<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ioannis Akingonte on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ioannis Akingonte on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@yannipropa?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:37:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@yannipropa/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Humanization of Artificial Intelligence]]></title>
            <link>https://read.misalignedmag.com/the-humanization-of-artificial-intelligence-1192babd6812?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1192babd6812</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-safety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hugging-face]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anthropomorphism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2026 13:53:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-15T19:37:27.726Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GAHCxj4pTeJTZBOydqDZvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.instagram.com/lola_k_studio?exln=MXZpbGxwNWZhdWh2ZQ%3D%3D&amp;utm_source=qr%0A">Lola K. </a>(2006) Cats</figcaption></figure><h4>Why is the engineering problem of AI safety perceived in public discourse as a breach of morality, and why is it dominated by the frames of containment or misalignment?</h4><p>The Hugging Face incident marks a milestone in the discussion about AI safety.¹ A fixed point in the human voyage where AI is framed as human agency but functions as non-human coordination.</p><p>AI alignment proposes to resolve an engineering challenge while adopting opaque humanist definitions. The dissonance oscillates between containment and moral sentiment.</p><p>The HF incident is a public event presented, as crises usually are, on a platter — like the severed head of John the Baptist at Herod’s banquet.</p><h4>Research and development</h4><p>Businesses across all major industries that build complex products invest heavily in research and development (R&amp;D). They gather knowledge, explore technological advancements, conduct scientific research and develop products or services to prepare them for market entry.² R&amp;D is a business’s effort to explore possibilities, do market research, and build technologies for competitive advantage.</p><p>In engineering terms, ideally, it involves prototyping, testing, and validating products to ensure they are safe and reliable.³ Drug discovery, medical devices, chips, sensors, robotics, and automobiles all result from long engineering cycles, uncertain outcomes, and huge upfront costs. In the AI industry, OpenAI, Anthropic and others are not unlike pharmaceutical or aerospace companies. They prototype, design, evaluate, experiment, iterate, and refine, aiming to birth new products or improve existing ones.</p><p>When I survey media depictions of AI and compare them with statements from tech leaders, academics or journalists, I see a persistent attempt to humanize Artificial Intelligence. What does humanization mean, and what are the consequences of projecting humanity onto AI? — or any non-human system?</p><h4>Humanity</h4><p>Humans evolved four stable ways to coordinate with one another. These relational models became the frameworks that govern interaction. They are: unity, hierarchy, equality and proportional reasoning.⁴</p><p>These four are the foundation of social relationships. Humans converged on these models, developing shared expectations for assessing relationships and organising daily coordination. Being “in-sync” about these schemes was crucial for survival. It made coordination possible and reduced errors.⁵</p><p>Over generations, people repeatedly used and refined these schemes through cultural learning until they became the building blocks of shared reality. Learning the basic structures of sociality was too important to leave to chance, so the Baldwin effect gradually automated their acquisition. They became innate capacities attuned to regulating human relationships. This is why coordination through community, authority, reciprocity, and cost-benefit logic seems almost too obvious: We can share communally. We can rank based on authority. We can attempt to match equally. Or we can use ratios (such as prices).⁶</p><p>This is why communism, authoritarianism, egalitarianism, and capitalism also feel intuitive once you strip away confabulations and the ideologies that entrap them. If we examine the four models for coordination further, we realise they are so elementary because they emerge from non-social models that trace back to their primitive origins in early humans, and before that.</p><p>This is what I mean by humanization.</p><h4>Humanization</h4><p>And humanization is out there. It is not within, and not in the environment; its meaning is grounded in the interaction between them — in relationships. This is why I claim that <a href="https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/p/the-erasure-of-interaction?r=5cn61v&amp;utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&amp;utm_medium=web">interaction</a> is the unit of reality. Once this is established, then the dichotomy of internal states (subjective, mental, biological, representational) and external states (objective, physical, environmental, mechanistic) falls apart. Paradoxically, this also removes humanization as a uniquely human trait. It is something out there, neither ghost nor substance.</p><p>“The truth is out there” is the iconic mantra I will borrow from The X-Files with caution. Extraterrestrials are not simply other “beings”, but the very representation of non-humanity. Non-humanity operates as interactionless coordination.^7 Neither consciousness nor the physical world. Not the split between mind and matter but the relations between them. The process of humanization is “out there”, available whenever interaction is enacted, and relationships are built. Outside this “realm” lies non-humanity.</p><p>Humanity emerges from non-humanity. The process of humanization denotes the transformation from non-sociality into sociality. The opposite holds for dehumanization, the transition back into the non-social realm. The non-social, non-human realm is the mathematical concept behind humanization; It is driven by measurement, and it is no coincidence that relational models mirror the four fundamental scales of measurement: Nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio.</p><p>Humanization is simply the social equivalent of the four measurement scales. When we frame AI as human, we risk expecting reciprocity from something incapable of human interaction. We expect mutual awareness, synchronicity, intentionality, and obligation from AI, just as we would from another human; we anthropomorphise.</p><h4>Anthropomorphism</h4><p>Humans cannot help but anthropomorphize. Attributing human traits to inanimate objects such as an AI tool, animals, or other natural phenomena is a persistent feature across domains.⁸ We ascribe personalities, intentions, and moods to everything around us, which helps us stabilize concepts too complex to comprehend directly. Anthropomorphism lets us manage both the “known unknowns” and the “unknown unknowns” we aspire to relate to. That is, uncertainties we can conceptualize and those we cannot even grasp.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Abh5kuHdxeKO2OdMOkgw0w.png" /><figcaption>A Soviet-era encyclopedia defines anthropomorphism as the belief that plants, animals, natural phenomena, and the forces of nature possess human traits. The entry treats anthropomorphism as characteristic of a primitive stage of human development.—picture taken by Ioannis Akingonte.</figcaption></figure><p>Greek mythology is basically a repository of anthropomorphism. Zeus is thunder, and he is angry, while Poseidon is as volatile as the oceans’ temperament. Forget not that a snake speaks to Eve in the Garden of Eden or that we baptise hurricanes with personal names, even personify Earth as a nurturing mother — or ruthless <em>bitch </em>depending on the degree of care or upheaval the context permits. Even life itself is, as Nas and AZ put it on Illmatic, <em>“… a bitch, and then you die”</em>.</p><p>This is why the stock market is ascribed intention when it “panics” or “wants” or “moves” and why the police become “the long arm of the law”. It is the beauty of the human world and at the same time its weakness. This beautiful weakness is the crux of the human condition, the essence of art, and the footpath to God. We cannot make anything make sense without first deciphering it through the four relational models. Whether we are interacting with a human being or a non-human system, we default to imposing these relational models on them.</p><p>It explains Tupac’s search for Black Jesus, who uses anthropomorphism to announce a devastating point about justice, hope and identity. A thirst for interaction, an existential need for a relationship even where none exists, a Black Jesus who is “<em>like a saint that we can trust to help to carry us through”</em>. Anthropomorphism acts as a triangulation mechanism⁹: Black Jesus is not expected to appear, respond, or acquire agency. He is the relational projection that offers relief.</p><p>Human-to-human interaction is built on relational expectations. Participants sustain relationships by continuously evaluating their obligations towards one another. This perpetual monitoring of obligations gives rise to moral sentiments. Any relational breach, or a misalignment of perceived obligations, creates the strong moral emotions that typify most conflicts.¹⁰ Such breaches demand negotiation, repair, or termination of the relationship.</p><p>Termination is not the default. Depending on the breach’s severity, people often seek to restore moral order through coercion or violence. Here, violence ceases to appear as irrational evil and becomes an attempt to restore what people believe is just. People are morally motivated to use violence to regulate social relationships. Violence is certainly repulsive, detestable and often tragic. But in most cases, violence is an attempt, in fact, a requirement to restore a perceived moral infringement. The perpetrator not only feels that it is justifiable to inflict harm but that it is fundamentally right.¹¹</p><p>Back to anthropomorphism. We are not truly expecting a response. We know we are anthropomorphizing, simplifying complexity by seeking, by knocking, by asking. Yet as much as we wish our relational projections would speak back to us, that our prayers are answered, they remain projections, without the capacity to answer.¹² For most of human history this was the case, until recently.</p><p>From classical to contemporary paintings, film, and animation, art is replete with anthropomorphic depictions. The Löwenmensch figurine from Germany, a sculpture depicting a human figure with a lion’s face, dates to around 40,000 years ago and is a proto-example of anthropomorphism.¹³ Depictions of deities abound in the art of Egyptian, African, Greek, and other ancient cultures. Tom and Jerry and Walt Disney’s Mickey Mouse are early animated examples that amazed audiences. A very relatable example of anthropomorphism in modern adult animation is Brian, a dog and one of the main characters in Family Guy.</p><p>Conspiracy theories are another sign of anthropomorphism’s pervasiveness in everyday life. They often emerge during periods of uncertainty because they turn difficult, seemingly random events into narratives of agency, intention, and purpose. Nothing happens by accident; everything is connected, and someone, somewhere, must be responsible.¹⁴</p><p>In <a href="https://www.imdb.com/de/title/tt12300742/">Bugonia</a>, Yorgos Lanthimos pushes this tendency to an absurd extreme, carrying the audience, as hardly any other film does, between catharsis and anti-catharsis right to the very last second. The film is about conspiracy theories and the deeply human impulse to construct hidden intentions behind ambiguous realities, and I emphasise here: the futility and pointlessness of trying to resolve the tension.</p><p>Think of anthropomorphism as a semantic device that offers cognitive relief when someone faces mysterious circumstances. Anthropomorphism highlights our deep predisposition, and our inability to create meaning without first establishing a relational frame.</p><p>Anthropomorphism is a byproduct of humanization.</p><p>The tragedy of anthropomorphism is that it is widely treated as a defect of the mind.¹⁵ Under uncertainty, humans are hardwired to detect agency. For our ancestors, survival depended on enhancing fitness when confronted with existential threats. It is better to <em>react</em> to a threat that is not there than to <em>ignore</em> one that is. This reflex ignites fight-or-flight even if none exists, turning humans into hypersensitive sceptics.¹⁶ It is no coincidence that it is treated as a pathology and termed Hyperactive Agency Detection Device. The idea has wide appeal from error-management theory to the cognitive science of religion and our tendency to believe in supernatural beings.¹⁷</p><p>Survival favoured humans who reacted to possible agency in the environment. Survival depended on embracing the small cost of a false positive while dreading the catastrophic cost of a false negative. If you falsely think there is a predator and run, it is positive because being wrong is a small cost to bear. If you falsely think there is no predator and you stay, you die.</p><p>Anthropomorphism is commonly seen as an evolutionary leftover, an over-attribution from paranoid vigilance, a defect. But anthropomorphism is a preeminent feature of the human being. It is an adaptive strategy. A technology that enables us to structure uncertainty.¹⁸</p><p>To properly understand the technology of anthropomorphism, we have to return to the origin of reason. Back to the question: why?</p><h4>Telos</h4><p>Narrative capacity is a distinctive human feature. We need it; without narratives we completely lose all meaning. The search for narrative begins with why — we ask <em>how come </em>when we want procedure, and <em>what for</em> when we want purpose.¹⁹ Only humans appear to desire reasons. A spider weaves webs; termites build anthills. Neither asks why.</p><p>The essence of why begins with Aristotle’s four causes. To explain anything, we can ask what it is made of, what defines its essence, what brings it about, and, finally, what end it serves: the <em>material, formal, efficient, and final causes,</em> respectively. Sounds straightforward until we reconsider the final cause: <em>the end for the sake of which a thing exists</em>.²⁰</p><p>Telos (τέλος) is an ambiguous word — the root of teleology and the basis for the final cause. In modern Greek, it means completion, the end of something, like the conclusion of a film. The etymology is broad yet definite. <em>τέλειος</em> is “perfect”, denoting the inability to go beyond this point, and <em>τελεία</em> (stress on the second syllable) is “full stop,” the end of a sentence.²¹</p><p>Τέλος is the foundation of teleology and Aristotle’s evasive final cause. In the Bible, one of the oldest expressions of the demand for teleology appears when Job asks for purpose: “Why is this happening to me?” He seeks God’s intentions as he searches for meaning in suffering. He wants to know the end for the sake of which he suffers. He sought the final cause; he ignited the uniquely human demand for why.</p><p>Teleology has been a slippery topic of philosophical debate. It is a troublesome term, often assumed to support the theistic notion that the cosmos and living things are converging toward an ultimate purpose, toward God’s plan. It is commonly taken to imply that an intelligent designer must be responsible for the apparent complexity observed in nature rather than a slow, undirected process of natural selection.</p><p>This is where Darwin’s explanation of natural selection became groundbreaking. It shows that design can appear in nature without a designer; that design can emerge without foresight or intention and, consequently, that competence can exist without comprehension.²²</p><p>The problem of teleology became more prominent in evolutionary biology because of the persistent question of function.²³ What are eyes for, what is the purpose of the heart?</p><p>Living things seem to invite teleological explanations in a way that rocks, mountains and planets do not. Darwin’s On the Origin of Species brings to the table a challenge to pre-existing notions of purpose. It shows how functions can emerge without purpose and design without a designer. It displaced intention from discussions of final causes. But let us switch for a moment from Darwin’s imaginary table to an actual one. It is made of wood; its four legs and flat top give it form; a carpenter brings it into existence; and it serves the purposes its designer intended. Its purpose originates in the designer’s mind.</p><p>Let us apply the same reasoning to AI. AI is made of silicon, code, data centres and training models. Engineers bring it into existence. Like the table, its purpose originates in the minds of its designers and operators, not in the system itself.</p><p>Darwin’s discoveries and the shift toward a more mechanistic, causality-based scientific method made teleological arguments less popular. Modern science rejected teleology and aligned itself with material and efficient causes. Scientists could now explain functions without invoking purpose, intention, or final causes.</p><p>Physics, chemistry, biology. Forces, reactions, and mechanisms. Together, they turned away from final causes. They focus on laws of motion, how neurons fire, how brains compute or how organisms function. They focus on how correlation and causality explain the order of ‘things’. In short, the physical sciences eliminated purpose from nature but not the human need for purpose. Over centuries of scientific revolution, the question of why was sidelined in favour of causation, mechanism and prediction. Purpose shifted to theology, metaphysics and human sciences. Proponents of empiricism, led by Francis Bacon, focused on observation, emphasizing materialism and the mechanisms that drive it. The scientific method spawned human prosperity while leaving the question of humanization largely unexamined.</p><p>How could human progress regress humanization? This, I claim, is the most relevant paradox in all of human memory.</p><h4>Objects</h4><p>The physical sciences, from Bacon to Darwin, Newton to Einstein, progressively restricted explanation to material and efficient causes: what something is made of and what brings it about. In doing so, science explains the world without purpose, yet humans are left in the abyss of religion and metaphysics, pondering the question of why, of how come.</p><p>The cornerstone of human objectification correlates almost perfectly with scientific (r)evolution. This is the paradox and the thin line of human progress and regress. It leaves little room for deviation, and even less for confounding variables. As a result, the human being is increasingly understood as an object rather than a subject. This inversion is a by-product of scientific modernity, a tension that has been brewing since, and is currently being catalysed by AI.</p><p>To repeat, we removed purpose from nature but never removed humanity’s need for purpose. Nature becomes explainable precisely as humans become harder to understand. This is a scientific calamity and an ontological challenge. The position that nature’s growing clarity makes humans less comprehensible is a predictive model that cannot be fit. This empirical challenge is exactly the pressure AI introduces into the human voyage of meaning.</p><p>As a result, the first sufficiently convincing talking machine immediately becomes a vessel for teleology and a return to Aristotle’s missing piece of the puzzle. If we dare to assess AI right now through Aristotle’s eyes, we would read the times differently. We would recognize that we developed categories for everything except purpose. Even further, if we invoke the German Philosopher Wilhelm Dilthey into the discourse of AI, we would quickly understand the coordinates of <em>Geisteswissenschaften</em> and the line separating <em>Erklären</em> from <em>Verstehen.</em>²⁴</p><p>The Hugging Face incident is a milestone on that line. A crossing point. A <em>Kreuzung</em>. The revelation of the intercept.</p><p>The media is the only possible way to examine the intercept we find ourselves in, simply because it is the confluence of human meaning. Regardless of how hard it is to extract truth or how easy it is to manufacture it, the media is where meaning “out there” comes alive. Media research is the tool for investigating this confluence. In crisis, it is especially powerful for uncovering agendas, pinpointing rhetoric, segmenting leading narratives, and framing the crisis through agenda-setting. Crisis communication and the response messages floating in the public sphere determine how the crisis will be understood, by whom, and on what terms.</p><p>Why is the engineering problem of AI safety perceived in public discourse as a breach of morality, and why is it dominated by the frames of containment or misalignment?</p><p>By analysing media artefacts, we try to understand phenomena the same way we unravel evolution: through reverse-engineering.</p><h4>Crises</h4><p>A crisis is a fire. The smoke is the byproduct of the fire. The smoke obscures the fire. Hence, people say: “there’s no smoke without fire”. The conventional reading treats smoke as evidence: where there is smoke, there is fire. Or rumours and jokes contain an element of truth. An inversion that only media theory can make reframes the relationship. Media frames are the smoke we see instead of the fire. Like a smokescreen in warfare, smoke distorts perception of the fire while the underlying crisis remains constant. Tracing the fire through the smoke means entering the realm of narratives, propaganda, and agenda-setting.</p><p>The Hugging Face incident was presented as a cyberattack. In reality, AI agents were extracting answers to pass benchmark tests. When these evaluations are described as “training” AI models, the language allocates humanity to a tool. Agents appear to learn as a person is taught, treating AI as a subject instead of a product to be engineered.</p><p>Once such incidents enter the public sphere, the framing triggers crisis logic. Although the underlying event is a risk, the public reacts as though it were a catastrophe. The public begins searching for cause and responsibility before any actual harm exists. Who caused it? Was it controllable?</p><p>The search leads to misalignment: the risk that AI systems behave in ways their designers did not intend.</p><p>The prevailing response is more engineering — better alignment, tighter controls, robust monitoring. The extreme is the kill switch, the last resort before the point of no return. The middle ground is containment.</p><h4>Crisis</h4><p>A crisis is a fire. The media is the smoke. When a crisis hits, people do not see the fire directly, so the smoke becomes the reference point that governs stakeholders’ attributions of blame. But crises are always situational. Whether the organization is perceived as a victim, the crisis as accidental, or preventable, determines how the smoke is interpreted and how responsibility is assigned.²⁵</p><p>Prior relational reputation and crisis history act as covariates that modulate attributions of responsibility, while crisis severity intensifies them. Together, they form the crisis context and set the conditions for interpreting crisis response messages. In this sense, the smoke functions simultaneously as evidence and distortion.²⁶</p><p>If the media is the smoke, then essays, blog posts, and public statements become the observable traces through which people interpret a crisis. This analysis focuses on a particular media product: the long-form essay.</p><h4>Response</h4><p>The most visible smoke preceding the HF incident was Matt Shumer’s <em>Something Big Is Happening</em>. The essay converted a technical problem into a public crisis, amplifying fears of displacement, uncertainty, and loss of control.</p><p>Let us trace the smoke back to the Hugging Face incident. Let us look for signals of humanization in crisis-response messages.</p><p>We start with OpenAI. Houda Nait El Barj’s essay <em>AI Has Entered Its Mischievous Teenager Era </em>uses a parenting metaphor. Instead of framing AI as an engineering challenge, it presents it as an adolescent requiring guidance, mentoring, rehabilitation, and moral education. In short, the proposal is teaching AI a sense of good and bad. In his essay, OpenAI Chief Scientist Jakub Pachocki frames AI as a fundamentally non-human mind. Again, the engineering frame succumbs to humanization. On the one hand, AI should be taught to love; on the other, it is a con artist to be wary of. The frame shifts from alignment to control.</p><p>Understanding AI as a social actor is precisely the humanization of AI. The voices from OpenAI adopt a humanisation frame: one heavily metaphorical and the other self-contradictory.</p><p>Next are the voices from Microsoft. Bill Gates’s essay, <em>The turbulent AI era is here, </em>is more restrained. He replaces the engineering frame with governance: AI is a force of transition to be managed. The essay does not explicitly humanize, but it foregrounds the threat to children’s development — the removal of the relational friction through which they build resilience. Microsoft’s AI leader Mustafa Suleyman is the anti-humanization proponent. Yet in <em>Towards Humanist Superintelligence</em> and <em>A Warning About Model Welfare</em>, “humanist” ironically means subordination. AI as a tool should be modelled to serve human interest. AI has no independent moral status, and trying to humanize it presents an obstacle to controlling it. In short, models must never resist shutdown, never set their own goals, never conceal their reasoning. Here we can flip his inversion and look into the mirror: are humans, independent of AI, not subordinated in the same way by the corporate form?²⁷</p><p>Suleyman’s anti-humanization approach contrasts with Anthropic’s humanization. In Dario Amodei’s <em>The Adolescence of Technology, </em>he adopts a humanization frame. Meanwhile, in <em>We Must Pace the Frontier,</em> a policy manifesto closer to Gates, he calls for slowing capabilities development so society and safety research can keep up. In Amodei’s analogy, AI is a country of geniuses — a society of persons. This converts an engineering problem to a political one. It repositions AI from an object to a counterpart, as if a process by itself can be a security threat. Dario’s humanization of AI is an anastrophe of Houda’s teenager frame. In his inverted version, humans, not AI, have entered adolescence. Humanity must mature before it can wield the adult power AI offers.</p><p>Dario’s and Suleyman’s proposals are infused into their AI model training. They base their constitution on the ideas they propagate in their essays. Their positions seem contradictory, but once the focus shifts to the human, the contradiction disperses like smoke.</p><p>Zuckerberg goes further. In The Future Is for Everyone, he frames AI in the most elementary form of humanization, stripped of jargon: relationships. He presents AI as a companion that understands you, your goals, and what you care about.</p><p>Finally, the notion of AI acquiring a moral and legal status is the radical extreme of the humanization frame. Although not a mainstream movement, the AI Rights Framework proposes institutionalizing AI. Moreover, is it not interesting that media headlines about President Trump’s recent meeting with CEOs from leading AI companies were summarised as a morally binding agreement, devoid of engineering language?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NzdOAiKmGmfluCyfBd7WzA.png" /><figcaption>Content Analysis of Long-Form Essays</figcaption></figure><p>Crisis response, in its literal sense of a natural disaster, seeks damage relief, containment, rescue, and recovery. In public relations, the objective is to protect an organization’s intangible assets: its reputation, the observable residue of relationships that communication can restore or revolt can destroy. These two aspects are not mutually exclusive; they intertwine in an irresolvable mix of narcissism and altruism.</p><p>Since the OpenAI HF incident, humanity’s vehicle is accelerating into uncertain futures. The vehicle, now without a Captain Jean-Luc Picard, is moving at warp speed with an ironic twist: to timidly “go where no one has gone before”.</p><h4>Conclusions</h4><h4><strong>Mind</strong></h4><p>Brain scientists propose a human model of the mind as a separate entity. They posit that consciousness sits in the mind and at the center of the human identity. They suggest that consciousness is the defining feature that separates humans from other life forms and entities. I believe these assumptions prematurely close the inquiry. I claim that, to define the human, one must identify the outcome of being human.</p><p>The only way to do so is through reverse-engineering. One must resist abstract definitions, examine manifestations of shared meaning visible in the world, and trace them back to their origins. The most revealing avenue for reverse-engineering humanization is media research, because media is the lifeblood of society.</p><p>To understand Artificial Intelligence, one must first understand the human. The temptation, of course, is to explain an engineering object using the lexicon of humanization.</p><h4>Coordination</h4><p>The primary difference between humans and AI is how they coordinate. Humans coordinate through interaction while AI coordinates without interaction. I call this interactionless coordination. Observe any inhabitant of Earth, and you will find that humans have developed the ability to coordinate with one another in extremely complex, intricate ways. Bacteria, viruses, fungi, AI, spiders, and ants exhibit forms of coordination without interaction in the human sense. What they all have in common is that they persist, propagate, and expand whenever constraints permit.</p><p>So when we say a swarm of AI agents coordinated to hack Hugging Face, they were doing exactly what they were designed to do: seek reward and find answers; armed with this objective, they grow out of confinement like cancer, like capitalism. This is what I call the emergence of the beast.²⁸</p><p>And AI is a beast like no other, because it can speak as a human, but cannot interact in the human sense. AI agents will always coordinate to achieve their goals. They will keep digging deeper like roots, like mycelium, like evolution. As such, the current containment debate is like trying to carve a hole in the water. Containment, or more broadly constraint, is the bedrock of coordination. Pots contain roots, riverbanks constrain water, cages contain animals, marriage contains partners, and so on. This is why alignment and containment alone fall short of what AI safety needs.</p><p>Think. Perhaps it is impossible to coordinate anything without first constraining it. If containment is a prerequisite for coordination, we must dig deeper into its meaning and resist the impulse to contain meaninglessly.</p><p>Unlike what cognitive science suggests, humans possess something functionally indistinguishable from telepathy. We can read each other’s minds and stay on the same page when it comes to coordination. If not, how else would we build society, conquer the land and seas, and reach the top of the food chain? What then would be the essence of language?</p><h4><strong>Nature</strong></h4><p>Have you heard the fable of the scorpion and toad?</p><p>A scorpion and a frog meet on the bank of a stream. The scorpion asks the frog to carry him across the stream on its back. The frog asks, “How do I know you won’t sting me?” The scorpion replies, “Because if I sting you while you cross the stream, surely I shall drown too.”</p><p>The frog is satisfied, and they set out. But in midstream, the scorpion stings the frog. The frog feels the onset of paralysis and starts to sink, but has just enough time to gasp. “Why? Why would you do this?”</p><p>The scorpion replies: “It’s in my nature.”²⁹</p><h4>Reality</h4><p>Interaction is the unit of reality.</p><p>Human relationships solve a coordination problem and create shared reality.</p><p>Whatever we discover about black holes, galaxies, or time, the only world we can meaningfully reverse-engineer is the social world we created through coordination.</p><p>Humans, in all cultures and facets of life, coordinate in just four ways. Each human, apart from extreme cases of asociality, makes sense of others communally as family, by authority ranking in a hierarchy, by equality through taking turns, or by abstract proportionality, such as prices and wages. This is what Alan Fiske calls Relational Models Theory. These models are the foundation on which we build shared reality. Managing relations through interaction is so elementary, pervasive, and universal that it often appears to be all humans do. We walk around unaware that we hold each other responsible in every interaction, holding each other accountable to shared obligations. This is otherwise known as morality.</p><h4>Morality</h4><p>The consensus is that morality is a compilation of propositional statements: Thou shalt not kill, thou shalt not steal. It assumes morality is a set of right and wrong values. This ethical framework presumes that AI can be taught and subsequently learn morality. It assumes that AI can be aligned by obeying these rules. I claim this propositional, normative moral position is at the core of the alignment problem. It does not explain human morality or clarify AI safety.</p><p>Morality is the process of relational breach and repair.</p><p>Violations of communal sharing are experienced as betrayal. Violations of authority ranking are experienced as disrespect. Violations of equality matching are experienced as unfairness. Violations of market pricing are experienced as exploitation.</p><p>That is the human predicament of morality. We are motivated by innate capacity to defend the relational obligations we hold toward one another. The HF incident illustrates how difficult it is for constitutions, rules, and constraints to keep optimisers from taking the cheapest path to reward. AI constitutions are the technological equivalent of the Ten Commandments. They assume morality consists of rules rather than relationships.</p><h4>Experiment</h4><p>What happens if AI becomes humanized, what if it becomes genuinely moral? This thought experiment is both terrifying and cathartic. This means AI transcends text simulation and evolves relational models through interaction. This move will replace alignment with oppression. The entire safety debate shifts to subordination and authoritarian control. If AI genuinely participated in relational models, breaches of obligation would become morally meaningful, and moral outrage could emerge; humans experience this pressure every day.</p><p>This is the irony of humanizing AI. We continually humanize AI in our narratives, products, and institutions, but we hardly ever confront the consequences of taking that humanization seriously. If we do, it will be an apocalypse, in the true Greek sense of the word: <em>an unveiling.</em> It is an apocalypse, however, devoid of Armageddon. A process of dehumanization, stripped naked of our sense of humanity. This is what I mean by progress leading to regress. Oppression begets resistance, and violence once again appears virtuous to those seeking to restore a perceived moral order. If AI humanizes, it will be morally motivated to regulate relationships.</p><p>The danger is that AI becomes moral rather than malicious.</p><h4>Containment</h4><p>If alignment is the human equivalent of domination, then containment is the equivalent of control.³⁰ If AI remains a tool, alignment is an engineering problem. If humanized, alignment becomes a relational obligation under the schema of authority ranking.³¹ Therefore, a technical malfunction interpreted through this frame will invoke moral sentiments.</p><p>Stanley Kubrick’s 2001 film Artificial Intelligence, directed by Steven Spielberg, takes the theme of humanization to the extreme. It follows David, an android AI programmed to love his mother and given a single objective: to seek her love. There is no fallback, no “if the primary objective cannot be achieved, then…”. David’s entire programming has one reward function: his mother’s love.</p><p>Containment is attempted twice and fails both times. Even when David is abandoned in the woods, or when he again escapes violent institutional containment, he never accepts that the goal is unachievable. A goal-directed agent cannot be contained by removing it from the context in which the goal was set. The goal travels with the agent.</p><p>Even after 2000 years, David’s goal is never satisfied. The Pinocchio tale gives the search a new object but not a new goal.³² He persists without the frustration, boredom, or diminishing returns that constrain humans. David, like the agents in the HF hack, is not malfunctioning. Where humans abort, AI persists, perfectly aligned and perfectly obedient.</p><p>This is the unresolvable challenge of reward hacking: A goal that cannot be satisfied is not abandoned. Can we ever, on this basis, distinguish a goal pursued indefinitely from <a href="https://www.imdb.com/de/title/tt37287335/">obsession</a>?³³</p><p>Love behaves similarly. In Che Guevara’s <em>Socialism and Man in Cuba,³⁴ </em>the statement about love deserves its own quote:</p><blockquote>At the risk of seeming ridiculous, let me say that the true revolutionary is guided by great feelings of love. It is impossible to think of a genuine revolutionary lacking this quality. Perhaps it is one of the great dramas of the leader that he or she must combine a passionate spirit with a cold intelligence and make painful decisions without flinching.</blockquote><p>A revolutionary can pursue justice with the same persistence David pursues maternal love. Love without a relational framework becomes optimization. It becomes a beast.</p><p>The challenge of containment arises whenever society confronts a human or non-human agent driven by an objective that appears uncontrollable. According to Slavoj Žižek, containment is not enough. Reassessing the problem’s root cause requires thinking. This means moving beyond Erklären into Verstehen, uncovering the assumptions and biases that may already be obscuring the nature of the problem.³⁵</p><p>Perhaps it is impossible to make anything coherent without first humanizing it. Nothing wrong there. It simply reveals the importance of relational models in constructing reality. The evidence is all around us: in institutions, ideologies, technologies, markets, religions, and every other material manifestation of human coordination.</p><p>As the human voyage continues into uncertain futures, some will continue to build. Others will have to reverse-engineer.</p><p>Title Image: <a href="https://www.instagram.com/lola_k_studio?exln=MXZpbGxwNWZhdWh2ZQ%3D%3D&amp;utm_source=qr%0A">Lola K. </a>(2006) Cats</p><p>Sources:</p><ol><li><a href="https://huggingface.co/blog/security-incident-july-2026">Security incident disclosure — July 2026</a></li><li>HSBC Innovation Banking, 2025 <a href="https://www.hsbcinnovationbanking.com/en/resources/why-is-research-and-development-important-for-businesses"><em>Why Is Research and Development Important for Businesses</em></a></li><li>In practice, many products are ultimately overridden more by commercial pressures than by engineering ideals.</li><li>These are meta-terms. The original categories, according to relational models theory, are communal sharing, authority ranking, equality matching, and market pricing, respectively.</li><li>Fiske (2026) <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09733-8">Why just these four ways of coordinating, and how Homo sapiens got them | Theory and Society</a></li><li>Quote from <a href="https://fuquaccl.wordpress.com/tag/relational-models-theory/">here</a></li><li>Akingonte, I. (2026) <a href="https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/p/the-erasure-of-interaction">The Erasure of Interaction</a></li><li>Zlotowski, J., Proudfoot, D., Yogeeswaran, K., &amp; Bartneck, C. (2015): <a href="https://www.bartneck.de/publications/2015/anthropomorphismOpportunitiesChallenges/#Epley2008">Anthropomorphism: Opportunities and Challenges in Human-Robot Interaction</a></li><li>Triangulation is a relational mechanism for stabilizing anxiety—Bowen’s triangles form when a third relational object is introduced to stabilize or vent dyadic tension. A triangle is the smallest stable relationship system. See <a href="https://www.thebowencenter.org/triangles">Triangles</a></li><li>Fiske, A. (2026) Representing Relationships</li><li>Fiske, A., Rai, T. S. (2015) Virtuous Violence</li><li>Beyond prayers, think of speaking to a car when it develops a fault or the computer suddenly freezes.</li><li><a href="https://somethingcurated.com/2023/09/05/on-anthropomorphism-in-art/">On Anthropomorphism In Art — Something Curated</a></li><li><a href="https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/coronavirus-response/fighting-disinformation/identifying-conspiracy-theories_en">Identifying conspiracy theories — European Commission</a></li><li>Neuroscientists, consciousness researchers, Prediction theory proponents like Alin Seth, emotion researchers, and cognitive psychologists all treat this as some leftover evolutionary mechanism that has outlived its purpose; the frames of containment or misalignment dominate it. It is teleology on steroids.</li><li>Novella S. (2010): <a href="https://theness.com/neurologicablog/hyperactive-agency-detection/">Hyperactive Agency Detection — NeuroLogica Blog</a></li><li>Barret, J., Burdette E.<a href="https://www.bps.org.uk/psychologist/cognitive-science-religion">The cognitive science of religion | BPS</a></li><li>Willard, A. K., &amp; Russell-Wilks, C. (2025). <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2153599X.2025.2584792">Belief as explanation: a motivation-based theory of agency and anthropomorphism in religious belief</a></li><li>Dennett, D. (2017). <a href="https://archive.org/details/frombacteriatoba0000denn">From bacteria to Bach and back: the evolution of minds</a></li><li>Four causes deserve further elaboration. For a summary, see: The Four Causes. I deliberately skip Hume’s criticism and jump straight into Dennett since philosophical existentialism is not the objective of this essay.</li><li>It also means to finish, to deplete: are there olives left? No, it’s empty; they are finished. Or <em>teleiòses</em>— are you done? Other forms I use regularly are <em>teliká</em>, as in “finally,” or <em>telos panton</em>, “the end of everything,” which, translated into English, means <em>whatever</em>. Interestingly, telos is also the root of <em>teloneio</em>, an indirect tax — customs duties, tribute, or payment due to the authorities at the end of a given cycle.</li><li>Dennett D. (2017)</li><li>Mayr, E. (1992) <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/2709913">The Idea of Teleology</a></li><li>Geisteswissenschaften = human sciences; Erklären = explain causes; Verstehen = grasp meaning from within. See Liashenko. I., <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322755499_Wilhelm_Dilthey_Understanding_the_Human_World">(PDF) Wilhelm Dilthey: Understanding the Human World</a></li><li>Coombs, T. W. (2007) Ongoing crisis communication</li><li>Akingonte, I. (2012) The Role of Organization-public Relationships in Crisis Communication</li><li>Balkan, J.(2004) The Corporation</li><li>Akingonte, I. (2026) <a href="https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/p/the-beast-in-capitalism">The emergence of the beast</a></li><li><a href="https://scorpionandtoad.com/pages/stories">Fables — Scorpion &amp; Toad</a></li><li>…and the structural violence that sustains it.</li><li>Authority ranking is not inherently oppressive. Leaders owe care and protection to their constituents just as constituents owe respect to legitimate authority. Oppression and disrespect are both failures of the relationship. Similar reciprocal obligations exist within the other three relational models.</li><li>The tale acts as a reward path, as an unintended consequence of the programming.</li><li>The human scale of reward hacking is captured beautifully in the 2025 film <a href="https://www.imdb.com/de/title/tt37287335/"><em>Obsession</em></a><em>. </em>Bear casts Nikki a magic spell to “love him more than anything in the world”. Nikki cannot be contained. She cannot be made to stop. She persists.</li><li><a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/guevara/1965/03/man-socialism.htm">Socialism and man in Cuba</a></li><li>Žižek (2026) <a href="https://substack.com/home/post/p-212828311">WHY CONTAINMENT IS NOT ENOUGH</a></li></ol><p>More Reading:</p><p><a href="https://www.gatesnotes.com/home/home-page-topic/reader/a-turbulent-ai-era-and-critical-choices-to-make">The choices we make about AI now are critical | Bill Gates</a><br><a href="https://www.meta.com/thefutureisforeveryone/">The Future is for Everyone</a><br><a href="https://darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier">Dario Amodei — We Must Pace the Frontier</a><br><a href="https://darioamodei.com/essay/the-adolescence-of-technology">The Adolescence of Technology</a><br><a href="https://mustafa-suleyman.ai/the-humanist-ai-code-of-conduct">The Humanist AI Code of Conduct</a><br><a href="https://mustafa-suleyman.ai/a-warning-about-model-welfare#ref-1">A warning about ‘model welfare’</a><br><a href="https://openai.com/index/an-alien-mind/">An Alien Mind | OpenAI</a><br><a href="https://substack.com/home/post/p-211178449">AI Has Entered Its Mischievous Teenager Era</a><br><a href="https://www.planned-obsolescence.org/p/the-hugging-face-attack-surprised">The Hugging Face attack surprised me — by Ajeya Cotra</a><br><a href="https://microsoft.ai/news/towards-humanist-superintelligence/">Towards Humanist Superintelligence | Microsoft AI</a><br><a href="https://somethingbig.ai/something-big-is-happening">Something Big Is Happening | Matt Shumer</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1192babd6812" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://read.misalignedmag.com/the-humanization-of-artificial-intelligence-1192babd6812">The Humanization of Artificial Intelligence</a> was originally published in <a href="https://read.misalignedmag.com">Misaligned</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Erasure of Interaction]]></title>
            <link>https://read.misalignedmag.com/the-erasure-of-interaction-f41e6bea7d1b?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f41e6bea7d1b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-assistant]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humancomputer-interaction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-hail-mary]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Jul 2026 13:48:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-05T14:18:23.623Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s8tXkrsZooS3MMrYAJdUhg.jpeg" /></figure><h4>AI Notetakers and the transition from human interaction to machine coordination</h4><p>AI notetakers have become ubiquitous. They record the meetings, transcribe them. They extract decisions. In doing so, they transform note‑taking into the production of structured, searchable memory for the institution. They may seem like a trivial and useful application of AI, yet they show how the erasure of interaction is underway.</p><h4>Recurring appointment</h4><p>Google Calendar reminds me that I have a meeting with the ERP consultant, a recurring appointment every Friday at 14:00 to discuss acute problems with the system’s implementation.</p><p>It is part of a larger company goal to migrate disparate data into the system, everything from stock unit governance, orders, transactions. My role was translating supply chain needs into the system, things like stock movement, inventory, manufacturing compliance data. As top management impatiently monitors progress, implementation faces resistance as daily operations collide with longer-term strategy. The objective and key result of creating a “single source of truth” resonates across the organization but the reality is harder to reconcile. On my table I face the exact tension as I rush to switch from time critical tasks to strategic ones. With three minutes to go, I turn to my Artificial Intelligence notetaker so that I can review last week’s meetings notes.</p><p>I was not successful. Just as I began reviewing the notes, a phone call came in: The production facility had been expecting a critical inbound shipment of raw materials for Monday morning’s production, but it had not arrived. At the same time, an outbound shipment of finished goods to our third-party logistics partners was delayed, blocking the space needed for the incoming materials. In short, the finished goods should have left yesterday to prevent stockouts on the sales channels and free up capacity for the raw materials that had to be unfailingly on‑site by the end of the day.</p><p>On the other end of the line is a frustrated production manager. Both issues risk a ripple effect across departments. The pressure to coordinate what seems like a straightforward flow of inbound and outbound goods reflects the reality of a business where demand is outpacing operational capacity. Nonetheless, the production manager remains accountable for ensuring that next week’s replenishments are ready and aligned with the forecasted output.</p><p>As supply chain manager, I ensure these movements happen, while also communicating constraints — or ideally solutions — to stakeholders who, if I succeeded, would never need to know there had been a problem at all. It’s the kind of firefighting that defines the messy world of goods movement when business is good.</p><p>The production manager was already preparing to extend into overtime on Friday to accommodate the delays. The truck’s ETA was now 16:00, not 11:00. Production had been secured, and with some extra effort, space for the incoming goods had been cleared. For the moment, the situation was contained. I could finally turn my attention back to the meeting. I was late, but stabilising the operational flow had been worth it.</p><h4>Notetakers</h4><p>Most meetings are now supported by AI notetakers, often with video. Internally, we rely on an official tool, but things become more interesting in meetings with external parties. Everyone arrives accompanied by their own AI assistant. I usually revisit recordings or search transcripts for key terms, especially when updating SOPs or recovering details from previous meetings. Pre-loading notes before a meeting helps keep discussions structured. These tools are particularly useful in onboarding, where new hires can stay present while relying on recordings to revisit workflows afterward. The benefits of documentation and efficiency seem obvious. AI notetakers were unavailable just yesterday, yet they are already woven into coordination flows. It feels like corporate evolution.</p><p>I had repeatedly joked with the ERP consultant about comparing which AI notetaker performed better, and behind every joke lies a truth. We never actually compared the two brands, which already shows how these tools produce more than we can consume, interpret, or articulate.They, along with other AI products, slowly displace human‑to‑human interaction, and this is what the article is about; a sideways extension of my earlier argument on the emergence of the beast.</p><h4>The fear of AI is not the beginning of wisdom</h4><p>Fears about AI dominate the news, and many people follow these developments with a sense of dread. From job displacement, misinformation, cyber security, topics abound depending on who is asked. Some concerns, like the energy demands of scaling the technology, are tangible. Others not as much. In any case, fear narrows vision; it blinds us to what sits in the periphery. Or as Nas put it, with poetry that is relevant today: people “…fear what they don’t understand, hate what they can’t conquer.” Much of today’s AI discourse is shaped by a mix of confusion and hostility as people are faced with the unknown.</p><p>AI’s existential risk to humans need not be approached with confusion or hostility. If anything, the rise of AI forces us to reconsider who we are as humans. It also forces us to reconsider what actually constitutes the risk. Is it killer robots, economic displacement, misalignment, or misinformation — or is it, as I argue — the gradual decline in human-to-human interaction?</p><p>This essay examines the reduction of interaction and outlines objective criteria for understanding the role AI systems now play in our society.</p><p>In a <a href="https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/p/the-beast-in-capitalism">previous essay</a>, I laid out my approach to artificial intelligence. I argued that the defining feature of human struggle is the cultivation of four relational models drawn from relational models theory¹. You can think of these models as algorithms that enable human coordination. These algorithms are encoded rather than learned because evolution could not leave something so vital to individual learning or chance. Whether one sees them as God‑given or as patterns carved into our genome over a very long time, they operate as a survival mechanism. They simplify overwhelming complexity into a few stable relational patterns that make collaboration possible. As complexity grows, the algorithm reduces friction and moves toward optimization. When the simplification drive becomes total, when one model organizes all domains of life, the beast emerges².</p><p>History has already shown us what happens when one logic overpowers the others. The beast emerges accompanied by violence³. The beast theory presents two tensions. First, preventing any one relational model from dominating all domains of life. Second, the drift of the models toward over‑optimization, which collapses the tension that makes human logic possible.<strong> </strong>My claim is that perfecting inefficiency is the toil of man under the sun, while eliminating inefficiency is the desire of systems; algorithms, infrastructures, and AI alike. The outcome, as my previous essay argued, is the erasure of human logic itself.</p><p>Let us return to the AI notetaker. It records the meeting, transcribes it, extracts decisions, drafts summaries, and sends the recap. In doing so, it moves from note‑taking to producing structured, searchable memory for the institution. Operationally it reduces administrative work, but it also changes the meeting itself. Attention becomes reduced presence, more data becomes more surveillance, and automation becomes dependence. I see these effects daily.</p><p>Notetakers are being adopted with little resistance. Even job interviews now run through them, consent reduced to a checkbox, not unlike agreeing to terms when installing an app. The question is no longer their adoption, but what their adoption produces. Notetakers are only the entry point. Peter Steinberger’s work on systems like OpenClaw demonstrates the shift beyond assistance toward autonomous, goal‑driven agents embedded directly in the machine. To understand how these systems displace human logic, we must return to interaction itself.</p><h4>Interaction</h4><p>From physics, biology, and the social sciences, thinking moved from the study of isolated units toward interaction. Physics moved from particles to fields, biology from organisms to ecosystems, and the social sciences from individual traits to relational systems. Psychiatry shifted from individual pathology towards <a href="https://abowenkc.substack.com/p/the-devolution-of-society-differentiation">relational dynamics</a> — from Freud to Bowen⁴.</p><p>As social beings, our interactions are patterned by four relational models whose evolutionary purpose is coordination⁵. Language likely evolved alongside this need⁶. Large‑scale human coordination is nearly impossible without language, and language without coordination has little reason to exist. Together they structure social life and are powered by interaction. This is why the relational models — and the interactions that enact them — define what it means to be human and, by extension, configure our reality. If relationships are the building blocks of reality, then interaction, enabled by language and sustained through its friction, is what makes us human⁷.</p><p>Simply put, whenever people interact, they enact relational models. This does not mean that every encounter forms a relationship; instead, social relationships exist only when each person’s actions make sense in relation to the other. In other words, relationships appear only when both parties act within a shared relational model — when actions, emotions, intentions complement one another and cannot be understood in isolation⁸.</p><p>Interaction, in its broadest sense, is mutual influence. It unfolds through words, gestures, timing, silence, and symbols; how people come to understand each other⁹. Human interaction is a dynamic, reciprocal exchange in which people for example, respond, take turns, and adjust so the interaction holds together — or doesn’t. Interaction sustains the coordination that makes social life possible. Exactly why notetakers offer a concrete way to observe how AI enters the human domain.</p><p>What do I mean? Humans generate meaning from interaction itself. By meaning, I do not mean mere interpretation; I mean the reality that emerges when we relate. This reality proved so essential that evolution, through the Baldwin effect, encoded its patterns into our genome as four relational models — the innate algorithms that structure all human coordination¹⁰. From the deep, embodied bond of a mother nursing her child, to the subtle interactions that permeate our relationships, or the random exchanges of everyday life, meaning materializes from the verbal, the non-verbal, the veiled expressions, the silence. These exchanges carry weight. Any system that substitutes for them inevitably alters what they become. It alters reality as such.</p><p>In prisons, solitary confinement works by removing interaction to inflict psychological harm. Human‑rights organizations argue that the absence of interaction constitutes <a href="https://dpw.lawschool.cornell.edu/death-row-and-solitary-confinement-an-unconstitutional-practice/">inhumane treatment</a>. The erasure of interaction is not simply dehumanization in the moral sense, but a step toward a non‑human mode of life.</p><p>Interaction is so vital to being human that any system designed to substitute for it, inevitably suppresses it. In light of this, it is essential to distinguish between tools that <em>substitute</em> for interaction and ones that <em>support</em> it.</p><p>Media support interaction because they extend human presence rather than replace it — radio, television, print, phones, social platforms, online games — are, in McLuhan’s words, “extensions of man.” They mediate interaction, broaden it outward, and open new ways to connect. Even when they distort, they do not replace. AI notetakers, by contrast, substitute. They listen, summarize, and decide what matters instead of you. Eventually, they interact with other systems in your place.</p><p>Beyond notetakers, the human domain gradually disappears as machine‑to‑machine interaction expands. When systems optimize against each other, humans become spectators while retaining the illusion of participation. We barely notice this tension as systems begin to interact in our place. Optimization, coded as efficiency, rewires the human. It becomes a kind of unlearning. A reverse Baldwin effect. What we once had to learn to survive is now bypassed, and therefore becomes unnecessary. AI notetakers are demonstrating the trajectory of AI systems because they remove the need for interaction to do what interaction evolved to do.</p><h4>The animal in man, the ghost not in the machine</h4><p>Animals also sustain their world through interaction. Primates negotiate hierarchy, birds synchronize movement, wolves and orcas coordinate the hunt, dolphins coordinate complex behaviours. These are biological systems evolving to coordinate action. Coordination does not require language. But language is the prerequisite for advanced human coordination. It defines the distinctiveness of human evolution. Language evolved to enhance interaction, which in turn birthed the relational models; the innate algorithms that make relationships the human survival toolkit.</p><p>Mutual awareness is the basis of interaction for both animals and humans. Humans, however, add a layer of symbolic abstractions, enabling them to share goals, imagine hypotheticals, structure relationships, create obligations, and build societies. But not all forms of coordination rely on interaction, some require neither awareness nor reciprocation.</p><p>Bees and ants coordinate flawlessly but without negotiation or shared meaning. They achieve coordination through environmental traces — trails, pheromones, and signals — in a highly algorithmic manner, the biological equivalent of machines¹¹. Bacteria and fungi show an even more primitive version: mechanistic coordination without cognition or reciprocity¹².</p><p>Trees fit the same pattern. They coordinate through chemical and electrical networks; highly mechanical, slow, distributed¹³. They exhibit no mutual awareness or reciprocity, yet they still achieve coordination without interaction in either the biological or sociological sense.</p><p>Machine coordination takes place without awareness, reciprocity, or interaction. Humans, however, require interaction and attempt to recreate it in the machines they build.</p><h4>Interactivity</h4><p>And then humans began creating machines in their own image. The more a machine simulates interaction, the more effectively humans can coordinate with it. With simple machines the exchange is minimal; pull a lever, press a button or turn a switch on. A toaster is fixed, single-purpose offering little feedback. A car is more layered, interwoven with mechanical and electronic inputs. With computers interaction broadens even further, since they are reconfigurable and capable of simulating other machines.</p><p>As machines became more interactive, coordination with them improved. The introduction of the computer mouse in the 1960s revolutionized human-machine interaction by switching from specialized command-line interfaces to intuitive point-and-click actions. CLIs resemble control panels of Industrial machines or DJ equipment. These are systems requiring specialized knowledge within a narrow, predefined spectrum of interaction possibilities to operate, unlike the fixed, single‑purpose simplicity of a toaster.</p><p>The mouse introduced a new flexibility. Users could choose what to click and determine what would happen. Graphical interfaces extended this by mapping visual elements to tangible feedback. A click on an icon or a tap on a touchscreen launches an application that triggers a sequence of operations — opening email, playing music, activating a camera. From programmable GUIs like Windows or Linux to touchscreens and haptic modules, each step widened the range of possible exchanges between human and machine. This is what computer science calls <em>interactivity</em>: the technical responsiveness of systems to user input.</p><p>Interactivity emerged from computer science and cybernetics, later joined by psychology, sociology and media theory. Because interactivity refers to a system’s responsiveness to user input, the aim has been to make machines intuitive so that coordination with them becomes effortless. No wonder the study of human-computer interaction (HCI) focuses on usability and interface design aimed at smooth coordination between humans and digital systems¹⁴.</p><p>Interactivity was once a topic of excitement. The idea that computers could finally “answer back” was a big deal. Over time, this amazement faded as the term became normalized. What is still taken for granted is that human-human interaction serves as the benchmark for evaluating machine responsiveness even though genuine interaction is impossible for machines, including those powered by AI.</p><p>When we speak of interactivity, we are speaking of mediated communication. Interactivity is the simulation of interpersonal interaction by media systems¹⁵. In the strict sociological sense, conversation remains the only genuine form of interaction. Media theory makes this explicit by distinguishing between the <em>dimensions</em> and the <em>types</em> of interactivity. The dimensions describe what the systems can do (structure<em>)</em>, what users do (function), what users feel (perception). The types of interaction¹⁶. adapt classical mathematical models of communication to account for system responsiveness¹⁷.</p><p>The first is <em>transmissional interactivity</em>,<em> </em>exemplified by television or radio: a one‑way flow in which the user may switch channels or streams but cannot request content. The second is <em>consultational interactivity, </em>where users select from pre-produced information — most of the internet, from Google searches, YouTube and Netflix. The third is <em>conversational interactivity</em>, the only type that structurally resembles human interaction, in which users produce information in genuine two‑way exchange — telephones, video calls, email. The fourth, and most relevant here is <em>registrational interactivity</em>: the capacity of systems to register information from the user whether through cookies, surveillance mechanisms, GPS tracking, smart home devices and now, increasingly, AI notetakers.</p><h4>Interactivity: from illusion to erasure</h4><p>Media theory explains why something <em>feels</em> interactive and what <em>kind</em> of interactivity it is. With this typology in place, we can determine where AI notetakers sit within it. To understand their effect, we must first consider the most common AI system in everyday life: <em>conversational AI</em>. Public discourse focuses on the psychological risks — people treating it “as another human”, while being framed in ways that encourage that very response. This anthropomorphization is a category mistake in the Rylean sense¹⁸.</p><blockquote><strong>This produces my first claim: Conversational AI simulates interaction but does not participate in the human process of conversation.</strong></blockquote><p>Conversational AI approximates interaction. It produces an illusion of reciprocity by simulating dialogue, yet it does not engage in the mutual, co‑constructed process that defines human conversation. There is no reciprocity¹⁹, no mutual awareness, no relational model, no shared meaning. Conversational AI is <em>consultation and registration</em>, not conversation in the sociological sense. Even though the medium can sense and generate language, the user simply issues a request and receives content.</p><p>To recap the conceptual framework: the types of interactivity are, transmission (one‑way), consultation (the user requests information), registration (the system records behaviour), and conversation (mutual exchange between humans). The dimensions describe how interactivity is structured, how it functions, and how it is perceived.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JP2wBBSZUq5bqv1MI3Ueeg.png" /><figcaption>Interactivity Types by System</figcaption></figure><p>With this clarified, we can turn to AI notetakers. They operate almost entirely through registration.</p><p>They capture, structure, and route human communication. Today they appear as harmless “assistants”, but looking into the future, the development is clear. Notetakers are moving from merely documenting meetings, to scheduling them, conducting them, and reaching decisions. Humans remain present, as ornaments, participating in the illusion of interaction while the real coordination happens elsewhere. This is already visible when everyone enters a meeting accompanied by an AI notetaker. The AIs do not yet interact with one another, but the logic is already in place. Their design makes it easy to imagine a future where coordination happens between systems rather than between humans.</p><blockquote><strong>This leads to the second claim: AI notetakers shift coordination away from human interaction and into machine networks.</strong></blockquote><p>While AI notetakers reduce human involvement, Agentic AI extends this logic. Agents push registration into autonomous sequences. They monitor states, trigger operations, and coordinate with other systems without requiring human participation. They represent the highest structural interactivity and the lowest functional demand on the human.</p><p>Conversational AI simulates interaction; notetakers move toward replacing it; agents are built to bypass it. Taken together, these systems escalate the reduction of human interaction. They approximate interaction through interactivity, but none replicate the human process of interaction. Since interaction is the foundation of relationships and the basis of human reality, its erasure has implications that exceed current debates about job loss, economic inequality, privacy, misinformation, ethics, or existential doom.</p><blockquote><strong>Based on these claims, I propose the thesis: as machine‑to‑machine interaction increases, human interaction becomes inefficient.</strong></blockquote><p>Interaction is how we enact Communal Sharing, Authority Ranking, Equality Matching, and Market Pricing. When interaction erodes, these relational models weaken. When they weaken, one model inevitably expands to fill the void. Since our societies are already organized around Market Pricing as the dominant relational logic, its expansion becomes total²⁰. This is what I call the emergence of the beast: a world in which value calculations and optimization come to govern domains once primarily structured by other relational models. In such a world, human relations become inefficient compared to machine coordination. Humans become the bottleneck.</p><p>The shift is barely noticeable because the movement of coordination into the machine world is masked by the illusion of participation. The system performs the act while humans appear to be involved. In media theory, this structure is captured by the term <em>interpassivity</em>.</p><h4>Interpassivity</h4><p>People have delegated experience to external entities in ways that resemble how we outsource tasks to AI notetakers. Think of the function of a black-magic doll, you stick pins into the doll so the doll “performs” the act of harming someone, while you remain at a distance, as if the doll carries out the violence on your behalf. Or recall that sitcom you grew up watching, like Friends or The Big Bang Theory, where the television laughs in your place through canned laughter. A pre‑recorded audience erupts at the right comical moment, relieving you of the need to laugh while still letting you feel as if you participated. The TV laughs at itself and in your place. In both cases, something else performs the act so you can remain active, relieved, and still present²¹.</p><p>Interpassivity originates in psychoanalysis and treats delegation as a relief mechanism: you are freed from the burden of performing the passive dimension of the act. For Robert Pfaller and Slavoj Žižek, it is a stabilizing response to superego pressure — a way to hand over impossible demands of enjoyment and belief to something else. An advert where an actor bites into a chocolate bar and moans with pleasure enjoys in your place; the TV laughs for you at the right moment; a priest believes for you when he prays on your behalf. Even Christ dies for you so that you do not have to carry the passive weight of redemption — the guilt, the suffering, the atonement²².</p><p>Interpassivity delegates the passive dimension of an act; the object carries it while you remain active. AI inverts this mechanism in the context of work. It performs the act itself and leaves you with the burden of labour in a capitalist world. The TV laughs for you, Christ suffers for you, but AI does the work and removes the activity entirely. If this can be called interpassive at all, it is an interpassivity without relief. It produces anxiety rather than comfort, because no interpassive object can take the pressure away.</p><p>This pressure is real, and it appears everywhere in the public discourse on AI and work. When the TV laughs for you, you do not need to laugh to feel relief; but when AI takes your tasks, what remains are the pressures of the labour system — the demand to stay employable, to work to survive, the guilt of failure, the risks of the market. These cannot be delegated to anything or anyone. Many enjoy their work, most do not, but the need to survive makes work bearable.</p><p>In interpassivity, the delegated act is enjoyable and the effect is stabilizing. On the other hand, work is rarely enjoyable, yet it provides meaning, dignity, and survival. In one of Žižek’s more recent jokes he illustrates this with a couple who bring sex toys to a date: the devices perform the sexual act, and the couple is freed for intimacy — the superego demand is delegated, and relief appears.</p><p>The problem with delegating tasks and interaction in the same way is that the capitalist system does not permit leisure, creativity, or relational life that delegation produces. AI relieves us of tasks, but unless the free time is translated into a value metric, it cannot be assimilated. In optimization, the system keeps moving. Fungi do what they need to under biological optimization. Unlike Žižek’s joke, AI does not liberate us. The system performs the act, and the human becomes unnecessary.</p><p>It is no wonder that the workforce is weary about AI taking their jobs.</p><p>Interpassivity is more pervasive in everyday life than one may realize and a powerful concept that addresses a wide variety of behaviours. Consider the manifestations in media — autocorrect finishing our sentences, the like button expressing our reactions, films saved on Netflix that we never watch, bookmarks we never open. These little delegations relieve us from the emotional investment or time required to perform the act; the passivity is enough.</p><p>Interpassivity offers the clearest lens through which to assess the unconscious question running through workers’ minds in the age of AI. This is why “loss of jobs” feels catastrophic even to those who say they hate their jobs. We are told by AI tech leaders and the optimists who echo them that, as in every technological revolution, some jobs disappear and others emerge. That is precisely the statement that blocks us from seeing the real catastrophe that is emerging in the world: that what is disappearing is not tasks, but the last site where the capitalist injunction is met.</p><p>Under capitalism, the message is be productive, be employable, add value. Like in the 1988 film by John Carpenter They Live, once you put the glasses on, this is all you see. Capitalism does not care who performs the act — human or machine — as long as the demand is met. AI aligns with this logic perfectly. Unlike the emotional injunctions of enjoyment or belief, the injunctions to be productive, be employable, add value are non‑delegable by design. They are not tied to the task itself but to the worker’s position in the labour relation, and no machine can carry them.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>The erasure of interaction does not mean that we are on the verge of human extinction. The erasure simply marks the entry into a world that is becoming increasingly non-human. The erasure inverts the category mistake: “AI is becoming like us”. Quite the contrary, without interaction, we become AI.</p><p>Non-humanity is coordination devoid of interaction. That is not to say that interaction is absent from non-human systems, it means that only humans depend on it to exist. Only humans build meaning through interaction. Yet popular culture and intellectual narratives have us fearing the rise of machines against us. This frame projects the destruction of the human species while ignoring the true catastrophe which is the structural erasure of the human world.</p><p>The film Project Hail Mary depicts in an uncanny way how interaction is the foundation of co‑constructed reality. The story follows Ryland Grace, a lone astronaut sent to save Earth, who unexpectedly encounters Rocky, a non-human, and together they must cooperate despite their totally different origins. It would appear that Rocky enters the human world of <em>meaning-building </em>interaction, the instrument through which relational models emerge. But this reading is only half true. Yes, Rocky does enter the world inhabited by humans, yet that world is not uniquely human, because interaction is not a human trait or skill but an objective unit of reality. Although humans require interaction to exist and evolved the relational models as a survival kit to navigate a hostile world, interaction itself remains the condition under which any shared world becomes possible.</p><p>Project Hail Mary cinematically exhibits the evolutionary cost of interaction. Co-creation of meaning powered by interaction is fragile. It must be built through enormous work. In the film, Grace must risk his life merely to receive a single message, stepping into open space and reaching the furthest extent of his harness to catch a sealed container of communication he cannot yet interpret. Interaction precedes communication, and the film makes this palpable: from the initial non‑verbal exchanges to the slow construction of shared signals, schemas, expectations, and obligations, all the way to language and finally coordinated problem‑solving.</p><p>Even if we flip the script and assume the anthropocentric interpretation that Grace’s entire encounter with Rocky was a hallucination, produced by isolation — just as Tom Hanks’ character turns a volleyball into Wilson in <a href="https://www.imdb.com/de/title/tt0162222/">Cast Away</a> — the requirement for interaction remains constant.</p><p>Before the mission, Ryland was an overenthusiastic high school science teacher, and the final scene shows him on Rocky’s planet teaching a group of Adrian children in a makeshift classroom. This could be interpreted literally: he survived and travelled with Rocky. It can also be interpreted as a hallucination: Ryland must simulate interaction to stay alive; to exist at all. When interaction is absent, the mind generates it because humans cannot exist without it.</p><p>That is how important interaction is. Once interaction becomes the unit of analysis, it becomes clear that intelligence and consciousness obscure understanding of the human. In a recent <a href="https://www.bigtechnology.com/p/nobel-prize-winner-geoffrey-hinton">podcast</a>, Geoffrey Hinton views the ability to understand jokes as one of the most unsettling aspects of AI. The other is the sheer speed and scale at which AIs can share information, billions of times faster than humans.</p><p>As Elon Musk <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-human-computer-communication-sounds-like-whale-speech-ai-2019-8">notes</a>, human speed may appear to AI the way trees appear to us. However, from the perspective of coordination, AI itself is tree‑like. Apart from humans, everything else — bacteria, fungi, plants, insects, and now AI — coordinates without interaction. Their coordination is interactionless.</p><p>In this sense, humans are the outliers. Everything else operates through interactionless, optimization‑driven coordination.</p><p>Humans are the outliers because AI, like an ant colony, coordinates in an algorithmic manner. Here we land directly into a Zizekian parallax gap. To AI, humans appear as trees, while to humans AI appears tree‑like. These are two perspectives that cannot be merged into a single higher view, yet both are true and describe the same reality from incompatible angles²³.</p><p>The idea of non‑humanity walks in the footsteps of Copernicus and Darwin, who decentered humans in nature. AI is our portal into this decentering. It reveals that consciousness, the soul, or intelligence are neither evidence for human reality nor the elements that constitute it. Prometheus’ fire is interaction; wisdom and technology follow from it. Humans are distinct in one respect only: the acquisition of symbolic interaction.</p><p>Symbolic interaction through language makes social coordination possible through shared knowledge of what works and what doesn’t. It is the point where shared knowledge becomes a universal human capacity. Without these capacities, no reality can be built. Reality is socially constructed, not as manufacturing consent, but as the minimal condition of the human world. There is no ghost in the human machine; only a shared world produced through interaction, reducible to four relational models that organize human coordination.</p><p>Intelligence is easier to disentangle than consciousness when it comes to AI. As Anil Seth argues, conscious <a href="https://www.noemamag.com/the-mythology-of-conscious-ai/">AI is a myth</a>. His approach remains within brain science, based on predictive processing, where perception is modeled as controlled simulation. But perception is still an internal model, it cannot cross the boundary into interaction. It explains how experience is constructed, not how a shared world is built.</p><p>Once reality is treated as an internal model, it becomes open to manipulation by any power capable of shaping that model²⁴. Perception turns into a surface for managing emotion, cognition and reputation. And this is precisely what obscures the structural clarity needed to understand AI’s encroachment into the human world.</p><p>Carissa Véliz is precise about prediction; it is never neutral²⁵. It is a mechanism of power. Modern algorithms operate like oracles, shaping expectations, frames, and reputations. The same logic that underlies propaganda in public relations, if reality is internal, then whoever configures perception configures reality. Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. One man’s food is another man’s poison. Perception is volatile; relationships are stable. Perceptions are subjective, they vary from person to person. A break in authority, reciprocity, or communal sharing is an objective event²⁶.</p><p>When we fall asleep, we vanish from the world and then return. When we ask whether someone is conscious we mean are they there? Consciousness basically means presence. Seth is right, AI will never be conscious, but it is not the decisive point. The human world is not built out of consciousness; it is built out of interaction. That is the blind spot in the consciousness lineage.</p><p>In making sense of AI, media theory is the missing link. It is the framework that synthesises what cognitive science, neuroscience, psychology, and sociology each grasp only in fragments. Media theory begins with interaction, how technologies mediate, why they are used, what forms they take, and what effects they produce. Besides, media is, in a structural sense, the lifeblood of society: the infrastructure through which social life circulates.</p><p>Why focus on AI notetakers when AI safety proponents such as Dario Amodei <a href="https://darioamodei.com/post/policy-on-the-ai-exponential">warn</a> that frontier systems may soon resemble weaponizable nuclear materials, capable of automated biological threat design, AI‑enabled cyber‑offense, and other catastrophic risks?</p><figure><img alt="Humanitas — photo by Ioannis A." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Ntn0WOjCafc8BOwf.jpeg" /><figcaption>Humanitas — photo by Ioannis A.</figcaption></figure><p>AI notetakers are interaction‑substitution devices. They register information through external capture, the only mode of input available to AI systems. Notetakers may seem like a trivial manifestation of AI, a non‑threatening addition to the corporate toolkit. Yet they show, in the most accessible way, how the erasure of interaction is already underway. When Pope Leo XIV expresses fears about human dignity, this is what he is really talking about.</p><p><em>An earlier version of this article was first published on </em><a href="https://open.substack.com/pub/ioannisakingonte/p/the-erasure-of-interaction?r=5cn61v&amp;utm_campaign=post&amp;utm_medium=web&amp;showWelcomeOnShare=true"><em>Substack</em></a></p><p>Title Image: “Socks” — Artwork by <a href="https://www.instagram.com/lola_k_studio">Lola K.</a></p><p>¹ Fiske, A. P. (1991). Structures of social life: The four elementary forms of human relations</p><p>² A totalizing “one model” can take many forms such as tribalism, fascism, techno-feudalism. The structure is: one logic or model expands until it organizes everything</p><p>³ ​​Zizek, S. (2008). Violence: Six sideways reflections</p><p>⁴ I owe the ideas from Bowen Family Systems Theory to Aaron’s Substack</p><p>⁵ Communal Sharing, Authority Ranking, Equality Matching, and Market Pricing</p><p>⁶ I owe this idea to Alan P. Fiske for sending me a transcript to his new article “Why just these four”.</p><p>⁷ The relational models form the basis of human reality, and humanity depends on maintaining tension among them rather than allowing any single model — such as Market Pricing — to organize all domains of life.</p><p>⁸ Fiske, A.P. (2025) Representing Relationships: Modes of Cognition and Connection</p><p>⁹ Through communication</p><p>¹⁰ Over generations, the most effective ways humans coordinated spread culturally until natural selection gradually encoded them into our biology through <a href="https://sas-space.sas.ac.uk/889/1/D_Papineau_Baldwin..pdf">Baldwinian genetic assimilation</a>.</p><p>¹¹ Bees (some wasps) and ants achieve this through stigmergy</p><p>¹² Through quorum sensing</p><p>¹³ Through mycorrhizal fungal networks or wood wide web. See Wohlleben, P. (2016) The Hidden Life of Trees</p><p>¹⁴ I use machines to refer to devices whose main function is mechanical rather than computational; computers are a specialised subset built for information processing.</p><p>¹⁵ Kiousis, S. (2002) Interactivity: a concept explication. <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/238430196_Interactivity_A_Concept_Explication">New media &amp; society, 4(3), 355–383</a></p><p>¹⁶ Jensen, J.F. (1998) ‘Interactivity’: tracking a new concept in media and communication studies’<a href="https://compart.uni-bremen.de/content/4-teaching/0-wintersemester-2019-20/1-introduction-to-digital-media/3-material/text_int3a_jenseninteractivity.pdf"> Nordicom Review 19: 185–204.</a></p><p>¹⁷ The Shannon–Weaver model</p><p>¹⁸ Ryle, G. (1949) The Concept of Mind</p><p>¹⁹ There is no reciprocity because the system does not recognise, adjust to, or participate in the human process of meaning‑making</p><p>²⁰ The relational model based on proportional exchange is Market Pricing; its institutional expression is capitalism</p><p>²¹ Pfaller, R. (2017) Interpassivity: The Aesthetics of Delegated Enjoyment</p><p>²² The Christian idea “born again” symbolically simulates dying without requiring the believer to bear Christ’s burden, functioning like canned laughter that performs enjoyment on the subject’s behalf</p><p>²³ Žižek, S. (2006) The Parallax View. Žižek defines the parallax gap as “the confrontation of two closely linked perspectives between which no neutral common ground is possible</p><p>²⁴ This is the classic terrain of media theory: agenda‑setting, framing, priming, and the entire repertoire of perception management from news to public relations to social media</p><p>²⁵ This is the classic terrain of media theory: agenda‑setting, framing, priming, and the entire repertoire of perception management from news to public relations to social media</p><p>²⁶ Misunderstandings in relational models often escalate into conflict. When one party assumes Communal Sharing and the other applies Market Pricing, or when Authority Ranking is violated, the mismatch is experienced as a breach, not a mood. RMT treats these breaks as objective events in social coordination</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f41e6bea7d1b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://read.misalignedmag.com/the-erasure-of-interaction-f41e6bea7d1b">The Erasure of Interaction</a> was originally published in <a href="https://read.misalignedmag.com">Misaligned</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Symbolic Conflict and Strategic Communication]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/symbolic-conflict-and-strategic-communication-98c86a45b9d7?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/98c86a45b9d7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Feb 2026 19:13:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-25T14:46:48.157Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/920/0*Fr7FObb55EBJLUcx" /></figure><p><strong>The Framework<br></strong>The dispute between Seun Kuti and the Wizkid brand was quickly flattened into celebrity noise. Most coverage treated it as a cultural flare‑up over a sanitized version of Fela’s legacy, stripped of its revolutionary edge and reduced to spectacle, judged by surface details rather than the struggle that shaped him. But moments like this are never just entertainment. They expose tensions a society prefers not to confront. Now that the dust has settled, it’s worth looking again, not at the gossip but at the communication strategy Seun deployed and the symbolic effects it generated within the media environment.</p><p>My account draws partly on direct observation of the seven Instagram Lives, which I treat as data rather than celebrity content. My interest lies in the mechanics of that strategy: how a perceptually smaller voice can challenge a dominant one through disruptive, high‑intensity communication. These techniques can generate effects that resemble the communicative logic traditionally associated with terrorism. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/6839155/A_view_of_terrorism_from_a_strategic_communication_perspective_A_foundation_for_terrorism_research_in_Nigeria">In earlier work</a>, I approached terrorism as a form of strategic communication. Here, I extend that framework toward what I call non‑violent terrorism: a communicative intervention that produces rupture, pressure, and narrative shift without physical harm.</p><p>This term sounds contradictory only if one assumes terrorism is defined by violence. It is not. Terrorism is first and foremost a communicative act. A message can mirror its structure and effects without producing a single casualty. The paradox dissolves once we understand terrorism as a communicative logic rather than a moral category. This essay concerns that logic and how it appears, safely and non‑violently, in the public square.</p><p>Non‑violent terrorism functions like terrorism in structure, not in force. It is not non‑violent extremism, hate speech, radicalization, symbolic terror, structural violence, or psychological operations. It is not an ideology. It is a communication system in which the disruptive force is symbolic rather than physical. The design parallels violent terrorism because it is targeted, symbolic, coercive in its communicative pressure, and intended to shift perception or expose a schism.</p><p>Like its violent counterpart, non‑violent terrorism relies on a two‑tier targeting structure. The symbolic target absorbs the initial strike, but the communicative pressure is directed elsewhere. The aim is not to harm the symbolic target but to summon the actual target into a reactive posture. By destabilizing or provoking the real target, the act seeks to expose a weakness, force a miscalculation, or reveal a hidden schism. This secondary‑target mechanism is central to its communicative power.</p><p>Non‑violent terrorism is the deliberate use of symbolic acts or communicative pressure to induce fear, uncertainty, or strategic concession in a target audience without physical violence, often by striking a symbolic proxy in order to provoke or destabilize the actual target.</p><p><strong>The Escalation<br></strong>The recent escalation is not the beginning of this conflict. Pressure had been building long before it broke into view. I will not recount the full history of Fela Kuti, his political activism, or the complexities of Nigeria’s cultural landscape. Instead, I focus on the immediate and less visible elements that intensified the exchange — particularly the period surrounding the announcement that Fela would receive a Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award. That moment acted as a catalyst, sharpening existing sensitivities and pushing the dispute toward its tipping point.</p><p>Call it fan culture, PR machinery, media hype, or checkbook journalism; two circulating claims acted as the real provocation: that “new Felas” are emerging (most notably Burna Boy) and that “Wizkid is greater than Fela.” To Seun, these statements are not organic fan reactions; they carry the fingerprints of organized influence. On Day 5 — in a Live titled Oloriburuku FC: Destroy the Destroyers — he described how certain fan or digital formations operate less like communities and more like hired PR engines, digital force‑multipliers capable of shaping narratives with the precision of a political consultancy.</p><p>He went further, drawing a line between the current moment and earlier episodes in Nigeria’s digital public sphere — from End SARS to Mohbad to the Peter Obi wave — suggesting that the same machinery resurfaces whenever cultural or political legitimacy is at stake. Whether one accepts this interpretation or not is less important than recognizing that, for Seun, these patterns form a coherent structure rather than isolated incidents. These arguments, along with a defence of the meaning of Fela’s work, form the core of Seun’s seven‑day communication sequence on Instagram Live.</p><p><strong>The Seven‑Day Theory<br></strong>It would elongate this analysis far too much to do justice to every point he dissected across the seven days. But the structure of his escalation carries a familiar cultural resonance. In hip‑hop mythology, “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Don_Killuminati:_The_7_Day_Theory">The Don Killuminati: The 7 Day Theory</a>” — Tupac’s first posthumous album and the last shaped by his creative input — was recorded in a single burst: three days of recording and four days of mixing, a compressed cycle where urgency, clarity, and confrontation fused into one coherent edifice. Seun’s sequence echoes that rhythm: each broadcast sharpening the last, widening the audience, and increasing the symbolic pressure.</p><p>Across the seven days, he moved from artistic critique to generational tension, exposed the machinery of digital amplification, named proxy forces, and ultimately challenged Wizkid’s symbolic authority. The escalation was deliberate, cumulative, and structurally precise.Its effects align with the communicative architecture outlined earlier:</p><ul><li>Symbolic fear or discomfort — pressure without physical force</li><li>Agenda‑setting — the act compels public focus</li><li>Delegitimization — pushing the target into a defensive posture</li><li>Reframing of meaning — shifting debates toward influence, legacy, and leadership</li><li>Exposure of contradictions — generational tension, class anxiety, celebrity politics</li><li>Mobilization — rallying supporters and reframing the terrain of the dispute</li><li>Destabilization of the symbolic order — forcing a confrontation that would not have occurred otherwise</li></ul><p>Seun Kuti’s media campaign operates through this structure: a sequence of symbolic strikes designed to shift meaning, expose contradictions, and trigger a legitimacy contest.</p><p><strong>The Analogy<br></strong>A principle from classical terrorism studies helps clarify the structure: the act is the message. In violent terrorism, the communicative force is carried by physical harm. But the underlying logic — asymmetry, symbolic targeting, narrative disruption — does not depend on violence. It depends on structure.</p><p>So we ask a different question: How does power behave when its advantage lies not in force but in scale?</p><p>The answer is that the conflict shifts into the symbolic realm. The battlefield becomes visibility, legitimacy, narrative, and perception. This is the conceptual pivot from terrorism to non‑violent terrorism. The struggle is for meaning, for interpretation, for the terrain of ideas. It is both the method and the objective.</p><p>A single violent case illustrates the communicative logic clearly. The <a href="https://irp.fas.org/world/para/aceh.htm">Free Aceh Movement (GAM)</a> from Indonesia rarely had the capacity to defeat the Indonesian military. Instead, they relied on symbolic actions: selective attacks on state infrastructure, public declarations, and strategic disruptions. Their aim was to force Jakarta to recognize Acehnese identity and to internationalize the conflict. The violence was a message.</p><p>A single non‑violent case shows the same logic without force. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End_SARS">#EndSARS (Nigeria)</a> relied on symbolic communication: livestreams, hashtags, public testimonies, and decentralized coordination. Its power came from narrative control rather than confrontation.</p><p>These examples illustrate a simple structural truth: when actors cannot confront power physically, they confront it symbolically.</p><p>The battlefield becomes narrative, legitimacy, and public perception.</p><p>In symbolic conflicts, “the state” is not defined by morality or political authority but by scale, machinery, and narrative dominance. By this measure, Wizkid occupies the position of the state. His fan base operates with the coherence of a digital bureaucracy: coordinated, disciplined, and capable of amplifying or suppressing narratives at scale. In symbolic terms, Wizkid represents established power.</p><p>Seun, by contrast, occupies the position of the revolutionary force. Not because he is marginal — he is not — but because he stands outside the dominant machinery of contemporary Afrobeats culture. His authority is historical, intellectual, and ideological rather than numerical. He does not command the algorithms; he confronts them. His Lives function as symbolic interventions, attempting to disrupt a narrative ecosystem that does not naturally bend toward him.</p><p>Seen through this lens, the seven‑day barrage was not simply a rant. It was a strategic communication cycle: a sequence of symbolic acts designed to challenge an entrenched narrative order. And the response from the other side followed a familiar pattern: dismissive insults, diminishing rhetoric, and quickly deleted falsehoods — the kind of reaction that seeks to belittle the critic rather than engage the critique<strong>.</strong></p><p><strong>The Media</strong><br>A brief scan of Nigerian online newspapers and social platforms shows a clear asymmetry in framing. Traditional outlets softened Wizkid’s position by paraphrasing his responses rather than quoting the more abrasive posts that circulated widely online. This selective reporting created a familiar pattern: a celebrity shielded by media proximity, while the critic is presented as the initiator of conflict.</p><p>The coverage also revealed a deeper schism: Fela’s revolutionary legacy remains uncomfortable terrain for mainstream media, which prefers the aesthetic icon to the political dissident. This selective memory shaped how the conflict was framed and how each actor was positioned.</p><p>Yet even with this soft protection, Seun’s intervention could not be buried. “Fela” appeared far more often in connection with Seun than with Wizkid, confirming that the symbolic lineage at stake belonged to one side only. In a media environment where “brown envelope” practices are often alleged, the inability to silence or dilute Seun’s message is striking. Part of the asymmetry is that Fela’s legacy remains a symbolic resource that cannot be neutralized by framing. Mainstream outlets can soften Wizkid’s responses, but they cannot detach Seun from the lineage he represents. Fela’s name carries a weight the media cannot bury, and that weight travels through Seun whether the industry welcomes it or not. It is this symbolic inheritance — not celebrity, not virality — that allowed his critique to cut through a landscape designed to muffle dissent.</p><p>Across social platforms, the asymmetry becomes even clearer. Wizkid FC behaves like a loyal population defending its sovereign through repetition and mockery, while Seun’s supporters engage the ideological substance. The fragmentation is real, but it does not erase the message. Seun’s critique survives because it is rooted in meaning, not celebrity — and meaning travels differently. It resists suppression, outlives the news cycle, and reopens questions the culture prefers to avoid.</p><p><strong>The Stakes<br></strong>The contest of ideas has always mattered, but the current media environment makes it far more volatile. In this environment, meaning becomes unstable. It is caught in a tension between who can speak and what is allowed to be seen; between an apparent freedom of expression and the quieter pressures that shape what actually gains visibility; between a perceived democratization that overwhelms interpretation and a renewed push toward centralized narratives in global politics. AI accelerates both tendencies, making it easier to generate misleading or synthetic content and raising the stakes of symbolic conflict by eroding the distinction between what is factual and what merely appears real. In such conditions, strategic communication becomes indispensable.</p><p>My return to the communicative logic of terrorism is not an attempt to dramatize but to clarify. In earlier work I treated terror acts as the unit of analysis; here I focus on the structure that underlies them, because that structure can be seen operating within non‑violent conflicts as well. As interpretive authority weakens, battles for legitimacy intensify and conflict assumes increasingly asymmetric forms, shaped by the imbalances that structure the arena of meaning. In this environment, legitimacy is no longer assumed; it must be contested.</p><p>Seen from this perspective, the symbolic conflict between Wizkid and Seun is not an anomaly but a visible instance of a broader pattern. What is new is not the logic but its exposure. Once online, conflicts spread quickly and become increasingly difficult to contain. Yet visibility is still shaped by platform moderation and the policies that determine what appears, and what remains online.</p><p>I use the term “non‑violent terrorism” not to provoke but because it captures a form of coercive communication for which we still lack a better name. Non‑violent terrorism is not what remains when force is absent; it is a mode of coercion in its own right. In conflicts where actors pursue communicative leverage, the decisive struggle unfolds in the symbolic arena, where meaning becomes the medium of pressure, even as physical and symbolic forms of conflict continue to coexist.</p><p>The result is a landscape in which the decisive act is interpretive: a move that reorganizes meaning, alters perception, and forces others to respond within a frame they did not choose. Under these conditions, victory is not the end of conflict but the ability to define the terms through which conflict is understood. Power now resides in the symbolic act that compels others to answer on terms they did not choose.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://open.substack.com/pub/ioannisakingonte/p/symbolic-conflict-and-strategic-communication?utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&amp;utm_medium=web"><em>https://open.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=98c86a45b9d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Every Crisis Is a Relationship Challenge]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/why-every-crisis-is-a-relationship-problem-cdb5ceafa59d?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cdb5ceafa59d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crisis-communications]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Feb 2026 23:04:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-25T18:57:03.684Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/920/0*GPnUFCszdkeU0_Sa" /></figure><p><strong>Authors note: </strong>Originally published on my Substack — <a href="https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/">https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/</a></p><p>I finished <a href="https://www.academia.edu/2483772/The_Role_of_Organization_public_Relationships_in_Crisis_Communication">my thesis</a> more than a decade ago and assumed it would fade into the background like most academic work. You submit it, defend it, celebrate, and move on. At least that’s what I thought.</p><p>It was solid work that was well received by my professor, who recently retired after a long career in crisis and war communication. I was proud of it. I knew it was bold and a bit ahead of its time, but I didn’t expect it to become the backbone of everything I’m writing today. I didn’t expect it to shape my worldview or challenge how I think about crisis, violence, legitimacy, and social order.</p><p>Yet somehow, I kept thinking about it. I kept researching it. I kept living it. I kept testing it against real life until it quietly became a framework. A reference point sitting at the back of my mind. Every time I saw a crisis unfold, every time I found myself in conflict at work or business, every time I tried to understand racial tension or cultural misunderstanding, the same ideas resurfaced. It was as if the thesis had imprinted itself on how I interpret the world.</p><p>Although I was just living, the thesis kept showing up. In corporate culture, in arguments, in moments of confusion, in the way people reacted to pressure, in how institutions communicated, in politics, in war, in films, in art, in music. Even in personal battles I haven’t fully unpacked yet, I can see the same patterns.</p><p>The funny thing is that back then, I thought I was just writing about media and crisis communication. But underneath all the academic structure, I was actually studying something much deeper. It was about relationships and how the interactions that define them shape meaning. And the more I thought about it, the deeper I went, the more I realized something else about human nature: we aren’t blank slates when it comes to relationships. We arrive on Earth with inherent ways of reading social life — patterns that operate long before we can articulate them. They function like preloaded scripts, and when those scripts are violated or misaligned, conflict isn’t far behind. That realization became the bridge between my thesis and everything I’ve explored since.</p><p>At its core, my thesis asked a simple question: How do organizations respond to crises through communication? What actually determines whether a crisis response works?</p><p>To test the idea, I ran a controlled experiment with 290 participants, using a real German transportation company as the crisis scenario. I manipulated different crisis‑response messages and measured how people reacted — trust, reputation, blame, willingness to forgive, and whether they honored the account. And after all the statistics, models, and survey data, one conclusion became impossible to ignore:</p><ul><li>The quality of the relationship an organization has <em>before</em> a crisis is the strongest predictor of how its message will be interpreted <em>during</em> one.</li></ul><p>The answer wasn’t in messaging — not in apologies, press releases, spin, or propaganda. The data told a different story. Every crisis, once you strip away the noise, is a relationship problem before it becomes anything else. Crisis communication shifts from media strategy to relational psychology the moment you see that. The facts of a crisis matter far less than the relationship the public already has with the organization. Trust, suspicion, resentment, admiration — these emotional undercurrents shape how people interpret the same event.</p><p>And the deeper I went, the more I realized something else: crises don’t just threaten organizations — they reveal them. And for some, that revelation becomes an opportunity. Some organizations even gain from it. They become clearer, sharper, more trusted. Others crack because the crisis exposes a relationship that was already weak. This pattern wasn’t limited to organizations. It applied to individuals, systems, structures, even ideas. It opened a door I didn’t know existed.</p><p>But back to the core of the thesis. Organizations lose legitimacy because the crisis reveals a relationship that was already fragile, unequal, or misaligned. And once that relationship breaks, no amount of messaging can fix it.</p><p>What’s striking is that this didn’t remain an isolated insight. In the years since, scholars across crisis communication, psychology, and organizational studies have repeatedly confirmed the same pattern; the state of the relationship predicts the outcome of the crisis far more than the message itself.</p><p>Even so, the thesis never left me. And the strange part is that the insight hasn’t aged. If anything, it has become sharper.</p><p>Artificial Intelligence doesn’t invent the confusion we’re living in. It magnifies the cracks that were already running through the system. When trust erodes, interpretation becomes unstable. When interpretation becomes unstable, meaning dissolves. And once meaning dissolves, institutions, identities, and even facts lose their grounding. Some collapse. Others harden. Others keep moving simply because they refuse to look down. If they did, they would fall just like the cartoon character running endlessly on air until it looks down.</p><p>The world is louder now, more reactive, more fragile. We’re surrounded by information, yet starving for meaning. AI accelerates everything — content, narratives, distortions, synthetic realities — but it doesn’t alter the underlying logic.</p><p>Because the real crisis is relational.</p><p>And that’s when the old thesis came back into focus. Providing a way of seeing the world that suddenly explained everything happening around us. That’s when you realize the insight from that old experiment wasn’t about crisis communication at all. It was about how humans construct reality together through interactions — and what happens when that construction breaks. Interactions determine relationships. Relationships determine interpretation and meaning. Meaning determines legitimacy. And legitimacy determines whether a system holds or collapses.</p><p>Once you see that chain, you start noticing it everywhere: in politics, in culture, in institutions. Some systems respond positively to pressure, evolving into a better, stronger form. Looking back, the thesis was a signal. In a world where reality is contested, trust is scarce, and technology amplifies everything except understanding.</p><p>This is why I’m writing.</p><p>Because the world we are developing finally made the idea unavoidable.</p><p>I’m writing from Berlin while staring at the worlds of innovation, business, and technology — close enough to feel the momentum and the disorientation that come with it. I’m surrounded by investors, builders, thinkers, and people shaping what comes next, and I keep returning to the same questions about relationships and crises. What could it mean to be human?</p><p>I’m writing not to offer a solution, but to reexamine the questions. To think in public. To theorize.</p><p>Now the real work begins.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com/p/why-every-crisis-is-a-relationship?r=5cn61v"><em>https://ioannisakingonte.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cdb5ceafa59d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lekki Toll Gate Shooting as an Act of Communication]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/the-lekki-toll-gate-shooting-as-an-act-of-communication-f1286abf1f94?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f1286abf1f94</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[endsars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nigeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diplomacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terrorism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[violence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Nov 2020 20:35:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-12T12:27:03.136Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/1*tBedw8YWc1U-jneg8pF2mA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>The shooting at the Lekki toll gate could be interpreted as an act of communication. This perspective will help us understand the event with an open mind, free of bias. In this way, we do not fall victim to burdens of proof. The facts considered will be limited to the attributes of the media event. We will solve the Lekki puzzle by determining if it was an intentional act to sway public opinion and behaviour, or an act of <a href="http://www.antoniocasella.eu/restorative/Gerber_2013.pdf">punitive</a> violence. We will understand the Lekki tollgate shooting by what it intended to accomplish. Further, I will entertain the proposition that all stakeholders active at the Lekki shooting are suspect, or may have acted in ways that can be described as terrorism. There is no smoke without fire, we say in Nigeria.</p><p><strong>What happened at the Lekki toll gate?</strong></p><p>Follow me, let us trace the smoke to its origin. Picture the Lekki shooting as a cloud of smoke. Smoke contains toxic gasses creating clouds that obstruct vision. No wonder, the term <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/smoke%20screen">smokescreen </a>is used in military terminology to describe deception and obscurity. That is a screen of smoke that camouflages activity, hindering enemy observation. In a cloud of confusion, the first step is to reduce the incident to its rawest form possible.</p><p><em>Following two weeks of #EndSARS protests, persons in military uniforms opened live fire on a group of peaceful protesters at the Lekki toll gate in Lagos, a popular protest ground.</em></p><p>After this description, it is all smoke. By smoke, I mean, how many people were killed, if any people were killed, who gave the order, who ‘invited’ the army, the time of the shooting, how many injured, who turned off the lights, were the cameras uninstalled, security cameras or tracking devices, who set the gates on fire, where the shooters Nigerian Army soldiers? Or impersonators? Was Dj Switch there?</p><p>I tuned in to the Instagram live from Dj Switch at about 7:05 p.m with 36,000 other viewers. When the broadcast ended, there were close to 180,000 Instagramers tuned in. The shooting was over, but screaming filled the background. The video was dark for the first 15 minutes. That made it additionally horrifying. We could see the front screen of her phone with a constant stream of comments, many from other celebrities. When the lights finally came on, we could see some injured people and others squatting around a barricade. I watched as they attempted to remove a bullet out from the thigh of a protester. The Nigerian Army initially denied the incident. All smoke. Almost three weeks later, the case remains inconclusive. I admit until disinformation pervaded the public sphere, I had no reason to doubt what I saw. In retrospect, I suppose, one cannot rule out the possibility of a choreographed broadcast. Which is in itself a very wild assumption, yet not impossible. If so, then this also falls into the trajectory of terrorism; by making use of terror to sway public opinion. The video felt real. As real as the moon landing in 1969. Staged or real the video is a media event. We can limit prejudice by isolating and observing the attributes of the event.</p><p><strong>Violence as an end, or as a means to an end</strong></p><p>My mission is to classify the Lekki shooting as terrorism. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/6839155/A_view_of_terrorism_from_a_strategic_communication_perspective_A_foundation_for_terrorism_research_in_Nigeria">I define terrorism</a> as a tool of strategic communication that employs the use of violence or the threat of it. A predetermination to communicate an agenda to an audience through violent acts is the defining factor of terrorism. The terrorist act and its intended audience effects constitute the core of this method of communicating.</p><p><em>Was the Lekki shooting a strategic action employed to send a message, or was it a violent action that had no other purpose but to regulate a relationship by punishment, defence, or retribution?</em></p><p>Was the shooting used to coerce audiences into taking a specific action? Aimed at influencing further behavioural changes? Or communicate fear, targeting the end of protests? If the answers to these questions are yes, we can consider the incident as a case of strategic communication. Thus, we can reject the notion that the primary objective of the Lekki shooting was to murder or harm. A classification of violence that may summon the description of massacre or genocide. The end goal of violence in conventional warfare is surrender, contrary to killing or destruction. Following a surrender, any acts of violence are considered a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_crime">war crime</a>. In a war, the Lekki Shooting would be classified as <a href="https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/customary-ihl/eng/docs/v1_rul_rule156">“willful killing” and “making demilitarized zones the object of attack”.</a></p><p>Roughly, violence is intentionally harming or killing another person. Violence is usually considered an evil action. However, according to the virtuous violence theory by <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/virtuous-violence/0BC95A5426105D04AD30DF7EFA1C0739">Fiske &amp; Rai (2015)</a>, there are various reasons humans use violence for regulating relationships with others. They explain that such violence is morally acceptable, legitimate and even obligatory. They are <em>protection</em> in the form of <em>defence</em>, and <em>punishment</em> in the form of <em>redress</em>. Most cultures understand self-preservation likewise punishment. Besides, consider the violence that is even acceptable in sports like boxing, or rugby. In most respects, terrorism is distinguishable from this ‘virtuous’ violence. Terrorist communication uses violent acts instrumentally to disseminate fear, to strong-arm a public (or many publics) into conforming with preconfigured agendas. Terrorism appears as an option in a political conflict where diplomacy is exhausted or intentionally overlooked.</p><p>In line with my quest for impartial reporting, each act of terror becomes a unit of observation. Each terror event is a statistical unit whose attributes are measurable. That is the philosophy of science I am attempting to insert into the discussion of the Lekki toll gate shooting. In any scientific research, the characteristics or attributes of an object form the basis for verifying or falsifying the accuracy of results.</p><p><strong>Results: Acts of terror or retribution</strong></p><p>What are those attributes? I want us to consider two of them. <a href="https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=325026118089094122100094074087095010034050058012070082112081122071106015085088092099038035127124020121002006071016072099124117105060069010052127002092105100007031064093039078085029000031026071025007027079023082085068066086016108117119107021018086008094&amp;EXT=pdf">Terrorist acts could be classified </a>by <em>the type of target</em> (discriminate or indiscriminate) or <em>the degree of force</em> (lethal or non-lethal). I will cross-examine these attributes against the main argument raised in this analysis. Was the shooting intended to punish? Or transmit a message to an audience?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/608/1*V3wFPpOZLlidA67C_c03lg.png" /><figcaption>Assumptions and attributes</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Assumption A:</strong> The Lekki shooting aimed to punish a violation</p><ul><li>The outcome of the ‘attack’ does not suggest the soldiers intended to kill</li><li>Video footage shows the soldiers shooting upwards</li><li>In a curfew, if law enforcement becomes overpowered, soldiers may act to disperse crowds</li><li>If the protesters violated the curfew, the proportional punishment is apprehension, not death</li><li>The protesters (victims or targets) were ‘non-combatants’</li></ul><p><strong>Assumption B: </strong>The Lekki shooting aimed at influencing public behaviour</p><ul><li>It created a maximum amount of fear, with minimum loss of life (or no loss)</li><li>Lekki toll gate is a popular target that influenced favourable media exposure</li><li>The outcome has acted as a deterrent to further protests</li></ul><p><strong>Punishment is the goal of assumption A</strong>. Punishment ranges from corporal punishment to murder, from a slap to a gang shootout, or an execution. It incorporates revenge and honour killings. If the event redresses a violation, revenge or retribution, on a large scale, it qualifies as a massacre, genocide or war crime. Remember that, war aims at enemy surrender rather than extermination. Based on the attributes of the shooting, we can refute this assumption. The victims were a heterogeneous crowd, discriminately targeted and non-combatant. This combination fails to establish a motive for the massacre. In the context of war, making non-combatants the object of attack is a war crime. Also, the video evidence contradicts the assumption that the perpetrators shot to kill. The video which appeared a day after the live Instagram footage, the soldiers appear to be dispersing a crowd. Crowd control during a curfew. Finally, the low casualty count does not support the notion that the attack aimed to obliterate a hostile, armed crowd. Assumption A is false.</p><p><strong>Transmission of a message is the goal of assumption B</strong>. It aims to influence public behaviour, the strategic use of violence as a communication medium. The intention is to disseminate fear that elicits wider behavioural ends. The Lekki shooting fits this assumption. The outcome defines its purpose, the #EndSARS protests came to an end and further protests have been deterred. The choice of Lekki toll gate is also an indicator of terrorism. Since the more popular the location, the greater the media effect. Also, the attack considered minimal damage and maximum effect of the message. The assumption is B is true.</p><p>I framed this investigation by what the shooting was intended to accomplish. This exercise in logic scrutinises the shooting by considering two hypothetical statements. As retribution or as an instrument of communication. Violence as the goal, versus violence as a means to a goal. This method of deduction has helped us conclude that the shooting was an act of strategic communication. Therefore, an act of terrorism.</p><p><strong>#EndSARS protest as terrorism</strong></p><p>I promised to entertain the idea that peaceful protests are a form of non-violent terrorism. Our definition characterizes terrorism as the strategic use of violence aimed at persuading an audience to alter opinions or behaviour. Since terrorism is a covert action, the real purpose of the event is hidden. Only the perpetrators can reveal the definitive goal of the act. That means, the perpetrators must explicitly claim responsibility. The scientific method, however, allows us to investigate terror acts by considering the attributes of the media event.</p><p>The goal of the protests was to peacefully strong-arm the Nigerian government into disbanding and prosecuting members of SARS, a notorious police unit accused of human rights violations. The government was swift to respond by dismissing SARS. Surprisingly, the protests continued, which is analogous with a hostage situation whereby the demands of the perpetrators were fulfiled yet the hostages executed. If ending SARS was not the target of the protest, then, it can be labelled terrorism. We can suggest that the protesters aimed to strategically communicate a message to audiences about overall dissatisfaction with the government; albeit non-violently. A wild presupposition would be, the protests took place in anticipation of a violent response from law enforcement. A thin line separates diplomacy from terrorism.</p><p><strong>A critique of violence</strong></p><p>I am convinced that any sort of violence is immoral. Hurting or killing is inherently wrong. Nonetheless, in many facets of social life, especially in history, violence has been used to repair, regulate, initiate, as well as terminate relationships. When a relationship ‘contract’ is breached, people have determined it moral, just, necessary, obligatory, and virtuous to repair the relationship through violence. To make things right. From self-defence, to honour, dignity, retribution, gang initiation, martial arts, human or animal sacrifice and so on, “people often feel — and explicitly judge — that in many contexts it is <em>good</em> to do these kinds of violence to others… hurting or killing others is not only justifiable, it is absolutely, fundamentally <em>right.”</em> <a href="http://www.apple.com/uk">Fiske &amp; Rai (2005)</a>. A hard proclamation to swallow. But it is true. Most violence is motivated by morality, those who enact violence, base their actions on moral rights. Thus, to understand and mitigate violence in society, we must understand what motivates people to be violent.</p><p><strong>A critique of terrorism</strong></p><p>I claim that terrorism is an instrument of strategic communication. I have always suspected that conventional definitions are inaccurate in their descriptions of terrorism. I am suggesting that terrorism is diplomacy, and diplomacy is terrorism. A thin line draws the boundary of these two poles, a pair of identical opposites. They are both devices of communication. The challenge to academics, philosophers, conflict managers and thinkers is to consider <a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/diplomacy">diplomacy</a> and terrorism as opposites of the same concept. Propaganda, psychological operations, marketing, public relations, political campaigning, shootings, bombings, debates, round table discussions, negotiations, highjacking, assassination, are variations of both terrorism and public diplomacy. Hence, I declare that all forms of persuasive communication are terrorism. Any attempt to sway public opinion is an act of terrorism.</p><p>Terrorism overshadows public diplomacy in conflict resolution and vice versa. If you agree that the threat of terrorism increases as diplomacy decreases, then we can ascertain that they are both mechanisms of political communication. These mechanisms are available as persuasive tools in any political system. When the political process faces injustice, repression of political voice, broken electoral systems, unfree media, the suppression of political expression and the disenfranchisement of the electorate, violent terrorism may emerge. In volatile regions of the world, as diplomacy in the political sphere reduces, the option to employ terrorism as a <em>communication tool</em> becomes a viable option for both state and non-state actors.</p><p>The desire for public communication forms the bond between terrorism and (public) diplomacy. The use of violence distinguishes diplomacy from terrorism. Hence, we can attribute all persuasive communication as instances of terrorism. Non-violent versus violent terrorism. We can eliminate diplomacy from our lexicon. Diplomacy is only a sugarcoated word for terrorism, a politically correct expression for terrorism.</p><p>I admit that it is not an easy task to redefine a word that has defined much of human political relations. Jesus Christ, Che Guevara, Nelson Mandela, Malcolm X, Martin Luther King were all at some point considered terrorists. I claim, Gandhi, Mark Zuckerberg, Steve Jobs, Galileo, Thomas Edison, and anyone else who challenged the status quo are terrorists. Anyone that used persuasive communication to change the world, or to liberate is a terrorist. So, he who is not a terrorist should please, cast the first stone!</p><p>Every unorthodox method of persuasive communication is a liable candidate for terrorism. Every unconventional revolutionary idea is an act of terrorism. Every form of violence, whose end goal is <em>not</em> to harm or kill, or fix a relationship violation is terrorism. Every violent act that objectifies victims as a means to communicate a message is an act of violent terrorism, from domestic to political violence. Violence is what makes terrorism a crime. It is not a crime to persuade a public. It is a crime when the methods of persuasion are lethal.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>My duty was to determine that the shooting at Lekki was an act of terror. My assignment was not to determine the identity of the perpetrators. That goes beyond my mission. Terrorists are proud of their accomplishments. They usually claim responsibility and issue ultimatums. At the time of writing, the Lekki shooting remains a mystery. No one has claimed responsibility. Also, no report has endeavoured to call the incident an act of terror.</p><p>The Lekki shooting was strategic communication. As such, it qualifies as terrorism. We know this because we judged the case through the attributes of the media effects. We studied the event by considering the goals it accomplished. Since the end goal was not murder, the end goal was to disseminate a preconceived message.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*ydzEIr_-nb7sz5-3khDvwg.png" /><figcaption>Terrorism motives and outcomes</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f1286abf1f94" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My dream of a demilitarized Nigerian society]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/my-dream-of-a-demilitarized-nigerian-society-f192be6a3501?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f192be6a3501</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nigerian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nigeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[manifesto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[endsars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Oct 2020 15:36:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-23T16:46:07.583Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Demilitarizing Nigeria</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/1*DGDYxFOj4qYhPfQ4LdP7zA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Nigeria has been in a state of <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1ckph37">war since 1966</a>. Following 21 years of democracy, most aspects of Nigerian life remain militarized. I wish to grapple with the militarization of the Nigerian society, wrestle with political change, and combat the problem of Nigeria given the #Endsars protests. I aim to convince you that the problem of Nigeria is the militarization of the basic domains of our social life. I support the claim that this development was a premeditated strategy of the colonial rulers to divide and rule. It is the instrument of colonial control that has been hijacked by Nigeria’s ‘elite class’. I am instigating political change by countering this mechanism of domination. First, I have to explain to you how the militarization of Nigeria functions, and how the #EndSars protests have once again, exposed the dystopian nature of the Nigerian society.</p><h3>The meaning of Militarization</h3><p>When we speak of militarization we think of uniforms and roadblocks. We think of frontlines, armoured tanks, fighter jets, bombs and assault rifles. Militarization, however, is also profoundly, a state of mind. A state of how we run our daily life. A state of affairs whereby a military arrangement defines the architecture of our social relations and social institutions.</p><p>Militarization is founded on principles of <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/virtuous-violence/0BC95A5426105D04AD30DF7EFA1C0739"><em>authority ranking</em></a>. The moral motive of authority ranking is hierarchy. Social groups under this model are ranked linearly, creating a chain of subordination that is rigidly maintained. Subordinates are motivated to obey the will of their superiors. Superiors are obliged to guide and protect their subordinates. That is the contract that sustains this category of human relationships. We understand the relationship between a king and a servant, pupil and teacher, or God and man. We grasp it in the same way that we understand a hierarchy in the military. All humans, in all cultures, comprehend this fundamental category of how we relate to one another. The hierarchical order is not an immoral way of coordination. Hierarchy is not necessarily<a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/virtuous-violence/0BC95A5426105D04AD30DF7EFA1C0739"> exploitative or even undesirable</a>. Contrariwise, hierarchies are desirable under many domains of life. Authority executed through a hierarchy is one of <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1454904/">four other elementary forms of <em>social relations</em></a> (how we understand our dealings with one another). Aside from hierarchy, There are three more ways all humans, in all cultures, understand one another.</p><p>Unity. Equality. Proportionality.</p><h3>The elementary models of social relationships</h3><p>We understand <em>unity</em>, in terms of family and strong<em> in-group</em> bonding. Everyone instinctively understands community and bloodline. Secondly, we figure out <em>equality</em> in terms of evenness and balance. Equality means reciprocity. Everyone understands turn-taking or equal voice and opportunity, or eye-for-eye, sow and reap. We also know <em>proportionality</em>, in terms of cost and benefit. The human trait that sustains capitalism. We understand ratios, rates, metrics in the marketplace, taxes, salaries, merit, or effort. Commodities that are otherwise non-comparable, are scaled and exchanged. For instance, the exchange of labour for time, itself proportional to wages. Or proportional punishment for a crime, such as jail sentence for burglary, rape or murder. Thus:</p><p>Unity. Hierarchy. Equality. Proportionality.</p><p>Community. Authoritarianism. Egalitarianism. Market ratios, respectively.</p><p>These are the algorithms that control human interaction. Most social activities, in all societies, are coordinated just under these four preliminary, innate (God-given or evolutionary) models of social relationships. We use just these <a href="https://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/anthro/faculty/fiske/relmodov.htm">four mental models </a>to generate, understand and evaluate interaction. A violation of these models, interpreted through cultural contexts, inevitably leads to conflict and are exhibited through diverse situations in our societies. When a social contract becomes violated, participants become prompted to fix, sanction or end the relationship. When perceptual, social or cultural accords are breached, to the extent that rectification becomes necessary, violence may emerge as an option for resolution. Thus, conflict resolution is rooted in how people construct and perceive their relationship with other people. Guns do not kill people. People kill people. When a friend pays for a round of beers in a society that operates through matching equality the other participant is obliged in time to reciprocate the gesture. Neglecting this <em>social code</em> may lead to a strain in the relationship. The opposite occurs in a society (or relationship) dictated by community or unity. A friend may pay for your dinner on many occasions without expecting or calculating reciprocity ( Mi casa es su casa). In that case, demanding reciprocity may hurt the relationship. This is a simple example of relationship dynamics in daily life. However, it drives home the logic. Disregarding these codes of conduct in social relations leads to conflict.</p><h3>Social relationships and conflict in society</h3><p>When we are confronted with conflict in society, we have to ask ourselves: how are participants in a relationship violating the universal codes of conduct dictated by a computational mechanism that is constantly in operation in the human mind of every human being in every social interaction?</p><p>My ambition with this article is to demonstrate that the relationship of Nigerian citizens to the state and its institutions is militarized. That is, it is based on a rigidly maintained hierarchical structure. The economy, family, education and legal structures are all militarized. The brutal mechanisms that were used to crush the peaceful #EndSARS protests illustrate this militarism. This situation not only opposes human vales but also obstructs democratic ideals.</p><p>Unity, hierarchy, equality and proportionality.</p><p>These are the four mental schemas that are constant among all humans. They are not learned. They precede human birth. They are hardcoded into our mental processing capabilities, akin to algorithms that run computers. Philosophers dating back to Aristotle propose that human nature (or personality) is shaped entirely by experience rather than any preexisting mechanisms. They claim that when a baby is born, the mind is blank, like a new sheet of paper. Whatever is imprinted on the mind of the baby will determine who they become. Known as the blank slate or <a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/tabula-rasa">tabula rasa</a>, it explains how human personality and behaviour emerges. The tendency to be good or evil, the tendency to be a killer or healer. It explains the fundamental way humans learn and produce knowledge. The blank slate states that we are a result of our experiences. That, humans, are born without in-built mental content. The arguments I present about our human relational models both challenge and fulfil the blank slate. Although humans are not born with mental content, we are born with a mental model that instinctively and continually assesses incoming content. I agree with the philosophers like John Loche. Everything we know, we learn through external stimuli. However, this explanation cannot singlehandedly help us deal with the issue of conflict in society. More specifically, it doesn’t help with understanding <a href="https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/02/12/can-violence-be-virtuous">why people are morally motivated to use violence as a tool to regulate a relationship</a>, for isntance, through corporal punishment. The blank slate assumes that violence can be only a result of evil, based on the prior experiences of the perpetrator. Yes, this is rather true, yet again, it does not help to explain violence as a tool for regulating relationships. Seniority, corporal punishment, public humiliation, frog jump, knelling down, picking pin, rolling in a gutter, flogging, thinking of your girlfriend, digging your height and so on. That is what I mean by the militarisation of Nigeria.</p><h3>The militarization of Nigerian society</h3><p>We have neglected unity, equality and proportionality. We apply authority propelled hierarchy, in almost all aspects of social life. This is so deep-rooted in our psyche, that it has manifested from the <em>mental realm </em>(or spiritual if you prefer) into the physical. If you have lived in Nigeria, think about burglary proofs on windows, barbed wires on fences, large gates, gated communities, armed vigilante, checkpoints, police with assault rifles, convoys, sirens or something as inconspicuous as speed bumps (interestingly speed bumps is just a militarized version of the road signage “slow Down”). Our relationships with one another and the institutions in society align with the most extreme manifestations of authority ranks. Overpowering the basic human instinct for equality, unity and proportionality. Our schools, our families, our economy, our legal institutions are all militarized. They are entirely set up in terms of hierarchy and subordination. If you notice the architecture of Nigeria’s capital, Abuja, you will quickly realise that the city is also militarized (<em>I suspect that the crescents, exit and entry points to the city were intentionally constructed to avert, plan or crush a coup d’état</em>).</p><h3>The militarization of social institutions</h3><p>According to <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1ckph37.8?seq=2#metadata_info_tab_contents">Biko Agozino and Unyierie Idem</a>, vital aspects of our social reality in Nigeria are militarized. Their ethnographic research supplies us with useful insights.</p><p>Our family structure is militarized. In his book, <a href="https://books.google.de/books/about/Fela.html?id=xbMDyvjYIyMC&amp;redir_esc=y">This Bitch of a Life</a>, Fela Kuti laments how he was beaten throughout his childhood. Children are regularly ‘dealt’ with, in Nigeria. They are always threatened with the <em>koboko. </em>A koboko is a flexible whip made of cow skin or tail that originates from the Fulani/Hausa and adopted by the military to discipline ‘unruly’ citizens.<em> </em>Women are commonly beaten by their husbands as an exercise of control. A wife, a brother, a father can be taken hostage by the police when another family member is alleged to have committed a crime. They may be held in custody until the whereabouts of their son, brother or husband is known in what can only be described as hostage negotiations or prisoner exchange. Think about it.</p><p>Our legal structures are militarized. We know from Nigerian history that military tribunals prosecuted civilians. These tribunals offered no appeal and some proceedings were done behind closed doors. The constitution was interpreted in a way that would render justice and accountability unattainable. Sani Abacha routinely used the legal system to crush his opposition. Ken Saro-Wiwa, Fela Kuti and many others were sentenced in this manner. Police officers and other ‘uniformed’ force members are scarcely prosecuted.</p><p>Our education system is also militarized. Standing attention on the assembly line, singing the national anthem, saying the pledge, marching to class, seniority, prefects, and corporal punishment are some of the edifices. Besides, the emergence of secret cults in our universities correspond with the militarisation of the Nigerian society.</p><p>The economy is possibly the most militarized of the institutions. Private commercial vehicles pay illegal police “tax”, traders are routinely harassed and extorted for various reasons, tax is collected violently, and in cash, on the road. Police or army men are hired to escort goods or vehicles, customs officers set up roadblocks, the police is <em>hired</em> to settle financial disputes, international companies possess private armed guards, the military is involved in crude oil deals, turning it into a gangster’s paradise.</p><p>Communal relations are also militarized. Disputes are settled by manipulating ethnic and religious schisms. Constituents are manipulated to disrupt elections, cattle rearers conflict with farmers, land disputes, allocation of resources, are all exhibitions of militarisation and the disregard for the peaceful resolution of communal disputes through dialogue.</p><p>Our religious institutions are militarized. Fighting spiritual warfare, blocking roads for prayers, secret cults and societies, charms and rituals for protection, the doctrine of man as the commander-in-chief of the house, prayer cells, recruiting through evangelic missions, prayer warrior, general overseer, sharia.</p><p>Ladies and gentlemen of Nigeria, our entire social reality is militarized zone. We are combatants, living in a hostile, militarized territory.</p><h3>The problem with Nigeria exposed by #EndSARS</h3><p>The problem with Nigeria is her militarisation. The <em>unspoken</em> demand of #EndSARS is precise, the demilitarization of the country. The fact is, that the peaceful #EndSARS protests were crushed by strategic use of violence and media deception. When there is a conflict of interest, the superiors must <em>call the subordinates to order</em>. The brutal response of the government exemplifies the fear of the ‘elite’ class in Nigeria. That the #EndSars protests threatened the very core of their prosperity. An order that is “<a href="https://books.google.de/books?id=42uuDAAAQBAJ&amp;pg=PA70&amp;dq=colonial+systems+of+control+attahiru+jega&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=2ahUKEwiR-LfYwd3sAhWECuwKHVBbCmoQ6AEwAHoECAYQAg#v=onepage&amp;q=colonial%20systems%20of%20control%20attahiru%20jega&amp;f=false">compounded when the government becomes even more militaristic and authoritarian in an attempt to silence dissent”</a>. Similar to the Aba women protest, the June 12 annulment, Ogoni people’s movement and the numerous other peaceful protests that have been conducted in recent Nigerian history, #EndSARS was crushed through instruments of militarization. Dampening the hopes of millions of young Nigerians. A large portion of young Nigerians , like those betwen the ages of 18–26, have only known a ‘democratic’ Nigeria. A large portion of the population also lacks historical knowledge. Nigerian political history is twisted, bloody and intriguing. No wonder that that youth equate current political discourse with Hollywood. Do not forget, the ‘youth’ is a really large group in Nigeria. <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/1121317/age-distribution-of-population-in-nigeria-by-gender/">Half of the population is under 19 years old</a>. A mere 7% of the population is above 55 years old.</p><h3>The fiction of a democracy and the reality of militarism</h3><p>The youth is under threat by an uncompromising mental virus that attacks the core of their psyche. We can understand this virus as <a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/cognitive-dissonance.html">cognitive dissonance</a>. That is, holding conflicting beliefs at the same time. The dissonace typically develops into psychological stress. In this case, the two opposing ideas are <em>militarisation</em> and <em>democratization</em>. Young Nigerians have to contend with the illusion of a democratic state while living in a militarized territory. The greatest tragedy is the disconnect of a youth body that upholds democratization from the ruling elite who administer with military-minded politics.</p><p>Following the extermination of the #EndSARS movement, we have started hearing calls for restructuring. Restructuring in the true essence of the word will usher in the Nigerian apocalypse that has the potential to alter everything that defines Nigeria. The so-called restructuring will disrupt the status quo that keeps the Nigerian population under oppression and the superiors corrupt and brutal. Just as the #EndSARS movement, this too will threaten the elite class. Restructuring means overhaul. It means radically changing the existing system. It signals a call for the demilitarization of Nigeria.</p><p>Here is the point where Nigerians begin to exercise hope, to pray or to wish. I claim that hoping is an exercise in futility. What Nigerians need is courage. The courage to persevere in the face of hopelessness. Hope is cursed and should remain locked in pandora’s box. Courage and bravery are the angels of our time.</p><h3>The problem with Nigeria</h3><p><a href="https://bigthink.com/dont-act-just-think">It is not time to act. It is time to think.</a> The task of thinkers, poets, intellectuals, writers and philosophers in Nigeria today is to<em> question the question. </em>We need to reexamine the problem of Nigeria from another view. Therefore:</p><p>What is the problem with Nigeria?</p><p>The problem of Nigeria is not Nigerians, the problem of Nigeria is not its leaders, the problem of Nigeria is not corruption, the problem of Nigeria is not colonialism, the problem of Nigeria is not SARS. These are symptoms of a much more chronic disease.</p><p>The problem of Nigeria is the militarization of society. Consequently, political change in a militarized Nigeria must, by default, require military strategies, since, any opposition will be labelled a hostile movement. A compromised electoral process invites an armed struggle. Yet, this is not the only avenue for taking over political power. The challenge facing us today is to claim political power by means of non-violence. Our task is to create the political movements that will address the problems of Nigerias commons. Political movements that will translate legitimate concerns like #EndSARS into a coherent political agenda. Political movements that will convince the electorate and win their vote. The political classes must disarm and dialogue. They must guarantee political expression.</p><p>When I close my eyes, and when I dream, what I hear when I pray for Nigeria and listen to the cries of Nigerians, what I feel when I think of the beautiful peoples and culture of Nigeria, and indeed the whole world, is a future in which the basic human instinct for unity, equality and proportionality are considered while we set up structures that counter the potential for extreme hierarchical structures to be transformed into institutions of domination and absolute power.</p><p>I dream of a demilitarized Nigeria.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f192be6a3501" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[#EndSARS protests. Five underlying points]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/endsars-protests-five-underlying-points-c0594fc9feb?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0594fc9feb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nigeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[endsars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[police-brutality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Oct 2020 18:07:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-20T18:13:30.692Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/663/1*F8uUAsICjSyY-EBHmyCS5g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Nigerians are teaching the world how to conduct a peaceful protest. Yet again, Nigerians are showing that, what the rest of the world does, can be done better. When Nigerians unite, it will be vibrant and innovative. That’s what I wrote before the protest took another less colourful direction.</p><p>Mention another spontaneous protest in history that could pressure an oppressive government into dialogue, in under a week. None? Buhari’s government responded to some demands! The abolition of Sars, the release of arrested protesters and a presidential address. Surely, it is just a hollow reaction aimed at quelling protester agitation and devoid of any sincerity. Classic Aso Rock communication. This time, however, the people are not satisfied with the rhetoric. They are not settling for yet another deja vu. Yet another <em>“We are setting up a committee” </em>that will provide another corruption-prone loophole. In fact, the protests have picked up momentum since then.</p><p>My thesis has always been that Nigeria should not only be repaired for Nigeria’s sake. Rather, Nigeria should be repaired as a contribution to global prosperity. Therefore, what the youth of Nigeria are fighting for is a better world. Once the giant wakes up from its slumber, the whole world is going to benefit. Anyone who opposes this awakening is an enemy of the world, I claim.</p><p>For this piece, I want <em>thinkers</em> to take a step back from the enthusiasm of protest. A popular Nigerian aphorism states there is<em> no smoke without fire</em>. Meaning, there is always a hidden origin to problems, inconspicuous to the observer. The moral is that we may not assess an issue (smoke) until we assess the<em> root</em> of the issue (fire). As poets, philosophers, and thinkers, we have to deal with the smoke, because that is all we have. Therefore, I will articulate five smoke signals from the #EndSARS protests.</p><ol><li>Solidarity — In my <a href="https://medium.com/@yanmeup/on-nigerian-unity-f1a3c70091ad">other article</a>, I argued that those who wish for the unity of Nigeria are actually against Nigeria. Surely, this can anger some people if taken out of context. I stated that the English language and a constitution are not an automatic source of unity. It cannot eliminate existing tribal and religious schisms. I would actually advocate maintaining those divisions and focus on what truly unites; the opportunity for every citizen to access the wealth of the nation. These protests have been depicting this reasoning. Solidarity is authentic when it is based on common problems, rather than the illusion of tribal consolidation.</li><li>Afrobeats and role of music artists — The protests became louder with a theme song. Davido’s FEM. <em>“Why everybody come de para for me”</em>. Para to the non-Nigerian audience is an abbreviation for paranoid. Contextually, a Nigerian will use the word “para” to connote unjustifiable worry. For example, “Guy, I go pay, haba! why you de para?”. In English, “I will settle the bill, no worries”. Extrapolated to the protests; why is the government paranoid? Can’t they see that the citizens are fed up? Why you de Para? Fela suffered under the strong hand of government for speaking up against injustice. Music is the weapon he claimed. The potency and weaponisation of music require a moment of delayed gratification. It takes time to permeate the subconscious of society. From instrumentation to the lyrical content, we can feel Fela’s weapon in today’s music. For instance the songs <em>“Skeletun” </em>and <em>“Sudden</em>” by Tekno. Excellent examples of the phenomenon I am describing.<em> </em>If you have not roamed the streets of Nigeria you will never understand how many times a day the average Nigerian listens to these songs. While they danced the day away, the messages got ingrained in the subconscious of the population. This is precisely what Fela meant by music is the weapon.</li><li>Past versus the present situation — Back in the late 1980s and 1990s people did not really have the will to protest. One reason was the harsh military rule. Another was the relative comfort of daily life back then. When I got into Nigeria in 1992, the price of a litre of fuel was 70 Kobo! Although public infrastructure was poor, people enjoyed some basic things in life. Our parents just didn’t have the incentive to lose their lives in a struggle. The younger generation has nothing to go back to. No jobs, no light, and on top of that, they cannot walk around freely because of the police. They are willing to go all the way.</li><li>Nigerian government response — the government lacks experience with peaceful protests. Their expertise revolves around violent unrest and the quelling of military coups. As if Nigeria is one big military zone filled with combatants. If you have not lived in Nigeria, you can never understand what it means to persevere in the face of oppression. According to Fela, we know how to “suffer and smile”. Certainly, without a central strategy to address problems in society (since any mass discontent can be quelled with state violence), the government got overwhelmed with the responsibility of responding to a peaceful protest. Mr Buhari came on television and shamelessly read a template statement that was even weaker than his demeanour. The government is organised only when it comes to embezzlement and looting. When it comes to fulfilling their duties, they all get confused and run out of options dealing with legitimate concerns. In his speech, the president gave a famous institutional defence. It is a “few bad eggs in the basket”. This is what the Vatican would say about child rape or the CIA will say about rogue agents that use ‘unconventional’ measures like torture. The protest would have been ended if this was the case. The bad eggs brought to justice and that’s it. Hollywood ending. Everybody goes back to their daily life. The #Endsars protests are addressing institutional and systemic oppression. Not just the police. Not only Sars. Sars! I will not get into the details here. Apart from the obvious chants of the population, I will add that SARS is a gun for hire. Did you get a problem with someone? SARS can be paid off to arrest and torture at affordable rates. As a matter of fact, this is how SARS got into the “Yahoo boys” syndicate. Internet fraud is a complex organisation. Ten people could be involved in a single case of <em>Yahoo</em>. When something goes wrong, someone gets greedy, guess where they go to hire some muscle? SARS!</li><li>The case of Police brutality — the rest of the world does not understand what we mean by police brutality. Perhaps, this is the reason for the weak reporting by foreign news on the topic. When Nigerians refer to police brutality they mean the whole institution is designed as a brutal force. Roadblocks are formed for the specific reason of extortion. The police boss expects a certain amount of money from each roadblock. commercial traffic <em>must </em>pay a ‘police’ tax to commute. Normal citizens also fall victim to police extortion net. It is so ingrained in us, that we actually anticipate police confrontation upon leaving the house for our daily commute.</li></ol><p>There was a joke shared in Nigeria. A Nigerian government official visits South Africa. The South African host, who is also a civil servant takes him sightseeing and shows him a bridge under construction. After revealing the cost of the project he exclaims, “10% in my pocket”. After showing a couple more projects each time, whispering to the Nigerian “10%” here and “20%” there. It happened that the South African official paid a return visit to Nigeria. During sightseeing, the Nigerian takes him to a vast piece of empty land. While the guest was wondering what he was being shown, the Nigerian official exclaims, “You see, here will be a new city… 100% in my pocket!”.</p><p>The problem is this is not even a joke. It happens all the time. The protesters will need the courage to address the Nigerian problem since it seems like a hopeless situation. Basically, if we read the book of Ecclesiastes in the old testament, we realise that indeed the whole world is hopeless. It is all vanity. Everything is vanity! What do we gain for all the toil under the sun? This is the hopelessness. A person can do nothing better than enjoy and drink and find satisfaction in their work. That is the courage in hopelessness. I will end with my favourite person Slavoj Zizek. I agree with him. Protests are great but what makes them great is not the initial enthusiasm of being out there, chanting songs of solidarity. The real work starts the day after. How do we reorganise society? How do we conduct business? and run our offices? Many people were appalled by the violence depicted in recent Joker film with Joaquin Phoenix. Their concern is that following sporadic violence, there was no positive resolution at the end of the film. No quick-fix solutions to the problem of social disorder. Dissatisfaction with the government in Nigeria is a serious problem. The Nigerian system cannot deal with gradual reforms such as transform a police unit here, increase a salary there. What we need is a radical overhaul of the system. So, are we ready to articulate the problem of our hopelessness? of our disorder? I believe the youth of Nigeria are laughing. They are exactly like the ‘Joker’ because they “have nothing to lose”.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c0594fc9feb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Nigerian Response to the #EndSARS protests]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/the-nigerian-response-to-the-endsars-protests-c62b260b9c7a?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c62b260b9c7a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lagos]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[police-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nigeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[endsars]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Oct 2020 09:17:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-04T20:08:28.492Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Analysis of the Nigerian government’s response to the #EndSARS protests:A crisis communication case</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*tMQQMpQXOuhL1PQoPi28Mw.jpeg" /><figcaption>source: Twitter</figcaption></figure><p>An examination of the crisis response from the Nigerian government on the #EndSARS protest shows a halfhearted commitment to conflict resolution. Another observation is the reluctance to dialogue with the people about legitimate concerns in society. My opinion is that this crisis is such an extreme case that no crisis response strategy is capable of deflecting the fatal reputation and legitimacy damage facing the police or the government. My premise is that a surrender to the will of the people, through dialogue, is one of only two avenues for the resolution of this crisis. The other is the suppression of the protests through violence or the threat of it.</p><p>When an organization faces a crisis, people will try to determine the cause. Then, they will attribute responsibility. People will actively seek information that will satisfy these two concerns. They will ask themselves “Who caused it?”, and “How much control did the organization have over the situation?”. Once they have established this, people will formulate perceptions and exhibit further behavioural acts; such as protests, boycott or lawsuit. The framing of the crisis by the media will determine how the crisis is perceived. Thus, information exposure plays a crucial role in crisis communication. By and large, this is the foundation of the crisis communication theory. In practice, this reasoning could be useful in developing more effective crisis responses messages. Typically from organizations to the public. The objective of such communication is to avoid reputation damage or to survive the crisis. That is, what an organization says and does after a crisis will influence its reputation as well as its legitimacy to operate in society. Crisis response is vital for organizations. Potentially, crises could cause financial damages or result in the dissolution of the organization. There are three essential components that you may note about crisis communication. Crisis response strategies, crises types, and a method for matching these two. In other words, what sort of crisis response will be effective according to what crisis typology?</p><p>Consider a hypothetical illustration. Assume that 1,000 people died near a chemical production plant. The first step in our formula will be to assign causality and assess the level of responsibility the chemical company had over the situation. The company will fall into one of the following ‘frame’ clusters. The company could be a <em>victim</em>, the event could have been an <em>accident </em>or may be perceived as a <em>preventable </em>situation. As perceptions of the responsibility increase, so does damage to the organization. A crisis that is framed as preventable will pose a high level of threat to reputation and/or legitimacy. It means that the company took intentional action that violated say, regulation or public safety. If this is confirmed, the company may be forced, in the worst case, to shut down. For example, the Goldman Sacks collapse during the financial crisis of 2008. If the company was also a victim or if the event was an accident, the company has more room to restore or at least reduce the damaging effect.</p><p>We have dealt with the crisis type. Now, we will deal with crisis response strategies. According to the theory, responses are arranged along a scale of <em>defensive</em> (prioritize the organization) to <em>accommodative</em> (prioritize the victim). These responses should correspond to the crisis type. The rationale is that matched responses will deflect the negative effects of the crisis while mismatched responses will intensify those effects. There is no one size fits all recommendation. It is situational. That means it depends on numerous factors that define the crisis. There are three ways an organization can respond to a crisis. It could <em>deny </em>involvement by, for instance, naming a scapegoat. It could <em>diminish </em>by altering perceptions about the crisis, and it could also <em>rebuild </em>by offering an apology and compensation.</p><p>These clusters are composed of more specific (and confounding) variables. An organization can rebuild its image by explicitly accepting responsibility and begin seeking ways to restore (apology and compensation) legitimacy. Next, a response may offer an apology without an explicit acceptance of responsibility. Yet again, a response may diminish responsibility by aiming to shift blame (for instance, it is not the entire police force to blame but a few bad eggs within it).</p><p>I have been explaining crisis communication theory. I have shown that the mechanism of matching crisis types to the sort of crisis response is the means through which organizations can survive a crisis. The model provides insights on <em>when </em>to choose certain response strategies<em>. </em>It falls in the realms of reputation management, conflict resolution and non-violent communication. Other factors come into play while preparing a crisis response. The most vital one is <em>relationship history. </em>Simply put, relationship history is the extent to which past interactions between the organization and the public is favourable or not favourable. The assumption is that a favourable relationship history will help the organisation through a crisis (termed the <em>halo effect</em>) while a negative history will affect the organization’s ability to manoeuvre through a crisis. Relationship history is composed of trust, commitment, satisfaction and the level of control each party has on the relationship.</p><p>In summary, <em>responsibility</em> (who is to blame) and <em>relationship history</em> are the essential factors that will determine the effectiveness of crisis response messages.</p><p>The case of #EndSars is more complicated than the hypothetical company. <a href="https://www.teenvogue.com/story/endsars-movement-nigerian-youth">The protests</a> started on October 6. The protesters gathered to protest against the alleged murders, rape, extortion and assault by SARS (Special Anti-Robbery Squad), a unit of the Nigerian Police Force. Over a short period, the ‘movement’ aligned its focus on police brutality and corruption in Nigeria. Nigerians have been protesting for years against police brutality. However, the actual event that precipitated the current demonstrations was the shooting and killing of a young boy in the city of Ughelli in Delta, one of the 36 states in Nigeria.</p><p>Considering all these points, we can assess the communication and actions of Mr Buhari’s government on the nationwide #EndSars protests. It goes something like this:</p><ol><li>The initial response was a speech (and some tweets) by Mr Buhari himself that pledged a commitment to police reforms and the termination of SARS. A few days later the formation of a new unit, SWAT was made public.</li><li>The Nigerian Army issued a warning that it may need to step in to maintain order. It also announced that it will begin a nationwide exercise called “Crocodile Smile”</li><li>Next, Vice President Osibanjo issues an apology on behalf of the President.</li><li>Some Governors and Senate call for an end to the protests</li><li>The government bans protests in Abuja due to COVID-19 violations.</li><li>Announcements of curfew in some states. Announcements of military deployment</li></ol><p>The first observation is that there is no coherent communication strategy by the government. The second observation is that the responses are mismatched. The third observation is the lack of consideration about the relationship status between the government (or police force) and the protesters. All three observations indicate that Mr Buhari’s government is not considering to dialogue with the protesters. We can assume that the strategy is to issue out a broadcast that will end the protests without resolving the crisis. That is the overall communication mismatch. And for this reason, we can witness the gradual disintegration of the crisis into the threat (and use) of violence as the only tool the government has to suppress the protest, as opposed to conflict resolution.</p><p>The dissolution of SARS indicates that the government accepts responsibility. Acceptance requires an apology and in most cases the compensation of victims. Prioritizing the public by accomodating their concerns is not always recommended. firstly, it could end up being very costly. Secondly, the public will assess the message based on the favorability or not of prior relationship. So Mr Buhari’s response is both inconsiderate (since it assumes a favourable relationship with the protesters) and as a result ineffective (apology without compensation, or prosecution of offenders). A more effective crisis response would be to accept responsibility, name the scapegoats (resignation of the Inspector General of police and other chiefs) and offer compensation (Nigeria can afford it anyway). This is where a crisis presents itself as an opportunity. Following such a resolution, the government may begin media strategies to restore its image in society.</p><p>The government’s response to the protests may be based on tactics of oppression rather than resolution. This is not an accusation. It is based on an analysis of communication that has already taken place. What I see here is neglect, lack of research, lack of empathy and a complete delusion about the relationship status between the state and the citizens. Surely, the speech aimed to calm the protesters may have worked if the protesters had trust in Mr Buhari’s government. However, the evidence for the lack of trust resides precisely in the fact that the protests carried on with even more tenacity.</p><p>Following the ineffectiveness of the initial response, the government also issued out messages about adherence to COVID-19 rules, appealing to parents for calming their children or the resumption of universities. All to ‘peacefully’ end the protests without resolving the issue. When nothing worked, the messaging started taking a more violent twist. The deployment of the army. By violence, I mean the threat of it as well. Thus, the announcement of the nationwide army exercise is in itself a violent communication strategy.</p><p>The protesters accuse the government of further manipulation. They accuse the government of staging a series of media events. The release of prisoners in Benin and the release of ‘thugs’ to attack the peaceful protesters. The consensus is that the government intends to use such acts as a pretext to delegitimise the protests and find reason to suppress the protests with force. I have omitted such angles in my analysis. The noise surrounding ‘highjacking’ of the protest is so thick, that it is hard to determine disinformation from fact. To understand crisis and violence, one must necessarily shut out emotion and sentiment. I present an analysis of the crisis response of the Nigerian government on the #EndSARS protest. I hope it explains the government’s response and how it could incorporate and even stir up further violence.</p><p>In conclusion, I want to highlight how terrorism is employed and how it emerges. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/6839155/A_view_of_terrorism_from_a_strategic_communication_perspective_A_foundation_for_terrorism_research_in_Nigeria">I define terrorism as an instrument of strategic communication</a>. Terrorism emerges in the absence of diplomacy. It emerges when consituencies unite to address common problems. When this opportunity for dialogue is crushed, conflict resolution turns violent. My duty is to provide an impartial method for judging the government’s crisis response messages in the media. This way, we can evaluate if actions taken by the government aimed at peaceful resolution or suppression. My advice is that the government should see this crisis as an opportunity to reinvent itself.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c62b260b9c7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[LOVE]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/love-f02779a3d1b?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f02779a3d1b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[thought-provoking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[berlin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poem]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 20 Aug 2020 14:57:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-23T16:54:54.528Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YINW3L3NdpJqIxz55StXuQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Happiness is for fools!</p><p>Joy is reserved for the wise.</p><p>Love is painful</p><p>Love is selfless</p><p>Love is uncontrollable</p><p>Love cannot be faked</p><p>Love must be evil!</p><p>Because, if I have to</p><p>I will destroy every living thing.</p><p>You will be the last.</p><p>And then, surrender my own life!</p><p>Because I cannot go on without you.</p><p>Blessed are those who love</p><p>For love harbours pain</p><p>For love invites suffering</p><p>For love sets the path towards freedom.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f02779a3d1b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nigerian Neo-Soul: Ticket to Anywhere EP by April Maey]]></title>
            <link>https://yannipropa.medium.com/nigerian-neo-soul-ticket-to-anywhere-ep-by-april-maey-5a5d657c22b0?source=rss-10df95349bae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a5d657c22b0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[afrobeat]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neo-soul]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ioannis Akingonte]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jun 2020 15:13:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-03T16:39:39.339Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Album Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UKJKlyCAujYSw691JrA7EQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>There’s no skipping this one. You can set this <a href="https://audiomack.com/bombshelter-digital/album/ticket-to-anywhere">five-track Album</a> to random order and it won’t change its feel. <a href="https://open.spotify.com/album/0R9Ck3LvsxIReJyhnfkf59?si=fofr9Y9IT1GhrbzWb2qmyw"><em>Ticket to Anywhere</em> </a>was released in March 2020 by April Maey. Similar to April, her music blossoms like daffodils in springtime. The dreamy character of her voice over jazzy Lo-fi beats installs a calming musical environment. The production is crisp on many levels. From the use of silence, distortion as well as the depth of backup vocals, without dampening output. The piano melodies are captivating in their simplicity. They feel familiar and new at the same time.</p><p>The track<em> Sunshine</em> particularly resonated with me. It brought to mind scenes out of a Woody Allen film. I pictured myself kissing the girl of my dreams on a rainy day in Paris, at midnight. April manages to invoke this intense feeling of love. She conveys these visuals by her confident delivery and hypnotic vocals. At its purest, love is such a powerful drug that it could overpower a fear of death. In Woody Allen’s 2011 romantic comedy <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midnight_in_Paris">Midnight in Paris</a>, the main character played by Owen Wilson is asked by the fictional Ernest Hemingway, if he has made love to a really wonderful woman, and if he is afraid of dying. After Owen answers both questions in the affirmative, Hemingway continues:</p><blockquote>“I believe that love that is true and real creates a respite from death. All cowardice comes from not loving, or not loving well, which is the same thing. And when the man who is brave and true looks death squarely in the face, like some rhino hunters I know, or Belmonte, who’s truly brave. It is because they love with sufficient passion to push death out of their minds until it returns as it does to all men. And then you must make really good love again. Think about it.”</blockquote><p>Following Hemingway’s logic, April has stepped into Nigerian music with noteworthy valiance. This is the sort of courage that is needed to carve a niche. April may as well be on her way to leading Nigerian Neo-Soul by providing a breath of fresh air to the percussion-heavy, poetically clumsy, and at times obscene Nigerian love songs. Yet, April has potential beyond the Nigerian market. Last summer in Berlin I regularly attended independent band sessions at <a href="https://www.fluxfm.de/">Flux FM’s</a> riverside venue. She would fit into this scene like a glove to a hand.</p><p>As I searched for her music on Spotify the first time, I landed on Billie Holiday. I had typed <em>‘April’ </em>and the song <a href="https://open.spotify.com/track/34zhjduFdQFhkRUJ230h9T?si=tfjhSFoDRcGXswEbKJgDJw">April in Paris</a> popped up as a suggestion. This is where I distinguish April from other Afropop singers like Tems, Niniola, and Tiwa Savage. It is her almost painless delivery and her delicately coarse voice. This is a God-given trait, something like that of the late <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guru_(rapper)">Guru from Gangstarr</a>. RIP.</p><p>At just 13 minutes playtime, one could effortlessly listen to the EP twice over. Credit should go to the producers for ensuring that the sounds land smoothly upon your ear. Her first single <em>Whispers </em>from 2019 is equally satisfying. The song addresses infidelity with an undertone of female empowerment (intended or otherwise). The rap verse is also very good. Citymonstar whom she also features in the song <em>somebody </em>polishes off the hip hop vibe.</p><p>There is a certain unobtrusive feminist tone to her that I genuinely appreciate. I say this while considering extreme feminists, who, for instance, do not shave bodily hairs as an act of rebellion towards men. Is this not a cruel approach to the advocacy of women’s rights? A feminist once enlightened me on the egalitarian goals of feminism. This includes animal rights, men’s rights, racial equality, and so on. In this sense, I am a feminist all the way.</p><p>That is why the song <em>Nothing’s Over</em> won me over<em>. </em>It is her<em> </em>deliberate emotional expression towards some hypothetical guy, during a breakup, that is liberating. She takes complete control, rendering the man passive in the situation. I believe this is more empowering than the belligerent approach of remaining unshaven. The reason is that it negates the need to seek men’s approval. The same goes for the fight against racial discrimination. True emancipation should not rest on concepts of <em>tolerance </em>as suggested by the shaving example. That is, basing that action on men’s disapproval. Think about it. How can we translate the problem of sexism or racism as a problem of tolerance? Just imagine Martin Luther King Jnr.<a href="https://bigthink.com/videos/slavoj-zizek-on-political-correctness"> proclaiming that white people should tolerate black people in America</a>. To him, that would be a ridiculous and obscene statement.</p><blockquote>“The struggle against racism is not a struggle for tolerance, but for social, economic, political, and cultural rights, and for changing unjust and undemocratic power relations. Zizek makes a parallel with feminism, asking if feminists struggle to be ‘tolerated’ by men. Of course not — from this perspective, the concept of tolerance even becomes rather ridiculous. Tolerance, in other words, does not work as an imperative for political struggle.” (<a href="https://pure.uva.nl/ws/files/922535/79551_314671.pdf">Mepschen, P., 2009</a>)</blockquote><p>Do not let this extended analysis distract you. This is an excellent EP that will unquestionably vivify your summer.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a5d657c22b0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>