavor of kool aid you prefer, the investigation is either going break into a Trump impeachment any day now, or is going to collapse into an exposed (and foiled) coup d’Etat. My sense is that neither is true and, more to the point, that this particular location isn’t actually where the action is at all.</p><p>To my mind, the Mueller Investigation is an example of where the Deep State is able to grasp an aspect of the Insurgency (the Trump Administration) that is legible to old fashioned Deep State power. And, like <a href="https://youtu.be/ZdzCb_hjoTY?t=136">Arnold blasting away at the T-1000</a>, the Deep State is making the mistake of thinking that a well placed headshot will kill the Insurgency. If my read is correct, this might temporarily slow the Insurgency down, but, ultimately, will simply cause it to evolve at a more robust pace. This entire approach continues to represent the “last war”.</p><p>By contrast, I propose that the real action of 2018 and now into the future is already taking place on a very different stage: the Big Tech platforms.</p><p>From last year’s post:</p><blockquote>[I]t appears that there is now a decisive line connecting both Front One and Front Two: the major Internet media platforms (Google, Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, etc.). While the decentralized nature of the Internet renders it more naturally in alignment with the strategic mode of the Insurgency, the “network effects” of Platforms appears to be a natural characteristic of the terrain that is fully available to the modes of the Church (islands of stability and control). . . In other words, “the Battle for Television is over; the Battle for the Internet is begun.</blockquote><p>Boy did 2018 light up the Battle for the Internet. We saw Facebook reel from backlash surrounding its role in the 2016 election and then begin to endeavor to control the narrative that can flow across its platform at an algorithmic level. We saw Twitter begin to actively prune accounts based on speech-indexed heuristics and YouTube paying much closer attention to which video channels could monetize advertising.</p><p>More recently, we’ve now seen concerted action across multiple platforms (including payment services like Patreon and Paypal) to MOAB nodes of the Insurgency. The first strikes were at Milo Yiannopoulos and at Alex Jones whose Infowars had been making a somewhat surprising meteoric rise from 2016 through to the Ford/Kavanaugh complex. For a while, this new strategy pushed into the Insurgency with only superficial resistance.</p><p>All of this seems relatively predictable. The Deep State is optimized to fight in the “jungle” (relatively stable and centralized power structures and media landscapes) while the Insurgency is optimized for “desert warfare” (rapidly changing fluid decentralized landscapes). In this context, the dynamic of “network effects,” where the simple fact of having a large number of users makes your platform more attractive to more users in a self-reinforcing positive feedback loop, generates Big Tech platforms. Islands of stability and control on the otherwise fluid territory of the Internet.</p><p><em>Of course</em>, the conflict would move to this frontier where desert and jungle meet.</p><p>But, when Sargon of Akkad, a YouTuber who rose to fame during #gamergate with his criticisms of PC culture, was unilaterally removed from Patreon, a new line was drawn. Within minutes, the story was spreading across social media (most notably Twitter) and within days, Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson (two members of the IDW with large and highly attached followings) began the process of pushing back, ultimately announcing plans to leave Patreon and to create a new, competitive, platform.</p><p>Here we are seeing the real shift in the conflict. The IDW is an example of the broader decentralized collective intelligence that is not, strictly speaking, part of the Insurgency. The spread of the war is beginning to shift the forces at play. From Deep State vs. Trump Insurgency to the entire broadcast type collective intelligence of the Blue Church against some “rebel alliance Insurgency” that includes a loosely coordinated array of decentralized-type collective intelligences.</p><p>If we stay focused at this level, the conflict is not about politics, money or power in any ordinary sense. Rather, it is about a struggle to control the shape of the territory itself.</p><p>Simply put, to the degree that the decentralized forces are able to (<a href="https://epicbaz.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/nomadology_read1.pdf">as Deleuze would say</a>) “smooth” the space of the Internet and remove or bypass islands of centralization, they will have the advantage. To the degree that the broadcast forces are able to “striate” the Internet and “recentralize” it, they will have the advantage.</p><p>From the point of view of this new and broader Insurgency, Patreon is a soft target. We might say that it is very much on the border between desert and jungle. The tech is easy to replicate and while it has some “critical mass network effect,” the ability to shift energy away to a new platform is relatively easy (Harris and Peterson by themselves might represent critical mass for a new platform).</p><p>As we move farther from the frontier of the desert, however, the targets get substantially more challenging. Paypal, Reddit, Twitter and then, ultimately, the redoubts of YouTube and Facebook are vastly harder targets at both a technical and a “network effects” level.</p><p>It remains to be seen whether the new Insurgency can coordinate an effective way to move “up the stack”. Clearly Peterson and Harris, by themselves, have nowhere near the capacity to do so, but we might imagine how some alliance consisting of various “nodes of conversation” (including, but not limited to, the IDW) and self-actuating technical resources like the folks over at the blockchain (still mired in their winter of chasm crossing) <em>might</em> coordinate into a new level of decentralized power.</p><p>Perhaps. However, here we should go deeper. While surface conflicts like that between the IDW and Patreon are one aspect of the conflict, I would like to suggest that that true depths of the decentralized War Machine lie elsewhere. Again, the “world historic aspects of this war show up in the exploration of different forms of collective intelligence and power in the emerging landscape”.</p><p>If you want to really understand the nature of the war, you are going to have to go into the <em>prime materia</em> out of which the complete novelty of decentralized collective intelligence is emerging: consider the notion of <em>Butterfly War</em> (born in the Chans) as described <a href="https://cultstate.com/2017/10/13/The-Butterfly-War/">here</a>.</p><p>Warning, this stuff is <strong>not</strong> legible to the Blue Church. If you are still running a Churchly sensemaker, largely governed by “good opinion,” the Butterfly War might not make any sense at all. Just as, perhaps, the nearly schizophrenic jabbering of QAnon shows up as nonsense. But, if you can “zoom out” and perceive this as one node in an arbitrarily large network that is precisely designed to up-regulate even partial sense through iterative and extremely high velocity experimentation, you will see the underlying components of a creative OODA loop architecture that is at least one full order of magnitude more capable than the Blue Church-style architecture.</p><p>Rate and state. The Blue Church (and the Deep State fiefdom of the Church) has been around for a long time. Its state of effective collective intelligence is (relatively) high. But its rate of improvement is, as far as I can tell, negative. Every day, the Church weakens.</p><p>By contrast, the state of decentralized collective intelligence is still relatively low. But that rate . . .</p><p>My bet here is that soon we are going to start seeing parts of the Deep State defecting and looking to establish their own territory in the new decentralized world (if this hasn’t begun already).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*QTHTYu_SSV5er8lFc_c1jg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Front Three: Globalism</h3><p>It seems that we don’t need to spend much time here. As expected, without the power of the United States as an anchor and in the context of new media routing around old control structures, the forces of globalism are being routed world-wide. The Yellow Vests are convulsing in France. Brazil and Italy have flipped to populist nationalism. Everywhere the neo-liberal consensus is in flames and the shift to multi-polar nationalism is in advance.</p><p>At this point, even a major economic crisis seems to cut against the fading neo-liberal order. While it is plausible that the masses will forget the technocratic excesses of the various 2008–2010 era “bail outs,” it seems to me more likely that an economic crisis will simply accelerate the current trend. Simply put, the <em>ancien regime</em> has lost all legitimacy outside of narrow elite demographics and whatever comes next, it is unlikely to be similar to the world of Bill Clinton, John Major and Helmut Kohl.</p><p>Of course, from my perspective, it <em>also</em> won’t look similar to anything else we have seen in human history. The forces of accelerating change are fundamentally strange to our contemporary sensemakers. At best, we can grasp the fact that <a href="https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2018/11/28/the-digital-maginot-line/">the pace of change renders most of our old models (and institutions) fast fading artifacts of past wars</a>. But even this is wholly inadequate to a reality premised on *accelerating* change.</p><p>A decomposition of the neo-liberal order to some form of multi-polar nationalism seems to be the next move on this front. But, I expect this stage to be ephemeral. As decentralized collective intelligence continues to gather its power, the nation-state will find itself in a global ecosystem with entirely new forms of political consistency that are more fully aligned with the future.</p><p>The nation-state, as we currently understand it, is itself a function of broadcast-type coherence. Something new is on the horizon. China, with the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sesame_Credit">sesame credit system</a>, appears to be preemptively designing in that new space. The consequences of this experiment very much remain to be seen. But it seems unlikely that the decomposition of the neo-liberal order will stop when it reaches national borders. What comes next will be, simply, new.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*75WyU4IMC6DQjFyaSCFcuQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Front Four: The New Culture War</h3><p>If 2018 was the year of Jordan Peterson, then perhaps 2019 will be the year of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. With the breakthrough of AOC, the Culture War has entered a new phase.</p><blockquote>The collapse of the Blue Church is going to lead to a level of “cultural flux” that will make the 1960’s look like the Eisenhower administration. As the Church falls away, the “children of Blue” will emerge in a Cambrian explosion and reach out to engage in all out culture war with the still nascent Red Religion.</blockquote><p>To my mind, AOC is the first major example of a “child of Blue”.</p><p>For clarity, I would contrast her with Tulsi Gabbard who might be considered the ‘last great hope of the Blue Church.’ While AOC and Gabbard might both resonate (more or less) with the content of the Blue <em>Faith, </em>Gabbard appears to be functionally operating within the mind/media type of the Blue Church. AOC’s mode of collective intelligence, by contrast, is decisively new media.</p><p>The Congresswoman from the Bronx is not a culture warrior trained by and for the broadcast television wars of the 90’s. AOC is an Achilles dipped up to the heel in the Styx of decentralized media. Her style of communication is fluid, continuous and direct. She does not stand above and outside of the conversation, attempting to influence it with authoritative ‘good opinion’. Rather, she is <em>in</em> it — sensing and responding to a “social” that is <em>always</em> present and that is coextensive with her identity.</p><p>In this crucial sense, she vastly more like the Insurgents than the elder Democrats that happen to be sitting next to her in the Congress.</p><p>AOC will likely behave very differently from the waves of idealistic young Boomer congressmen and women who came to Washington in the 70&#39;s through 90’s with big ideas — only to melt into the party machinery. Her power is connected to an entirely different source then the Churchly powers of the DNC. As she experiments with and demonstrates this new power, she will be showing precisely how few clothes the Emperor is wearing.</p><p>I expect 2019 to be a year where the struggle for the heart of Blue becomes a central part of the story.</p><p>Pity Pelosi and Schumer. Soon, they will be facing a <em>Blue</em> Insurgency, a rising power that they do not understand and against which they have little to no defense. In this context, the attractor of the 2020 election can rapidly accelerate the collapse of the Blue Church as increasingly angry and empowered Millennials learn how to use social media (<em>et al</em>) to cohere many different forms of collective intelligence with which they can simply side-step legacy political and media institutions in the pursuit of power.</p><p>And there is no reason to believe that the Blue Insurgents will be bounded by 20th Century borders any more than the Red Religion has been.</p><p>If this comes to pass, the many different tribes of the Blue Insurgency will meet the many different tribes of the Red Religion in an intrinsically global + virtual conflict and we will have entered the “tapioca” stage of the Culture War.</p><blockquote>This Culture War will be unlike anything we have ever seen. It will take place everywhere all at once, constrained less by geography than by technical platform and by the complex relationship between innovation and power on an exponential technology curve. It will be a struggle over not just the content, but the very <em>sense and nature</em> of identity, meaning and purpose. It will mutate so quickly and will evolve so rapidly that all of our legacy techniques (both psychological and institutional) for making sense of and responding to the world will melt into so much tapioca. This will be terrifying. It is also the source of our best hope.</blockquote><p>What might this expanding decentralized Culture War look like? Peter Limberg and Conor Barnes at the Intellectual Explorers Club took an excellent first swing at it in their <a href="https://medium.com/intellectual-explorers-club/memetic-tribes-and-culture-war-2-0-14705c43f6bb">Memetic Tribes and Culture War 2.0</a>. Take a look.</p><p>From one level, the dynamic of Culture War 2.0 shows up as one of intense fragmentation and disorientation, where none of our 20th Century techniques for generating social coherence stand up to the rapidly changing reality. From this level, the experience will likely be one of increasing chaos in all aspects of culture, society and individuality. If you are running a 20th Century sensemaker, it will feel like a descent into some flavor of madness.</p><p>However, if we open into a sensemaker from the <em>future</em>, it begins to look substantially simpler. Not easier, unfortunately, but simpler.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UwMy4s1Aw8KPYwEUGK9ZTw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The War for Collective Intelligence</h3><p>Consider a molecule of water in a pond. It has a location and it is going a particular direction at a particular speed. We might imagine it in the same way we would imagine a billiard ball on a table. Zooming around, occasionally colliding with other molecules of water. For a while, we can try to make sense of these molecules by carefully tracking their location and momentum and calculating the consequences of their collisions.</p><p>But as the scope of our vision expands, we start to get overwhelmed. Tens of molecules become hundreds and thousands and millions and billions and quadrillions and . . . at some point we have to give up on the entire approach as a lost cause.</p><p>Enter ‘temperature’ and ‘pressure’. While we can’t keep track of a volume of water at the <em>micro</em> level, we can capture its most meaningful aspects at the <em>macro</em> level. Most notably, at atmospheric pressure, water freezes at 0 degrees Celsius and boils at 100 degrees Celsius.</p><p>These phases (solid ice, liquid water and gaseous steam) imply significant things. You can build an igloo out of ice. You can run a water wheel with water. Even more interesting things happen at the boundary, when one <em>phase</em> transitions into another.</p><p>From this point of view, Culture War 2.0 is rather simple. We might say that under conditions of accelerating change, humanity is now rapidly approaching a “phase transition.” We are moving from one way of being human to another, rather different, way of being human.</p><p>If we try to track it at the micro level, watching as the old coherence of the Blue Church dissolves into increasingly unfamiliar micro-tribes mutating at an increasingly disorienting pace, we are overwhelmed in the chaos. But we don’t have to focus on the micro. If we can recognize that we are quickly approaching a phase transition, we can reach for an entirely different set of tools to help us make sense of and respond to the situation.</p><p>A set of tools that is as old as humanity itself.</p><p>As it turns, out, this kind of phase transition isn’t entirely novel to the human experience. In fact, the moment we find ourselves in is somewhat familiar. In a deep sense, we have been here before. In fact, every time that our most distant ancestors faced a catastrophe of enough peril to force them to leave the security of home to venture through the hostile wilderness in search of a new place, we, humans, had to navigate this kind of transition.</p><p>Bret Weinstein once shared with me that the specific adaptation that made us most fundamentally human might have been the evolved capacity to navigate niche transitions in much faster than biological time. Throughout our species’ developmental history, we found ourselves pushed to the edge of extinction many times. Over and over again, our survival depended on becoming capable of leaving one niche and adapting to a new one. Ultimately, this problem itself *became* our fundamental niche. Evolution finally found a way to create a species whose niche is <em>niche transition</em>.</p><p>Evolution did this by moving almost all of our adaptive specialization from the biological (hardware) layer into the cultural (software layer). And it coded (at a very deep level) a capacity to shift from “culture mode,” where we are limited to using the tools in our given cultural toolkit, into a creative “liminal mode,” where we can form collective intelligence to navigate complex reality directly and with remarkable fluidity.</p><p>From my perspective, then, the resolution of Culture War 2.0, and the broader War for Collective Intelligence, settles into a simple choice. We either endeavor to make sense and choices on the basis of our existing cultural toolkit and, ultimately, battle into self-extinguishing chaos as lived reality accelerates beyond the bounds of those tools. Or we listen to our deepest humanness and allow ourselves to become sensitive to creative liminality. From here (and, I propose, <em>only</em> from here) we are capable of a coherent collective intelligence that is fully adequate to the novelty and magnitude of our present reality.</p><p>Letting go of everything that we think we know, indeed, letting go of a mode we might call “knowingness,” is no joke. Mystery and novelty are unspeakably dangerous. Letting go of certainty and expertise in the context of what appears to be a building threat in every direction is even more alarming. It only makes sense to melt into the crucible of liminality when the only way out is “up”.</p><p>Nonetheless, I’ve noticed that over the past few years this choice is beginning to show up more and more. I’m noticing an an increasing willingness, even urgency, for moving away from the simulated thinking of “knowing” into liminal space. A new kind of humanity wants to emerge and, for those with ears to hear, it is calling “from the future”.</p><p>So that is that. This will be the final installment of Situational Assessment. From this point forward, <em>my</em> entire focus will be learning how to come into coherent collective intelligence and learning how to <em>scale</em> that coherence. This is not the sort of thing that is at all available to broadcast-type communication like this Medium.</p><p>Instead, I am joining a new project, where we will be practicing embodied coherence and using that new level of collective intelligence to design, prototype, and embody the next layers of coherence and collective intelligence at both larger and broader scales. Thus, we intend, step by precise step, to construct an escape-velocity positive feedback loop through the “eye of the needle.”</p><p>If you would like to participate in this project, the good news is that its very nature is that anyone who chooses to do so is already in some fundamental way, doing so. There appear to be three major aspects, each one of which is a reflection of the others.</p><ol><li>Sovereignty: knowing when you are able to respond to the world and when you are merely reacting; and learning how to grow this capacity to respond into ever greater scope and strength. This involves integrity — bringing all aspects of yourself into right relationship with each other. It involves discernment — allowing the whole of you to listen with the utmost nuance and becoming more and more capable of making better and better choices. It involves embodiment — going slowly and allowing new capacity to settle into a complete context (yourself, your relationships, your community, your environment, . . .) that is balanced and strong.</li><li>Right relationship: finding your right place in the bigger story. This involves becoming ever more clear on who you are in your deepest, most authentic self and learning how to become attuned to how your highest self can show up in the many different relationships that make up the lived world. It involves leaving behind that which cannot be carried through the eye of the needle and discovering what might be called your “vocation,” that which is both most meaningful for you to gift to the world and which you are most singularly prepared to give.</li><li>Coherence: entering into a relationship where the whole is simultaneously much more than the sum of the individuals and the individuals are much more themselves for being part of the whole. As you enter more deeply into sovereignty and find yourself increasingly attuned to your vocation, you might find yourself called to explore coherence. This involves humility, gratitude and a keen sense of the crucible of love. It involves surrendering yourself into something that is higher than yourself and yet simultaneously becoming most fully clear and grounded into your most singular self.</li></ol><p>This might seem very simple. Not the sort of grand and complicated thing that can give rise to a completely new kind of civilization. Not the kind of strategy that can help us transition from a mode of being based on scarcity to one premised on abundance. But, I would propose that this is the very fabric out of which abundance has always been woven. And it is precisely by becoming masterful at weaving out of this fabric that we can together catch the ever blowing wind of abundance in our journey into the future. We already have what we need. We only need to step away from that which doesn’t serve the future and re-member that which does.</p><p>Note: My sense is that is not something that will happen at any center. The project that I am joining is, I imagine, only one of many that are already underway and will be only one star in the constellations that are forming. If you feel so called, you can and should begin the only place you ever could begin: right where you are. First with yourself. Then with those who feel called to gather in this journey.</p><p>If <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/0060908807/ref=cm_sw_r_tw_dp_U_x_2XkrCbRJ7J2PJ">the other times that this has happened in the past</a> are any evidence, soon enough, we will begin to see these gatherings grow and form into communities, then into neighborhoods and villages and, if the design is good, begin to scale to include the whole of the human family.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6e31897f35c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/situational-assessment-2019-aoc-edition-b6e31897f35c">Situational Assessment 2019: AOC Edition</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Considering Anti-Fragility]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deep-code/considering-anti-fragility-495494ce259a?source=rss----7c4eb9aca066---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/495494ce259a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[antifragile]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hall]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Oct 2018 21:50:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-23T21:50:29.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*eLzM0HcXp6-5a1WIIz2UZA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Nassim Taleb famously brought the notion of anti-fragile into our consciousness in his <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Antifragile-Things-That-Disorder-Incerto/dp/0812979680?SubscriptionId=AKIAILSHYYTFIVPWUY6Q&amp;tag=duckduckgo-d-20&amp;linkCode=xm2&amp;camp=2025&amp;creative=165953&amp;creativeASIN=0812979680">book by that name</a>.</p><p>I recently noticed that I have a conception of that notion that might bear sharing. I think this can be done somewhat quickly, so here goes.</p><p>First as a caveat, herein I will be using the term “anti-fragile” to mean that which is being described here. While this might be fully the same as the notion of anti-fragile introduced by Taleb, it might also only represent an aspect of that “larger” notion.</p><p><strong>Transmogrification</strong></p><p>To begin, consider a pocket watch. More specifically, consider the spring of a pocket watch. Notice that you wind the watch, applying some amount of mechanical energy (likely sourced by converting ATP into muscle contractions). And that this same energy is then converted into the rotational movement of the hands over some duration. This is “conversion”. Energy in, energy out. In point of fact, of course, by the laws of thermodynamics, less energy out.</p><p>Now move our object of contemplation to a very simple “barrel” music box. This contraption consists of a spring attached to a barrel that has some number and arrangement of pins that when turned ‘just so’ pluck metal armatures so as to cause them to vibrate at different (hopefully sonorous) tones.</p><p>To begin, let us assume that the pins on the barrel are completely randomly arranged. In this case, we have something quite similar to the watch. We convert ATP into muscle contractions to wind the spring and then the spring unwinds in a fashion that turns the barrel — producing a random arrangement of sounds. Energy in, (less) energy out. Perhaps ten turns of the key results in two hundred rotations of the barrel.</p><p>Now replace the random barrel with one that has been so arranged that the sounds played are the notes of “twinkle twinkle little star”. This time, something new has happened. From one perspective, it is the same. Ten turns of the key, two hundred rotations of the barrel. But from another perspective, ten turns of the key has resulted in a song. Twinkle, twinkle.</p><p>Now replace this barrel with one so arranged that the sounds played are the notes of Beethoven’s 9th Symphony. Ten turns of the key. Beethoven’s 9th Symphony.</p><p>There is something happening here. Something different from mere energy conversion. I’ll call it “transmogrification”. The same energy in can be transmogrified into really rather strikingly different results.</p><p>We can, of course, do the same thing with Beethoven himself. Ludwig Van, we might imagine, takes in about 3,000 calories a day. Most of the time, this 3,000 calories produces, let’s say, random noise. The normal day to day business of being a human in the world. But some of the time, this same 3,000 calories a day produced “the 9th Symphony”.</p><p>Transmogrification is not the same as conversion. The laws of thermodynamics don’t tell you much about transmogrification. The same amount of energy in can result in very different results.</p><p>This is the key to my understanding of anti-fragility.</p><p><strong>Anti-Fragility</strong></p><p>Consider robustness. This is the ability to resist some force while being what (and where and how) one is. If I am standing in front of you and you shove me, if I am robust, I remain un-moved. Energy vs energy.</p><p>Consider resilience. This is the ability to respond to some force by being able to return to what (and where and how) where were before the force was applied. If I am standing in front of you and you shove me, if I am resilient, I can return to my original position (and disposition). Energy vs. energy.</p><p>Now anti-fragility. This time, when you shove me, I invent Aikido. Transmogrification.</p><p>A city is anti-fragile when it responds to a flood by coming together, improving social capital and innovating new ways to respond to the future. A company is anti-fragile when it responds to market competition by innovating new ways to market or design or . . .</p><p>The strong version of this proposition is that transmogrification — the translation of energy from the energetic to the informational or from the rivalrous to the anti-rivalrous — is precisely all that can be meant by anti-fragile.</p><p>The weak version is that transmogrification is one of the more powerful and, I would suggest, interesting aspects of anti-fragility.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=495494ce259a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/considering-anti-fragility-495494ce259a">Considering Anti-Fragility</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deep-code">Deep Code</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>