<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Seth Abramson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Seth Abramson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@Seth_Abramson?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 01:38:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@Seth_Abramson/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Metamodernism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Seth_Abramson/on-metamodernism-926fdc55bd6a?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/926fdc55bd6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metamodernism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[twitter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-foster-wallace]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Apr 2018 04:51:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-16T17:28:47.757Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*2VXVl-S1dK8DImBUzqOEVg.jpeg" /><figcaption>David Foster Wallace, who in 1990 equated artistic rebellion with being laughed at.</figcaption></figure><p>As a kid I was a loner. Not shy, quiet, or reserved — a loner. I wanted to be alone. I’d decided that to be seen in public was to be <em>reduced</em> in some way.</p><p>Many years later, I read Edward Dorn’s post-hippie verse epic <em>The Gunslinger</em>. In it, Dorn equates naming something to killing it. I suppose that’s how I felt about being around other people in the 1980s — like it was actually killing me. In public I was a Jew, a Polack, short, and a host of other things which at the time were pejoratives. These were elements of my identity that I never really thought much about when I was alone, but was constantly reminded of in company. In the 1980s in rural Massachusetts, a Jewish boy was considered by his peers to be non-white, and anyone of Polish descent (which I was) an imbecile. Being short was likewise presumptively bad, as if there’s one thing boys in the 1980s knew, it was that “real” (masculine) men weren’t short.</p><p>So I kept to myself outside of school. I had a few in-school friends, and a few extracurricular activities that my mother — fearing I was turning into myself, like a nautilus — pushed me into. What I really wanted was to be in my room with the door locked. Alone, unknown, unnamed — and therefore anything or anyone. I associated self-confinement with freedom. I equated a locked room with <em>space</em>. I read books and played videogames that offered portals to other worlds far larger and more dynamic than my own. The world felt small to me because the world made me feel small. I think <em>many</em> children feel this way — though perhaps not so many react to it the way I did, or for such a long time.</p><p>Towards the end of my high school years, I went on the internet for the first time. I quickly learned that the internet was like an immersive game: you could be anything and anyone you wanted — and you could do anything you desired or invented — because it was all <em>virtual</em>. Almost immediately I did things like pretend to be female or pretend to be older or younger than I was. It wasn’t because I was confused about my sexuality or upset by my age, it was that I’d finally found a world in which I could name myself and change that name whenever I began to feel in any way reduced by being in the world IRL.</p><p>In 1994 I went off to college — and without having planned it, ended up at one of the most wired campuses in the country at the time. Dartmouth College in the 1990s was a wild place to be a freshman, as you were required to buy a computer, everyone emailed instead of using the telephone (even for basic conversations) and everyone was hooked up to an internal college-wide server that allowed you to see what peers had on their computers. All you had to do was click a button and everyone on campus could see whichever of your files you wanted them to see. I was obsessed with seeing what others had on their computers — mind you, not because I really expected or wanted to find anything untoward, but because it was a way of “connecting” with other people without having to meet them in person. It was a form of socializing, or so I think it must have seemed to me at the time. And suddenly the internet was not just a place as big as you needed it to be, where you could be whoever you wanted, but <em>also</em> a place in which you could interact with others without any of the complications of being “seen.” Which was fortunate for me, as by my freshman year of college I’d started to gain a little weight, lose my hair, wear glasses, become aware of how little I understood about fashion or — far worse — actual, face-to-face socializing. I’d “skipped” those formative years.</p><p>I don’t think my story is unique. I think many people — some shy, some quiet, some reserved, and some, like me, willful loners — discovered the internet in the 1990s or early 2000s, and saw in it everything they thought they wanted. And I suppose it’s equally unsurprising that I, much like everyone else who thought this way in the early days of the internet, turned out to be wrong and ultimately came to resent the internet (and myself) for how wrong I’d been.</p><p>For me, things started going wrong in 1998, the year I started law school. By then I had long since ceased pretending to be anyone else online or having much interest in looking through anyone else’s stuff. I went by my real name online and spent a great deal of time in online poetry workshops. What I discovered, soon enough, was that certain people had taken the Wild West ethos of the internet’s early years into the civilized online spaces of the late 1990s. Certain online poetry workshoppers went by fake names, and these men and women were significantly more likely than others to get into arguments, say vile things to other workshoppers, eschew basic niceties and even, on occasion, wreak system-wide havoc and intentionally. I saw that the internet was a great place for a certain type of kid to “find himself,” but that this dynamic wasn’t quite so endearing when it came courtesy of a sixty year-old ex-Army paraplegic alcoholic from Kansas (as one of the workshop’s most disruptive personalities happened to be).</p><p>A couple bad romantic relationships with poets I’d “met” in the workshop followed, and a blog about poetry that started fine but began getting me in trouble the moment my opinions about contemporary poetry diverged from those of my peers. In the workshop, there was little room to do anything but critique poetry; once I began writing a blog, people could see my thoughts in long-form, and sometimes they found my thoughts disagreeable and said so.</p><p>I began blogging in early 2004. By 2005, I’d learned that having an opinion IRL was substantially less dangerous than having an opinion on the internet. On the other hand, I also learned that, at least in 2005, it was possible to start your own political website and within 90 days be cited by <em>Rolling Stone</em> for your original investigative journalism. (What the internet taketh away, the internet giveth, and vice versa.) My political blog — I had both a personal blog and a political blog — was the first blog ever listed on Google News, at least until readers of Michelle Malkin’s blog, and Malkin herself, complained. Within a few months of its creation, the blog was getting upwards of 25,000 visitors a day. All those visitors meant more online interactions than I’d ever had before, and since those interactions involved politics, many of them were deeply unpleasant and even unsettling. I was finally self-defining; my words were being read by tens of thousands; I was pursuing my interests, and in a way that others found interesting; and even so, I was deeply unhappy.</p><p>I think most metamodernists become metamodernists when they realize that the internet is a place where you can become anyone you want to become — but also a place in which people reduce you to your <em>data</em> in a way that’s soul-crushing. In the era of blogs, it was a question of how many blog-lists you were on, and how much traffic your stat-counter said you had, and whether people were linking to you or not. Even in the tiny ecosystem of poetry-blogging, there was a hierarchy. In the world of political blogging, it was even more clearly so. It became harder and harder to distinguish what one said from the bare fact of how many people heard one say it, as well as which people were willing to acknowledge <em>publicly</em> that you’d said it. It all stank.</p><p>And this was before Twitter and Facebook.</p><p>I created my first Twitter account a few years after the platform started up, then deleted it in 2014, when it had 2,800 or so followers. I’d realized that I was only using the platform to remain connected to the poetry community — which as a community is about as sophisticated an ecosystem as a high school cafeteria. In other words, I was constantly thinking about how my feed fit into a larger network that I didn’t really respect or want anything much to do with in the first instance. And though it took a while, I ultimately got wise enough to my own unhappiness to kill it.</p><p>The Twitter feed I have now, with nearly half a million followers, is my second Twitter feed. I created it in 2015 only after I made a contract with myself that <em>this</em> time I wouldn’t care what others thought of what I wrote, if anyone at all followed me, or whether my obsessions were of any interest to anyone else. That it’s <em>this </em>feed, not its predecessor, that has become popular is something I never could have expected. (Perhaps metamodernism had something to do with it; you may or may not think so once you’ve read the rest of this essay.)</p><p>All of which is to say that postmodernism gave us <em>deconstruction</em>, and that that was a good thing until it was a bad thing. Deconstruction is merely a thought experiment in which one acknowledges (a) how many different ways one can see a given problem, and then (b) the many different ways that those many different ways are in direct conflict with one another. Put tens of millions of Americans who grew up in a postmodern culture — that would be all of us — into a space in which you can frictionlessly insert your own way of seeing into the slipstream of humanity, and you get exponentially more conflict than you would have gotten otherwise. Everyone realizes how stupid everything and everyone else is, even as small numbers of us work diligently to find either (a) an ultra-tiny thought-community in which we can regularly feel comfortable, or (b) a niche community in which only one topic is ever discussed. And since postmodernism also teaches us, helpfully, that everything is always-already “zero-sum,” every disagreement feels like a personal attack on our very lives.</p><p>Metamodernism is an evolution of postmodernism, and it comes from people who acknowledge how terrible and fractured everything and everyone is — a knowledge that’s the sum and substance of our postmodern inheritance — but who also still see the internet as a place of boundless self-creation, unfettered problem-solving, limitless invention, and more opportunities for collaboration than humans have ever had. To be a metamodernist is to adopt what’s called a “romantic response to crisis,” and to do so by trying to see <em>and</em> use the whole of the internet’s field of information. A metamodernist posits that by making use of our idiosyncrasies rather than hiding them or pitting them against those of others, we can arrive at better solutions than we ever would’ve alone. It’s an optimistic philosophy, but it’s a hard-won optimism that’s often called, by metamodernists, “informed naivete.”</p><p>Informed naivete is <em>knowing</em> your optimism is naive — but plowing on anyway.</p><p>A metamodernist poet might combine her own words and the words of others in an original composition, using forms taken from music — like the “remix” and the “mash-up” — not to underscore how fractured everything is, but to emphasize how <em>whole </em>everything can be made to <em>seem</em>. A metamodernist professional writer might construct a CV that includes not just the usual information but also information that (while 100% accurate) is contradictory, irrelevant, boastful, slight, or opaque — a way of showing that things are still okay when we allow ourselves to be the totality of what the hard data says we are, and also whatever <em>beyond</em> that totality the mere act of acknowledging it frees us to be. A metamodern social media user might deliberately misuse a social media platform on the theory that being authentically oneself in a way that is ostentatious and perhaps even a bit annoying is more likely to be an effective form of communication and activism than making oneself smaller by playing by the rules. A metamodernist scholar might reconfigure a “failing” discipline like English by reducing it to its operative skill-sets — say, in English, critical thinking, creative thinking, oral and written communication, and the ability to collaborate dialogically — then using those skill-sets to “reconstruct” the discipline as much more expansive than it ever was before. A metamodern journalist might look at all the polling data in a given primary and ask, “How many different <em>wholly accurate</em> metanarratives is this ‘field’ of data offering us?” Whereas in postmodernism only one metanarrative can be considered accurate at a time, metamodernism so dramatically expands the field of hard data to be considered that it often divines multiple accurate metanarratives where postmodernism would either (a) see only one, or (b) allow only one to exist. (The “dialectical” thinking of postmodernism tends to pit ideas against one another in a combat to the death from which only one idea can emerge.)</p><p>Where did metamodernism come from? Nonwhite activists-cum-scholars writing in obscure American literary publications in the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s. Most of these activists were Muslim, African-American, or Latino neo-Marxists who’d come to realize that postmodernism doesn’t actually help you <em>achieve</em> anything: it deconstructs systems without showing how to reconstruct them. These skeptical postmodernists realized that without a new cultural philosophy, progressive activists — and nonwhite activists in particular — would be forever shooting themselves in the foot by always deconstructing and never <em>reconstructing</em> the complex human systems they sought to change.</p><p>I came to metamodernism in 2013, at a time I’d had my fill of postmodernism and, in particular, postmodern poetry. I’d spent 2012 doing more reviews of contemporary poetry books than anyone in America, I think — writing for <em>The Huffington Post</em>, I reviewed about 100 books of poetry — and I was looking for a way of writing that would do more than merely recreate reality as it was. I wanted my writing, both my creative writing and my professional writing, to <em>innovate</em>. And like the earliest metamodernists, I wanted those innovations to be influential in moving progressive communities forward. In poetry, that meant publishing a trilogy of metamodern poetry books that substantially expanded what could be considered poetry and what material could be seen as a credible building-block for poetry; I believed then, and still believe, that expanding poetry in these two ways can bring American poetry back to a position of political consequence and meaningful influence in American life.</p><p>Soon thereafter, I began using metamodernism as a tool in my professional writing. Doing so allowed me to predict much about Donald Trump’s political career on the very day he announced his presidential run — and to predict, too, though I was sad to say it, that Clinton might not be able to defeat Trump in 2016. The reason for this wasn’t that Clinton wasn’t qualified; or that she wasn’t a noble, talented, intelligent, and accomplished person; it was that she wasn’t as metamodern in her cultural positioning as were Sanders and Trump. That wasn’t at all her fault — but it also meant that this wasn’t the right time for the particular type of campaign she wanted to run. I supported Sanders in the Democratic primary partly because I believed he had a better chance than Clinton of defeating Trump, and partly because I saw that polling “internals” revealed that Clinton was an even weaker candidate than many feared. The articles of mine that people today misquote (as they’ve only read their titles) as having said that Bernie was going to defeat Clinton in superdelegates — he wasn’t — are actually about polling internals and the real risk that Clinton could eventually lose to Trump. Which, to the evident detriment of the United States and the world, she ultimately did. It’s a bit bizarre to be taken to task, in 2018, for having written in 2016 articles whose content was accurate and predictive, but that’s a big part of being a metamodernist — taking flak for it.</p><p>(As a side note, I ultimately published an article endorsing Clinton during the Democratic National Convention, and I voted for her on November 8, 2016.)</p><p>One of the first metamodernists, David Foster Wallace, famously said in 1990 that the next real literary rebels in America would be artists with little interest in trying to shock or upset their peers but who were, rather, willing to become so credulous of everything in the world that their peers would <em>laugh</em> at them. Wallace, a vocal opponent of postmodernism, thereby launched a thousand metamodernists on trajectories that would, in fact, lead to many laughing at them in public. And I should know, as I’m now one of the people laughed at. On a regular basis people will come across my lengthy Twitter threads, or my obsessively curated CV, or my over-earnest social media presence and assume — as any postmodernist would — that only one of two possibilities could explain my seeming tone-deafness: that I’m an irredeemable asshole or an embarrassing tool. (Or both, I guess. Postmodernism encourages us to pretend, sometimes, that two different things are actually the same thing).</p><p>Wallace specifically, and metamodernism broadly, held that metamodern writing, whether creative or professional, wouldn’t shock people so much as either (a) annoy the hell out of them, or (b) be intensely engaging to them. The presumption, moreover, was that the <em>form</em> of metamodern writing would also be unrecognizable as either “conventional” or “experimental.” Instead, it would look nothing like it was supposed to — a metamodern poem wouldn’t look like either a conventional poem or a postmodern experimental poem, and a metamodern Twitter feed wouldn’t look like either a conventional feed or what postmodernists would consider an experimental one. Rather, it’d just look like someone trying too hard, or else being too earnest, or else not at all understanding how other people saw them. <em>Or</em> it’d look like the opposite of that: a cynical, studied manipulation of public appearances that was odiously obsessed with how it was received. But the reality would be something else.</p><p>My Twitter feed is what’s called “metajournalism” — a metamodern form of post-internet digital journalism that acknowledges that we all have too much information to process daily. Instead of despairing, however, metajournalism tries to find a way to see <em>and</em> use all available information to make <em>better</em> journalism. How does metajournalism do this? By seeing and using the entire field of information on a given subject — say the Trump-Russia investigation — whether the information comes from the United States or elsewhere, from print media outlets or digital outlets, from a verified Twitter account or a <em>New York Times</em> article from a decade ago. The idea is that, as long as all of the information that is <em>seen </em>by the metajournalist is accurate, it can be <em>used</em> to reconstruct false narratives into accurate ones. We’ve already found this to be true time and time again in the Trump-Russia investigation: conventional journalists, pressed for time and faced with a tsunami of digital news sources, are unable to see the entire field of information on the topics they’re writing on before they write about them. The result is that they miss information or connections that many of their readers — having seen a different part of the field — don’t. Unfortunately, when this happens many readers presume bad faith on the part of the journalist. “How could you have gotten that fact wrong!” they cry. “Either you’re biased, or you’re a liar!” By comparison, the metajournalist presumes good faith on the conventional journalist’s part, while acknowledging that conventional journalism makes it inevitable that any given reporter will miss a substantial sector of the field of information they’re working within.</p><p>Decades on from being that loner in a locked room, I’ve learned that I can’t control what anyone else thinks, perceives, or feels. Metamodernism is going to seem like a parlor trick to anyone who wants it to be that, and particularly to anyone wedded (whether they are aware of it or not) to the cynicism, irony, and dialectical thinking of postmodernism. And there will always be those who disregard critical theory altogether because it’s something they don’t enjoy or don’t understand. So be it. Many others will say that it doesn’t matter a whit whether your creative and professional writing is undergirded by post-internet cultural theory if your Twitter feed or what I perceive to be your online persona annoys or offends me. I think that’s fine; the purpose of this essay, much like the purpose of metamodernism itself, is merely radical transparency. Indeed, the point is to capture both the sincere and the cynical components of transparency, as transparency means revealing everything in a given “field” — not just what we’re comfortable sharing. (The internet isn’t so kind.)</p><p>If, and I know this is unlikely, you ever come across one of my three books of metamodern writing — <em>Metamericana</em>, <em>DATA</em>, and <em>Golden Age</em> — you’ll find that on the back of the first I include insults thrown at me alongside glowing blurbs; on the back of the second I include a bevy of embarrassing personal details about myself; and on the back of the third I include an excerpt from a “remix” project that failed so terribly it led other poets to falsely accuse me of condoning mass murder. (And it’s hard to fail harder as an artist than <em>that</em>, I think.) I mention this as a way of saying that it doesn’t so much matter to me anymore whether anyone reads my work, or enjoys it, or admires it. All that matters is that I be allowed to name myself, name my work, and name my intentions — whether or not anyone chooses to like me, to admire my work, or to respect my intentions. All I want is to exist within a field (call it an <em>internet</em>) and to do so honestly, fully, dynamically, and transparently.</p><p>The dominant cultural paradigm of the internet era isn’t postmodernism (which is often associated with the on/off and performer/viewer binaries of television) but metamodernism. I equally believe it could take a very long time for this to be universally seen, and that in the meantime life is going to be <em>very</em> hard for metamodernists — especially those who don’t realize yet that that’s what they are. If this essay has done anything to increase the common stock of understanding of metamodernism, especially if it’s done anything to help even a single young metamodernist see themselves for what they are, I’m happy. Or, I mean to say, both happy <em>and</em> unhappy<em> </em>— as it’s the digital age, of course, so all is, in a sense, both awful and fractured and hopeful and new. But I’m happy, at least, to cast, if I can, even a sliver of the narrow ray of hope that’s meant so much to me for so long.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=926fdc55bd6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Metamodernism in Five Terrible Diagrams]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Seth_Abramson/metamodernism-in-five-terrible-diagrams-5b430d681f7c?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b430d681f7c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Jul 2017 20:19:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-26T20:27:04.548Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Only Metamodernism Can Save America Now, As These Bad Pictures Illustrate</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*iiv0vbwaYAbigWBsEMdYFQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/746/1*Et5zuiihDGkDqI2dTFsYhg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/834/1*glibU4y9-vZ3OMXz3S-_lg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/835/1*CtSqoyBA5Hv8BnZFmwAIog.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/834/1*JI_Ub0JJAWzWtznjdXE59A.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b430d681f7c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Listen Up, Progressives: Here’s How to Deal with a 4Chan (“Alt-Right”) Troll]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Seth_Abramson/listen-up-progressives-heres-how-to-deal-with-a-4chan-alt-right-troll-48594f59a303?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/48594f59a303</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[4chan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reddit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alt-right]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 May 2017 21:45:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-03T02:16:17.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cFpsC2zok-RqBNWneUEhWw.png" /></figure><p>Needless to say, when an “alt-right” troll pops up in your social media feed, the best thing to do is ignore them. But sometimes — by dint of impatience, angst, or pique — you can’t help yourself and you engage the troll directly. It can be a cathartic experience, provided you indulge it sparingly. Indeed, the problem with trolling alt-right goons is that if you get <em>really</em> good at it, you’ll probably get <em>addicted</em> to it, too. So: don’t get too attached to the processes described below, but have them in your arsenal in the event you need to deal with an alt-right troll online.</p><p>One other note about “alt-right” trolls, before I get to the “Q&amp;A” portion of this how-to article: if you’re a progressive accustomed to feeling empathy for those who are vulnerable and hurting, you’ll find yourself developing some real sympathy for this particular brand of troll over time. There’s nothing wrong with this, especially as many of the alt-right trolls I discuss in this article are (a) relatively young, (b) sincerely confused about how to make their way in the world (which is why they use awkwardly transparent trolling and pathological online socialization as a crutch), (c) are not hard-right traditionalists so much as lapsed progressives rebelling ineffectually against what they see as the excesses of the “New Left”, (d) can be quite lovely, authentic, and caring people in person, at least when they’re not engaged in “IRL shit-posting” (see below), and (e) may actually be responding to social and political stimuli which, in the grand scheme of things, <em>are</em> genuinely bewildering to a young person growing up in the digital age.</p><p>My point here is, alt-right trolls do everything within their power to appear to be neo-Nazis online — and there’s a reasonable argument to be made that, when you inhabit a role perpetually, you in practical terms <em>become</em> what you pretend to be. But in the final accounting, the alt-right troll is a much more complicated entity than a run-of-the-mill neo-Nazi. Moreover, nearly all of these alt-right trolls will one day grow out of the esoteric, neo-Dadaist vortex of bullshit they’ve immersed themselves in online. So there’s <em>some</em> reason to feel sympathetic for these young people, even if we progressives can’t afford at this point in American history to indulge their thoroughly toxic tantrums.</p><p>Okay, so with all that said, let’s begin.</p><p><strong>Q: Where do alt-right trolls come from</strong>?</p><p>A: “Alt-right” trolls come from one of three high-volume troll-distribution centers online: the /pol/ board on Reddit; 4chan (confusingly, the “/pol/” board there); or 8chan. Some trolls are “cross-posters,” which means they participate in all three boards. Cross-posters are particularly pathetic online creatures, as it means they spend even <em>more</em> time staring at a screen rather than going outside than their peers do. Note that alt-right trolls will publicly deny any association with, or knowledge of, any of the troll-distribution centers listed above. A common tactic, indeed, is to make some vague reference to “Reddit” (e.g., “I saw your article on Reddit and wanted to comment on it”) or, even more specifically, “the /pol/ board on Reddit,” when one is actually from the “/pol/” (“Politically Incorrect”) board on 4chan. This misdirection signals to other trolls who one really is, and/or allows one to make oneself appear to be a “normie” (that’s alt-right code for anyone whose social life doesn’t revolve around anonymous web-posting on boards like Reddit, 4chan, or 8chan).</p><p>The simple fact is that <em>most</em> alt-right trolls come from 4chan’s “/pol/” board.</p><p><strong>Q: What are these distribution centers like? Can I participate in or observe them? Who would waste their time hanging out on these sites?</strong></p><p>A: All three of the alt-right troll-distribution centers listed above are public and use anonymous posting. What this means is that you can frequent them as much as you like as either a user or an observer. I recommend at least spending an hour or two on each site, as that’s all you’ll need to see how devastatingly pathetic the entire enterprise is.</p><p>I use the word “pathetic” advisedly here — these are really sad places, full of really sad people, and you’ll need to parcel out your time there carefully.</p><p>Keep in mind that most alt-right trolls are males under the age of 25, so what you’re seeing is a motley reenactment of what would’ve been the most achingly awkward fraternity at whatever college or university you attended. All of these sites are a compendium of stupid in-jokes, viral memes, multimedia from “nerd culture” — a shame, given how awesome that subculture is — and a persistent exploration of what young men can get away with online when they have the opportunity to act anonymously. So: you’ll see a lot of posts (and some images) that are misogynistic, homophobic, racist, anti-Semitic, and so on. The posters posting this content are in a few cases actually <em>committed</em> misogynists, homophobes, racists, and anti-Semites; much more commonly, they’re relatively unsophisticated “kids” — using that term here to denote emotional immaturity rather than chronological age — who are exploring complicated anxieties, angers, and associations they don’t really know how to process yet in any way but the anti-social.</p><p>Mind you, they don’t see <em>themselves</em> that way. You will <em>stagger</em> at the arrogance of all these young people who haven’t <em>done anything</em> yet.</p><p>Interactions between alt-right trolls on these distribution-center websites are bewildering to the uninitiated, every bit as much as meetings of Scientologists would be to non-Scientologists. Because online alt-right communities are essentially <em>Lord of the Flies</em>-like cults developed by young men, they include all the features you might expect from that sort of ecosystem. So, expect not just obscure in-jokes, but byzantine labyrinths of buzzwords; not just preening, but an odd sort of “virtue-signaling” in which what a given troll seeks to signal is that he is <em>less</em> “politically correct” than everyone else and therefore more (as he will see it) “courageously subversive”; not just references to pop culture, but citations of those obscure sub-dungeons of pop culture which only an initiate into the most esoteric cubbyholes of the digital age could ever grok.</p><p>While it’s true that most users on these sites are male, and that most are white, and that most are (importantly, <em>secular</em>) Christians, it’d be wrong to think that the alt-right is categorically hostile to non-whites, homosexuals, women, or Jews. While I discuss this much more below, alt-right <em>trolls</em> — as opposed to <em>politically committed</em> white supremacists, for whom the internet is merely a tool rather than a lifestyle — do not actually self-identify on the basis of race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, or religion. In fact, when they’re not virtue-signalling to other trolls but rather being “serious” about their political commitments, they categorically <em>oppose</em> anyone self-identifying themselves via demographics. Rather, the glue of their online (un)civil society is, quite simply, hatred of what they call “Social Justice Warriors” (SJWs). (An SJW, in alt-right trolls’ telling of it, is simply a far-left political activist who is aggressively evangelical — and even aggressive — about their views online, and is, therefore, unwilling to brook any public dissent against those views.)</p><p>In other words, if you are, for instance, Asian-American, female, Jewish, transgendered, or gay, <em>and</em> if you (a) detest Social Justice Warriors, and (b) are willing to listen to a lot of hate speech (allegedly) designed to upset Social Justice Warriors rather than signal actual animus toward any vulnerable U.S. population or minority, you can be a member of the alt-right troll community.</p><p>(But don’t do that.)</p><p>Some of the current “celebrities” of the alt-right community — accepting, for a moment, that the brand of celebrity we’re discussing here is very sad indeed — are <em>not</em> white Christian males with normative “alpha-male” traits (this latter fact being one I mention due to the alt-right community’s obsession with “alpha-male” behavior and signaling). Some of the currently beloved — but, not surprisingly, offensively nicknamed — darlings of the alt-right community include: “Jackie 4Chan” (an Asian-American male); “Uncle Chang” (an Asian-American male); “Brittany Venti” (a multi-racial female); “Jesus” (a dark-skinned, self-described “Bedouin” from Saudi Arabia); and “/Pol/ Blart” (a morbidly obese, middle-aged man). All of these folks became “famous” while appearing on Shia LaBeouf’s “He Will Not Divide Us” live-stream in Queens earlier this year; alt-right trolls treat “#HWNDU” as a sitcom rather than performance art, and consider themselves to have been at once “actors” and “themselves” whenever they appeared on the HWNDU feed. There’s even a multi-part “HWNDU documentary” on YouTube in which all of the “S-tier” (top-tier) “celebrities” from LaBeouf’s art project are interviewed on various topics.</p><p>(It’s confusing, I know. It’d take a whole article to explain it.)</p><p>All of the above said, let’s not kid ourselves: alt-right trolls <em>are</em> overwhelmingly white Christian males of a certain age. Still, the exceptions to this general rule are extremely telling, as they underscore that there’s a wide gulf between alt-right trolls and politically committed white supremacists. And while that distinction will in many instances seem — and be — more or less academic, I’ll explain below why it’s actually <em>critical</em> to resisting the “alt-right” online.</p><p><strong>Q: What do these people want, when they scurry out from their online distribution centers and onto my social media feed?</strong></p><p>A: This one’s simple: they want to “trigger” you. Period, full-stop.</p><p><strong>Q: What does it mean to be “triggered”? And why would someone get so much pleasure, over such a long period of time, from “triggering” people they’ve never met and will never meet?</strong></p><p>A: Obviously, the real answer to this question is, “Who knows?” (Spending your day being an asshole to strangers is literally the <em>worst</em> way to blow your time on Earth, kids. You’ll literally <em>never</em> look back at the time you spent on this when you’re, for instance, 63, and say to yourself, “Yeah, that was a good use of my <em>twenties</em>.”)</p><p>But if we absolutely <em>must</em> take a deep dive into alt-right trolls’ superficial, self-aggrandizing answer to this question — and we must — we can note that the central theorem of the alt-right troll is this: “political correctness” is the number-one problem in America. This is no exaggeration; alt-right trolls believe that the politically correct discourse often associated with the “New Left” is destroying everything fun, interesting, and (most of all) <em>free</em> about America.</p><p>For instance, alt-right “nationalism” isn’t usually (at least when found on /pol/, 4chan, or 8chan ) “ethno-nationalism,” but rather a far stranger brew which has it that political correctness is eroding the very foundations of America — most notably, the First Amendment. All-right trolls <em>do</em> believe in American exceptionalism, but (consistent with them being equal parts politically savvy and politically naive) not because of anything having to do with race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, or disability status. They’re even “fine with” any immigrant, of any nationality or hue, who<em> thoroughly</em> assimilates upon entry into the United States. So the reason they detest certain western European nations, for instance, is not because they’re heterogeneous but because alt-right trolls think of Europe as being less oriented toward personal freedom and less encouraging of “melting pot” assimilation than America is. An alt-right troll will be obsessed with the Second Amendment even if they’ve never held a gun; to an alt-righter, gun-toting Americans are metaphors for America’s commitment to a unique, frontier-like society in which personal freedoms are <em>religiously</em> prized.</p><p>(Of course, were these trolls more sophisticated, they’d see that retaining one’s sense of heritage<em> is</em> an exercise of personal freedom, but for the alt-right the far more pressing issue surrounding having a “heritage” is that it encourages what they call “identity politics” — in their estimation, a risible fragmentation of “American” political will and identity.)</p><p>Given the above, we can see that alt-right trolls are <em>most</em> threatened by the idea that far-left “Social Justice Warriors” will so police Americans’ thoughts, words, and behaviors — through the application of “political correctness” as a doctrine — that they will pose an existential threat to the fundamental character of the nation. (Many alt-right trolls believe we’re already at that point, actually.) And, because they believe that the Achilles’ heel of all SJWs is an over-sensitivity to thoughts, words, and behaviors that they cannot control and that displease them, they spend their days trying to “trigger” these persons by upsetting them publicly.</p><p>This, then, is the fulcrum of alt-right trolls’ pseudo-political agenda. They believe that if SJWs can, in large numbers, be publicly and repeatedly triggered, it will make those persons look so ridiculous in the eyes of the “average” (read as “centrist” or “center-right”) American voter that the “New Left” will collapse — politically, if not in social discourse. In short, alt-right trolls believe they can <em>literally save America</em> by making you angry in public.</p><p><strong>A: So what methods do these trolls use to force progressives into public anger and (therefore, in their view) a self-defeating over-dramatization of personal trauma?</strong></p><p>Q: Because these trolls view themselves as foot-soldiers in the battle for American values, they’re willing to do <em>anything</em> to make progressives publicly flip their lids. They desperately need us progressives to sound shrill, weak, self-righteous, and petulant, so their methods are both aggressive and — by any common standards of decency — enormously provocative and offensive.</p><p>In describing these methods below, <em>I do not defend them whatsoever</em>. But progressives <em>must</em> understand not only what these methods are but how and why they are being deployed by alt-right trolls against progressives on a daily basis.</p><p><em>Slurs</em>. Because alt-right trolls are, from a certain angle, radical ideologues, they’re willing to act anti-socially, including aggressively, in order to secure any advance for their cause. Their favorite tactic is to use racial, ethnic, religious, anti-Semitic, ableist, and misogynistic slurs without (in their view) actual animus. What this means is that they — again, in their own view — are protesting the policing of public speech by casually using hate speech online even though they harbor no actual ill will toward any of the groups they’re slandering. If you go onto /pol/, 4chan, or 8chan right now, you will see more usage of the f-word, n-word, k-word (“kike”), and c-word than you’ve seen in your last decade of polite public or private conversation — not to mention deliberate misusage of terms like “autism” and many references to outrageous conspiracy theories.</p><p>Let me acknowledge what most readers are thinking at this moment: what’s the difference between using a slur to make a political point, and actually being (as the case may be) racist, anti-Semitic, ableist, or misogynistic? And of course from the progressive view, which is the perspective I’m writing from here, the answer is <em>none</em>. If I can’t distinguish you online from an anti-Semite, and if you’re never going to “drop the act” and explain your use of the word “kike” to me, and if I’m never going to meet you in person to see that you’re a decent sort actually, it <em>doesn’t matter to me</em> whether you’re an “actual” anti-Semite or an alt-right troll because <em>I’ll never find out which you are</em>.</p><p>This is why so many alt-right trolls are, without fully realizing it, in danger of slipping into politically committed white supremacy: they’re so committed to their “act” that, for anyone except their closest friends, they might as well be <em>exactly</em> what they’re pretending to be. This also explains why politically committed white supremacists use /pol/, 4chan, and 8chan to recruit new members: they have a captive (because internet-addicted) audience of confused young people who really just want to belong to something, and that’s fertile soil for “actual” neo-Nazi and KKK recruiters. And they know it.</p><p>So why don’t the disaffected (generally) young people on /pol/, 4chan, and 8chan <em>care</em> that they’re projecting themselves “erroneously” into the public sphere? Several reasons: (a) they sincerely believe they’re saving America from losing its unique sociocultural and jurisprudential elements; (b) they are so socially isolated that /pol/, 4chan, and 8chan become their “real” homes, where their “real” friends are, and therefore as long as <em>those</em> people know that any slur used in those three environments or elsewhere is political theater, it’s okay (and remember here that David Bowie engaged in a similar performance, which he later awkwardly apologized for, as the “Thin White Duke”); (c) in a certain sense they consider these slurs authentically “self-expressive,” as it allows them to self-define <em>themselves</em> rather than being defined from without as a result of their race, gender, age, and so on. In their — thoroughly confused — minds, using the f-word or n-word publicly is <em>not</em> a statement of animus but a bizarre statement of “self-confidence”: you can’t police my thoughts or words, progressives, they appear to be saying, as I’m the “sort of person” (a key concept in juvenile self-realization) who would never be cowed by the demands of strangers. From this standpoint, these slurs are like self-harm, underage drug use, truancy, bullying, or running away from home: anti-social behavior that doubles as an oppositional identity-formation device.</p><p>It’s all very boring — and I don’t condone any of it — but there it is.</p><p><em>Shit-posting</em>. “Shit-posting” (sometimes non-hyphenated) simply refers to being a disruptive asshole for the sake of being a disruptive asshole. It’s a pre-teen/teenage “acting out” ritual that, in alt-right troll-distribution centers, is socially acceptable and therefore carries a negligible social cost. One “shit-posts” by deliberately derailing others’ conversations, undermining others’ real or perceived authority, confusing readers of a given “thread,” or “triggering” peers — something that’s exponentially more difficult to do in a <em>community of trolls</em>, which is why /pol/, 4chan, and 8chan naturally exhibit “race-to-the-bottom” social phenomena slur- and shitposting-wise.</p><p>A newer phenomenon is “IRL [‘in real life’] shit-posting,” which means trying to bring the disruption of message-board threads into real time. This usually takes the form of directly provoking the anger of, or attempting to engender confusion in, left-wing protesters and their allies in whatever real-life fora these individuals appear. Increasingly, “IRL shit-posting” creates dangerous situations because of — ironically — the “fighting words” doctrine enshrined in the nation’s Constitution. Essentially, alt-right trolls are too dim (thus far) to realize that shit-posting “IRL” may actually get them arrested or beaten up, and that in certain instances the Constitution actually condones their arrest and/or their attackers. For instance, calling an African-American the n-word on /pol/ may be held to be a sort of political statement, but in real life it will sometimes get you punched — and the courts may well allow that sort of response, as utterance of the n-word is seen by courts as a verbal signal that you wish to fight someone and, indeed, already consider yourself in the midst of a fight.</p><p>I guess my point is that these alt-right trolls who so venerate the Constitution don’t actually understand the First Amendment, whether it’s “fighting words” doctrine or the “time, place, and manner” restriction on free speech that could actually get you arrested under circumstances in which you believe you’re protected by the First Amendment. This is why I say that alt-right trolls are simultaneously politically engaged and politically naive. They understand the Constitution just well enough to know that some New Leftists do indeed take a narrower view of the First Amendment than they do, and just <em>poorly</em> enough to get themselves (increasingly) beaten up or arrested in situations in which they think they’re protected by the First Amendment but are not.</p><p><em>Memes</em>. Alt-right trolls on /pol/, 4chan, and 8chan are what we call “metamodernists,” though they’re very different in temperament, ambition, and subculture than most other metamodernists. (In other words, don’t damn metamodernists just because of alt-right trolls, any more than you would damn postmodern scholars at Yale because of violent anti-WTO anarchists in Seattle.) In this case, the term “metamodernism” simply means that alt-right trolls believe the internet has brought about <em>terminal data saturation</em> — a view shared by late postmodernists — but that, rather than leading us to despair, this fact should instead be used as a mechanism for retaining hope.</p><p>That sounds a bit confusing, so I’ll simplify it: alt-right trolls think that, because of near-universal internet access in the United States, we’re all awash in too much data, so they’re looking for a way to organize that data so it will still make sense to them. If postmodernism taught us that all truth is contingent — because there are so many different perspectives and angles on the truth, and so much contradictory data out there — metamodernism allows us to return to a belief in <em>metanarrative</em>, thereby staving off the despair often caused by terminal data saturation.</p><p>A <em>metanarrative</em> is a narrative that organizes many smaller narratives and thereby operates as a guidance mechanism for humans. “Manifest Destiny” is a particularly insidious metanarrative from history, for instance. Postmodernism (and hard experience) rightly taught us to be suspicious of any totalizing metanarrative, but one result of getting rid of metanarratives altogether is a sense of being unanchored in the world and in your own skin. Metamodernists allow for a <em>conditional</em> return of metanarrative; essentially, they condone metanarrative when it helps you do something generative and productive for yourself, your family, sub-community, community, or nation. But they <em>also</em> insist that you acknowledge, if implicitly, the imperfections — and, more broadly, the illusory nature — of the metanarratives you adopt.</p><p>When alt-right trolls talk about “meme magic,” they’re referring to the idea that there are so many internet memes out there right now that, at some point, memes become “real” — that is, they begin to forecast things that will actually happen rather than being meaningless. As we can see, “meme magic” is a useful metanarrative for confused young people because (a) it convinces them that the data they’re awash in isn’t meaningless, and (b) it finds a way to <em>celebrate</em> the volume of memes online by pointing out an obvious fact: if there’s enough data in your local environment, eventually some of it will come to seem significant <em>even when it actually isn’t</em>. To some metamodernists, even something that <em>seems </em>significant (but which you know isn’t) can be a sort of guidance mechanism; you may realize that you’re being misled into seeing significance where there is none, but you’re okay with it because at least you’re being led <em>somewhere</em>. It’s a stopgap measure intended to combat ennui and anomie.</p><p>“Pepe the Frog” is a reification of “meme magic” — in other words, a totem representing the principle that all things are connected (even though the alt-right troll knows, in a bit of cognitive dissonance, that they’re <em>not</em>). Another alt-right totem is Kek, the Egyptian God of Darkness. Another is the Bogdanoff twins, a highly unusual-looking duo whose reconstructive facial surgery is endlessly interesting, for some reason, to alt-right trolls. Much like Scientologists and L. Ron Hubbard, alt-right trolls venerate Pepe, Kek, and the Bogdanoffs as quasi-deities. Many alt-right memes use some or all of the iconography associated with these three totems. Do alt-right trolls actually think these symbols are meaningful? No, they don’t. But they <em>do</em> think they’re hilarious — because they trigger SJWs and allow alt-right trolls to signal to one another from a distance.</p><p>That “okay” hand symbol you’ve been seeing everywhere (for instance, below)? That too is an alt-right meme intended to trigger progressives. That’s why left-wing nonprofits are both right <em>and</em> wrong to call the symbol “white supremacist”; in practical terms, it absolutely is, as it’s nigh impossible to distinguish the behavior of an alt-right troll online from a “real” (politically committed) white supremacist, but the fact that many who use it online are simply trolling the Left without feeling any actual animus toward non-whites or Jews makes the whole thing devilishly fun for these man-children (and, of course, a few women, too).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/619/1*eZfQHBF9XMXzI9MBxWLP3w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cassandra Fairbanks and Mike Cernovich troll progressives with the “okay” signal in the White House briefing room.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Alt-right subculture</em>. Closely related to the concept of “meme magic” is the somewhat more banal practice of <em>subcultural formation</em>, a process central to the maintenance and expansion of major alt-right troll-distribution centers. In other words, in order for alt-right trolls — fundamentally lonely and confused, seeking belonging and togetherness in cult-like online spaces — to feel like they’re part of a community, they need music and other cultural artifacts that signify that they’re <em>building</em> something rather than merely tearing things down. The song “Shadilay,” an obscure, 1980s disco-pop song by the Italian band P.E.P.E., serves as “culture” in the world of the alt-right troll. Listening to the song will underscore for you just how pathetic this whole thing is:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Ffd.xuwubk.eu.org%3A443%2Fhttps%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FzAx0t3O55Zo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Ffd.xuwubk.eu.org%3A443%2Fhttp%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DzAx0t3O55Zo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Ffd.xuwubk.eu.org%3A443%2Fhttps%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FzAx0t3O55Zo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1125d30d4ce118233711aebf9871d0eb/href">https://medium.com/media/1125d30d4ce118233711aebf9871d0eb/href</a></iframe><p>It’s catchy — sort of — but the artifact of a vibrant digital subculture it is not.</p><p>Needless to say, “Shadilay” became an overnight alt-right “hit” because of “meme magic”: the coincidence of the band that sings the song being called “P.E.P.E.” and a frog being on the cover of the single. (<em>The Crying of Lot 49</em>, anyone? Again, though, whereas the postmodernist Pynchon was underscoring meaninglessness, the metamodernist alt-right troll <em>chooses</em> to see “meaning.”)</p><p><strong>A: Given all this, how should I deal with alt-right trolls, if for any reason I find myself unable to ignore them altogether?</strong></p><p>Q: There are two things you must do if you hope to troll an alt-right troll: (1) prove to them that you’ve infiltrated their “safe spaces” (/pol/, 4chan, and 8chan), and (2) do not, under any circumstances, no matter what they say, allow them to trigger you — which means you must immediately cease contact with the alt-right troll if you find yourself getting emotionally piqued by the interaction. The moment you get emotional — that is, the moment you assign <em>any substantive weight whatsoever </em>to anything the troll says — you’re toast.</p><p>The key to infiltrating an alt-right troll’s “safe spaces” — and make no mistake, /pol/, 4chan, and 8chan are merely safe spaces for people who cannot cope with the pace and dynamism of American social and political discourse — is to know their code.</p><p>This means knowing, for instance, that “weaponized autism” is alt right-speak for the ability of an alt-right troll to disrupt American social and political discourse even though they feel themselves unwilling or unable to generatively engage with that discourse. (This form of isolation and difficulty decoding social gestures is one that the alt-right troll identifies with autism.)</p><p>It means knowing that alt-right trolls will often talk about drinking milk because of their claim that African-Americans are genetically predisposed to lactose intolerance; they think, therefore, that by drinking milk publicly, or talking about milk, they will trigger anti-fascists.</p><p>(Yes, this is all quite strange, I know.)</p><p>It means knowing that “Ree!” — a high, prolonged screeching sound — is how alt-right trolls signify their self-described “weaponizing” of “autism.” It means knowing that “Bog-pilling” (a reference to the Bogdanoff twins) and “red-pilling” are merely <em>Matrix</em>-referencing terms for accepting the alt-right metanarrative of American decline and reemergence. This means having no reaction whatsoever, emotional or otherwise, when you’re referred to by the f-word — something alt-right trolls do to everyone — or misogyny-signaling terms like “cuck” (for “cuckold”) or “snowflake” (a “feminized” male).</p><p>Again, I want to emphasize that these terms are <em>actually</em> offensive and hurtful and their use is <em>never</em> okay. But failing to distinguish between use of these words to communicate hatred and use of these words to communicate a bullshit brand of political “dissent” is nevertheless <em>vital</em> to combating the so-called “alt-right.” Because postmodern dialectics have, over the years, convinced us that highly charged words can only be used either not at all or to communicate a violent animus, these metamodernist alt-right trolls are <em>deliberately</em> using the words in a <em>third</em> way to confuse and subvert American political discourse. If we can’t see that, we’ll constantly fall into their trap — and to be clear, believing that every alt-right troll is a politically committed white supremacist <em>is</em> a trap. If we want to fight these trolls’ view of American exceptionalism, or combat their weaponization of the divisions “political correctness” sometimes sows, we <em>need</em> to understand what they’re doing. Treating with them as pre-digital age bigots is extremely dangerous because it fits into their counter-dialectical, pro-“free speech” narrative perfectly.</p><p>As for (2) — never being triggered — that’s a much harder sell, as I know from experience. I naturally get triggered when alt-right trolls call me a “kike,” or refer to the anti-Semitic “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” trope, and to be triggered when addressed in this way is human. This is why, too, some portion of the alt-right generation will be lost to us permanently — that is, they’ll lead dreary, marginalized lives because of a stupid cult they joined when they were teenagers or in their twenties. (Simply put, if you can’t understand that throwing hate speech at people is <em>actually hurtful</em>, and if you privilege your own “political statement” above the quite <em>reasonable </em>sensitivities of others, you’re an asshole now and will die an asshole.) Alt-right trolls’ vaguely understandable reaction to certain iterations of “political correctness” has somehow morphed into something it was never intended to be — the embrace of speech that actually <em>is</em> unreasonably aggressive and cruel no matter <em>what</em> one’s political views are.</p><p>If you sense here some empathy for these jerks, this is why: they’re fundamentally unhappy young people whose subtle indoctrination into a cult is explainable by virtue of their juvenile anxiety, confusion, and pathological inability to assimilate into normative human culture. And those very human frailties will nevertheless end up destroying their lives in the long run. What began as a sort of lark — a performance of political resistance by generally entitled young people— will turn into, for many of them, either a lifetime of anti-social behavior and ostracization and/or successful recruitment by hate groups like the KKK. I don’t think any anxious, confused, socially awkward kid deserves that horrid fate, and it’s especially hard to see these young people be so damn <em>arrogant</em> about flushing their social and professional lives down the drain. If you don’t feel any empathy for cultists, you won’t feel any empathy for these alt-right trolls; for better or worse, I <em>do</em> feel empathy for those caught in a cult.</p><p><strong>Q: What does all this have to do with Trump?</strong></p><p>A: A lot, actually. Alt-right trolls see Trump — and you’ll be <em>very</em> surprised to hear this — as a total and complete loser. To use their own deeply offensive terminology, alt-right trolls consider Trump a “weaponized autist” who is so clearly dysfunctional in every way that his election as president is <em>hilarious</em>. If you’re thinking that it takes a real lack of situational awareness to <em>not</em> see how Trump could endanger the very nation alt-right trolls claim to love, and a real lack of empathy to <em>not</em> see (just because you think Trump couldn’t or wouldn’t ruin your own life) how Trump could ruin real lives, you’re right. That’s why many alt-right trolls come from middle-class or upper-middle-class upbringings — they’re essentially twerpy bourgeois assholes who use a lame brand of political dissent as cover for the fact that in a Marxist revolution they might well be the first ones up against the wall. (I make my point so graphically here only because I think this secret sense of being a fraudulent revolutionary is endemic to alt-right culture; they don’t have anything more <em>important</em> to rebel against, so they betray a “snowflake”-like sensitivity to being triggered by far-left activists. Deep down, though, they know there are <em>real</em> revolutions ongoing out there.)</p><p>While most alt-right trolls are, in fact, moderate Republicans, this is almost entirely owing to their distaste for “political correctness.” In terms of economic policy, they’re mostly Leftist populists (think “Berniecrats”). In terms of social policy, a few of them grew up in traditionalist households that were pro-life, pro-gun, pro-school prayer, and pro-death penalty, but many more are libertarians who smoke a lot of weed and think everyone should be able to do privately whatever they like. Some of them are even anarchists, which means they think everyone should be able to do privately <em>and</em> publicly just about whatever they like. Mainstream Republican voters these are not.</p><p>For this reason, Trump’s incoherence on policy, inability to engage in any normative social and political discourse, and obviously “meme-worthy” persona (think his fake-looking hair, orange skin, absurdly long ties, obvious fraudulence as a businessman, birth into wealth, conspicuously fake marriage, and so on) are all deeply, deeply attractive to alt-right trolls. Do they think Trump can “Make America Great Again”? Of course not — they think he’s a dolt. But they <em>do</em> believe that America needs to be made great again through the evisceration of political correctness as a guiding principle. And they <em>do</em> believe that America needs politicians who disrupt conventional political discourse every bit as much as they themselves hope to do in their social discourse online. And they <em>do</em> think American politics should be as entertaining as a videogame, addictive as viral video content, and readily reducible to meme as all other indicia of postmodern meaninglessness. And, because these faux rebels are all mostly well-off financially, they’re reasonably certain nothing Trump does will hurt <em>them</em>, so you’re damn right they’ll vote for him (again) in 2020. If Bernie Sanders ran they’d consider voting for him instead, but only if it seemed that him winning would usher in a new brand of hilarity in D.C. politics. After all, the alt-right troll votes — does just about everything — “for the lulz,” which roughly translates into, “for the laughs.”</p><p><strong>Q: Why should we fight these trolls rather than ignore them?</strong></p><p>A: Because they’ll make us better progressives.</p><p>As a longtime public defender, I learned long ago that we most readily come to the truth when we put our ideas through a trial by fire. I think the worst thing for progressives is to avoid vigorous debate, disagreement, and dissent; I’ve seen firsthand how those within any system who are rarely challenged — for instance, police officers, judges, and prosecutors — soon become smug, self-satisfied, and, most importantly, <em>far worse at what they do</em>. If we want to be mean, lean, progressive fighting machines, we need to be able to wade into the arena of public discourse wearing the invisible armor of <em>self-confidence</em> and <em>purpose</em>; and because right now the adversaries most likely to test our self-confidence and purpose are alt-right trolls, I’m committed to the idea that, quite inadvertently, they’re doing us all a tremendous favor. They are drawing us out into a form of engagement the internet doesn’t often enough afford us: real-time interaction with people we strongly disagree with. Our social media feeds have become echo chambers, and so the introduction of absurd, puerile, faux-rebellious “alt-rightists” forces us out of our complacency and back to the sort of charismatically evangelical mindset that wins hearts and minds, elections, and changes in policy. America continues to be, in its policy preferences, center-left, but right now the Left is losing these battles because we appear to be brittle, humorless, and unable to engage in ideological combat without overreaction and aggressive “silencing” tactics. We need to be able to troll as well as the alt-right does when necessary, and be <em>immune</em> to any trolling when <em>that’s</em> necessary. I’m not above shit-posting alt-right trolls or referencing their stupid-ass tweener memes if doing so shows the resilience of progressivism.</p><p>I’m not suggesting we should all be fighting alt-right trolls regularly — that’d make us all as miserable as these trolls secretly are — but that we should all understand alt-right trolls well enough to be able to clean their damn clocks online whenever we feel like it.</p><p><strong>Q: But what’s the endgame, here?</strong></p><p>A: To me, <em>this</em> is the interesting part. As a metamodernist myself — though certainly not of the “alt-right” variety — I believe in seeking out win-win scenarios whenever possible, even (perhaps especially) when it seems that such a scenario should be impossible. (“Generative paradox” is a byword for metamodernists of every stripe; while for alt-right trolls this means using hate speech to, in their benighted view, “fight for freedom,” for most <em>other</em> metamodernists it means finding a way to collide and fuse opposing forces.)</p><p>In this case, progressives’ fight with alt-right trolls is the most bizarre sort of “win-win” situation. If we progressives become rarely triggered advocates for social justice, we’ll be more successful in all our activist endeavors — as I know from years of experience as a left-wing activist. Meanwhile, if we become less fragile in public discourse, it’ll start to alleviate alt-right trolls’ fundamental complaint and therefore, incredibly, both make these trolls happier <em>and</em> less likely to subscribe to an “alt-right” brand of politics.</p><p>In other words, we progressives have a chance to simultaneously (a) fight alt-right trolls in a way that’s immensely pleasurable for us, (b) become more effective advocates for our progressive causes in the balance, and (c) eliminate the motive engine of the “alt-right,” thereby freeing these dead-enders from a lifetime of misery and pointless political posturing. It is (in fact) a “win-win-win” that would — but this time for real, and in a way progressives could appreciate — make America better than it ever has been.</p><p>(In fact, if 4channers were smart, they’d put out as many primers of the sort you’ve just read as they possibly could. Doing so would encourage — but in a more direct and effective way than anything alt-right trolls are doing now — those on the left to cease <em>most</em> of the behaviors that alt-right trolls <em>claim</em> to be anguished and unduly put upon by.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=48594f59a303" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[This Is How 2,000+ Americans Described the Trump Administration (in Two Words)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Seth_Abramson/this-is-how-2-000-americans-described-the-trump-administration-in-two-words-5b6805ad9bc6?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b6805ad9bc6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[republican-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democratic-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Apr 2017 23:18:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-28T23:18:32.471Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/876/1*KMDV6ZcVohFUasiUzohsQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The first 100 days of any presidential administration are crucial; so far, Americans are giving President Trump poor marks.</figcaption></figure><p>I recently asked readers of my <a href="https://twitter.com/SethAbramson">Twitter account</a> to describe the first 100 days of the Trump administration in two words. More than 2,000 readers responded, and while many of the responses were profane — and some didn’t quite follow the prompt — a trend among the replies was evident: Americans, or at least the 100,000 or so who follow my Twitter feed, have almost nothing positive to say about the current occupant of the White House.</p><p>Below I’ve listed several hundred of the responses I received to my query. Be warned: graphic language abounds here, and avid Trump supporters may find themselves repeatedly triggered.</p><blockquote>Impeach him! Promises broken. Ugh, why? Apocalypse Now. Shit sandwich. Triple bogey. The fuck? Shit poodle. Bigly disaster. Global embarrassment. Too long. (Unintelligible) (unintelligible). Tremendously flaccid. Epic fail! You’re fired. Total shitgibbonry. Dystopian horror. Monetizing treason. Russian idiot. Hillary won. National embarrassment. High treason. Kleptocracy agenda. Overdue impeachment. President Nightmare. Must impeach. Malicious incompetence. Russia, mostly. <strong>Uncontrollable shitnado</strong>. American kleptocracy. Utterly clueless. Pee tape. International embarrassment. Fourth Reich. Volcano diarrhea. Grifter dynasty. Hate-filled squatter. Malignant mass. Waking nightmare. Embarrassing, terrifying. 100% failure. Daily insanity. As expected. Sleepless nights. Increased Xanex. Completely insane. Uniquely unqualified. Unprecedented failure. Total disaster. Orange plague. Deeply terrifying. Breathtaking incompetence. Trumptonian disaster. Epic failure. Malevolent incompetence. Diarrhea typhoon. Obamacare won. Putin’s puppet. Bigly inept.</blockquote><p>What surprised me most about the responses I received is that none — as in <em>literally</em> none — assessed the first 100 days of Trump’s presidency positively.</p><p>While my Twitter account is undoubtedly (and quite resolutely) anti-Trump, usually a tweet that gets sent around widely will pick up a large number of pro-Trump respondents along the way. That wasn’t the case here, however, as the results reveal:</p><blockquote>Democracy disaster. Catastrophic failure. Complete disaster. High anxiety. Very frightening. Clusterfucastrophe bigly. <strong>Narcissistic sociopath</strong>. Please resign. Charlatan (remedial). No Vaseline. It sucks. Swamp growth. Distract, deflect. I’m ashamed. Corruption, corporatocracy. Golf, anyone? Oy vey. Apocalypse soon? Impending doom. Fears confirmed. Breaking bad. Pathetically embarrassing. Beyond comprehension. Apocalypse Now. Nightmare (tenfold). Fucking disaster. Unhinged failure. Tragic comedy. Complicit GOP. Abject failure. Unadulterated disaster. Pusillanimous calumny. Fraudulent, malicious. Cruel kleptocracy. Uncomfortably numb. Absolute travesty. Serenity now. Declining democracy. Cataclysmic embarrassment. Greedy oligarchy. Holy grab! Evangenlical terrorists. Fantastic shitshow. Just sucks! Putin’s revenge. Agent Orange. Un-American carnage. International embarrassment. “Nobody knew.” Painfully inadequate. National embarrassment. Unbelievable arrogance. Democracy fading. Tremendous failure. Predictably shocking. Just un-terrific. Tremendous disaster. Utter failure. Hot mess. Hail Mary! Abysmal failure. Peter Principle.</blockquote><p>As you can see, the most commonly repeated words across the more than 2,000 replies I received are “embarrassment,” “disaster,” “failure,” and “kleptocracy.” This would likely come as news to the new president, who has himself claimed, on <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/trump-says-his-first-100-days-have-been-a-historic-success-history-disagrees/2017/04/25/3ef61374-2616-11e7-a1b3-faff0034e2de_story.html?utm_term=.21d64dc5ef63">several</a> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/24/us/politics/donald-trump-100-days.html?_r=0">occasions</a>, that his first 100 days have been among the most successful in American history.</p><p>As I continued reading Americans’ two-word summaries of the Trump presidency, I found myself becoming numb to the horror, much like several of the characters in the 1979 film <em>Apocalypse Now</em> — the most-cited film among Americans trying to distill their feelings about this White House into just two words.</p><blockquote>Not nice. Utter failure. Daily affront. Damn shame. Anal tumor. Disaster porn. Bigly disaster. Goose egg. Baby tantrum. American tragedy. Not winning. Total fail. Incompetent ignoramus. Traveling circus. Totally bogus. Utterly ridiculous. Risky business. Fear (full).<strong> </strong>Impeach now. Winding down. Hot air. No dice. Complete incompetence. Bigly disaster. Impromptu shitstorm. A mess. Total fail. Complete failure. Soft wood. Atrocious kleptocracy. Russian asset. Oy vey. National embarrassment. Garbage fire. Told ya! Time machine. Improved handicap. Comedic tragedy. Failing failure. Fucked up. Epic fail. Underwhelming self-portrait. Utter failure. Absolutely horrendous. Complete disaster. Sad (enjoy!) USA blight. Attempt failed. Utter failure. Fierce resistance. Shit sandwich. Shit pool. <strong>Snifflegrabapuss dipshittery</strong>. Resistance unites. American tragedy. Kleptocratic fuckery. Bigly shitshow. Amateur hour. Amateur hour. America’s embarrassment. Shitshow clusterfuck. American tragedy. Darwin cried. Monumental embarrassment. Poor Melania. Tiny penis. White Russian. Big lie. Living nightmare. Help us! Utterly delusional. Illegitimate winner. Worst nightmare. Pre-impeachment placeholder. Freak show. Huge embarrassment.</blockquote><p>Far and away the most commonly cited <em>body part</em> in respondents’ two-word summaries was the butt, with the words “ass” and “diarrhea” appearing with some regularity. Trump’s tendency to golf at Mar-a-Lago rather than spend weekends working at the White House — as he’d <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2017/02/13/trump-used-to-have-a-slightly-different-opinion-of-presidents-playing-golf/?utm_term=.d6b3f30cf77d">promised</a> to do while still a candidate — was mentioned by a number of respondents, as was the current “Russiagate” investigation.</p><p>Not one respondent mentioned Neil Gorsuch.</p><p>Oddly, Charles Darwin was repeatedly cited. Less surprising, perhaps, were the large number of responses that mentioned Russia’s Vladimir Putin.</p><blockquote>Darwin weeps. Hot mess. Monumental fiasco! DJT, WTF? Cognitive whiplash. Totally failed! Putin’s prize. Liar, liar. Obama’s better! Hatred personified. Bad trip. Gong Show. National embarrassment. Potentially fatal. Total shitshow. Obvious kleptocracy. “Yuge” disaster. Tragic buffoonery. So embarrassing! Too long! Natural disaster. Clown show. <strong>Sewer backup</strong>. Failure (sad). Unmitigated disaster. Incoherent shitshow. Narcissist. Wind machine. Predictable disaster. Start impeachment! Total idiot! Total disaster. Russia’s thrilled. Goodbye, democracy. Putin puppet. Bigly shitshow. Pathological nightmare. Circus show. Catastrophic shitshow. Worst nightmare. American horror-show. Disaster overload. Toxic “president.” Continually lying. Alternate reality. Draconian dumbfest. Litmus test. Twilight Zone. Anti-democratic conflagration. Science experiment. A joke. Colossal shitstorm. Treasonous fuckery. Trump sucks. Russian presidency. Humpty Dumpty. Mar-a-Lago madman. Russian grifters. Special Education. As predicted. Maniacal mediocrity. Competence vacuum. Worldwide panic. Clown show. Corrupt liar. Hot mess. Absolute disaster. Horror, horror. Tangerine nightmare. Nero fiddling. Very destructive! America conned. Kleptocratic charlatan. Bigly disaster. Orange vomit. Incompetence, dishonesty. “Im-POTUS Incompetus.” Bluster, farce. Crazy Town. Bigly disaster. Chaotic evil. Pissing match. Small hands. Bigly liar. Clueless circus. Not legal. Election tampering. Inside insanity. Diabolical idiocracy. “Donnie’s Darko.” Complete disaster. Unpatriotic calamity. Empty offices. Without thought. Epic fail.</blockquote><p>Interestingly, even those who chose not to follow the rules of the game and offer, instead, one- or three-word summaries of Trump’s first 100 days were universal in their disapproval of the President.</p><p>The word “shitshow” — which many think is two words, but is actually one, according to the OED — appeared in these responses with stunning regularity (I’ve here typed it once for each instance in which I encountered it).</p><blockquote>Depression-inducing. Alt-world. Laughing-stock. Shitshow. Low-energy. Mind-fuckery. God-awful. Shitshow. Back-pedaling. Nothing-burger. Flim-flam. Flip-flop. Shitshow. Shitshow. Shitshow. Malaria. Shitshow. Caddyshack. Nutjob. Shitshow. Treasonous circus stunts non-stop. Mad, mad, madman. Circus. Shitstorm. Fuck-storm. Skull-fuckery. Shitstorm.</blockquote><p>The word “bigly” also recurred with some regularity, and was always followed (if somewhat ungrammatically) by either “tragedy,” “disaster,” “nightmare,” “embarrassment,” or — perhaps it goes without saying, now — “shitshow.”</p><blockquote>Petulant president. Gelatinous shitshow. Calamitous disaster. Batshit crazy. Epic fail! Inhumane policies. Double shitshow. Trump lies. Bigly nightmare. Despicable shitshow. Unprintable expletives. Bigly shitshow. Fucking shitshow. America’s shame. Bloodless coup. “Yuge” mistake. Fucked up. American disgrace. Treasonous shitshow. The end. Utter tomfoolery. “Dasvidanya, Komrad.” Arrogantly incompetent. Embarrassment, failure. Projectile fuckery. Incompetently inexperienced! <strong>Goat rodeo</strong>. “Yuge” shitshow. We’re screwed. Tragically horrific. Fucked up. Full swamp. Huge shitshow. Jesus wept. Useless nothing. Shitty show.</blockquote><p>One person used their reply to signify their admiration for the question itself. “Love this!” they wrote. (For a brief moment I thought they were applauding Trump’s first 100 days — and was actually a bit excited to have located a Trump supporter — but a quick glance at their Twitter profile confirmed them to be members of “The Resistance.”)</p><p>A few replies were inscrutable to me — many of these seemed to be about movies or television programs — so I put them into a separate category.</p><blockquote>Run, Forrest! Favorite soap. Contact embarrassment. Kindergarten Cop. “Pissing match.” Faulty Tower. TV watcher.</blockquote><p>I don’t think any of the above replies can reasonably be called complimentary.</p><p>Without question, there is, somewhere out there, a generous slice of the American voting population that likes Donald Trump and, presumably, admires his work in the White House thus far. Unfortunately, I could find no evidence of it here. (I’ve noted to many people, too, that the <a href="http://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2017/04/23/washington-post-abc-poll-do-you-regret-voting-trump-nr.cnn">recent ABC poll</a> that found that only 2% of the Americans who voted for Trump regretted it can’t be used to measure his current support; the poll, unfortunately, asked respondents whether they would still choose Trump <em>over Hillary Clinton</em>, not whether they’d choose Trump over, well, <em>anybody</em> else.)</p><p>So what can we learn from all of the above, apart from the fact that my Twitter followers universally detest this president? A good deal, I should think, as again one would’ve expected at least <em>one</em> of the more than 2,000 responses I received to speak positively of the current occupant of the White House. That not even <em>one</em> compliment could be found for this President’s handling of his job — even taking into account the uncommonly anti-Trump environment of my Twitter feed — is, I think, a rather startling finding. The consensus seems to be, as many media pundits are saying, that this has been, in fact, the worst first 100 days of any presidency in American history.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b6805ad9bc6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Metamodernism 101]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/just-words/metamodernism-101-8cdb8563e0?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8cdb8563e0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metamodernism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-foster-wallace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[postmodernism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jul 2015 23:21:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-23T16:42:12.752Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/867/1*c9Ml4bo-hhQIyqFDKvvwkw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>How David Foster Wallace Started a Cultural Revolution</h4><p><em>by Seth Abramson</em></p><p><strong>Metamodernism,</strong> the cultural philosophy with which David Foster Wallace is most often associated, is usually summarized as <em>a romantic response to crisis</em>. But the “romantic response” metamodernism has in mind isn’t merely a philosophical one; rather, it’s an entirely practical reply to looming tragedies like the sinking of the nation of Bangladesh, the continued payment of royalties to the inventor of the Selfie Stick, and the next novel from <em>Fifty Shades of Grey</em> author E.L. James. The answer to these and other crises? Hope.</p><p>If, as many of us believe, metamodernism is quickly becoming the dominant philosophy in the United States, it’s because we’re increasingly acknowledging both the crises we collectively face — and the obstacles that lie before us in facing them, like the American media’s ongoing love affair with “Kimye” — as well as the importance of moving forward with optimism. Our domestic political sphere may be more partisan than at any other time in U.S. history; our global climate may be nearing the tipping point, making a mass extinction event within the next few centuries a real possibility; economic polarization may be worse now than ever before; and in fact all of these challenges may in some sense be insurmountable — but the metamodernist view is that we can still choose to live, work, make art, and creatively problem-solve as though they’re not.</p><p>It’s difficult to summarize the fundamental crisis we face in the Internet Age, as in fact there are many crises simultaneously unfolding in different parts of American culture. But what all of these crises have in common is this: they feature the erosion of distinctions we’ve long relied upon. Scientists may broadly agree that climate change is manmade and has reached catastrophic levels, but as long as a large segment of America equates science with personal opinion there’ll be no consensus as to how to react. We can say that our culture is economically polarized, but as long as there are daily lottery winners and politicians arguing the definition of “the middle class” it will appear as though the American dream is alive and well. More broadly, while confusing, contradictory, ambiguous, and unreliable data — often, anonymously authored — may now race through virtual spaces at unthinkable speeds, these data nevertheless make up the bulk of our collective environment, whether we like it or not.</p><blockquote>The optimism favored by metamodernists is of a brand that celebrates the erasing of boundaries and treats the indistinguishability of reality and unreality —<br>or other supposed opposites, like irony and sincerity — as a creative rather than destructive force.</blockquote><p>The result is that it’s gotten more difficult than ever to draw bright lines between, say, the real and the unreal, or sincerity and irony, or optimism and cynicism. We open a browser tab and try to figure out whether Donald Trump is earnestly seeking the presidency or just promoting his “brand”; whether the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jx96Twg-Aew">music video for Donald Glover’s “Sober”</a> is depicting a touching courtship or the terrifying harassment of a woman by a stranger; whether multi-genre performers <a href="https://twitter.com/reggiewatts">Reggie Watts</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/sarahksilverman">Sarah Silverman</a>, and <a href="https://twitter.com/boburnham">Bo Burnham</a> are trying to confuse, deceive, critique, entertain, or enlighten us; even whether to laugh at or be inspired by the movement to create an <a href="http://www.flagofplanetearth.com/#intro-shift">“International Flag for Planet Earth.”</a> Metamodernism is a philosophy that helps us navigate these and similar online data by proposing an optimistic response to the collapse of order the Internet often seems to represent: a “both/and” approach that insists Donald Trump is both earnest <em>and</em> cynical, Reggie Watts imaginative <em>and</em> analytical, and so on.</p><h3>Donald J. Trump on Twitter</h3><p>@GovernorPerry failed on the border. He should be forced to take an IQ test before being allowed to enter the GOP debate.</p><p>The optimism favored by metamodernists is of a brand that celebrates the erasing of boundaries and treats the indistinguishability of reality and unreality — or other supposed opposites, like irony and sincerity — as a creative rather than destructive force. If postmodernism urged us to “deconstruct” reality by dividing thought and experience into so many subcategories that we all felt more distant from one another and “truth” than ever before, metamodernism self-consciously reconstructs those scattered pieces to form new and inspiring wholes. When one is, for instance, both sincere and ironic, one creates an entirely new state of action and reaction; new possibilities emerge, too, from new juxtapositions.</p><p>After decades of postmodern irony, cynicism, and the sort of despair that comes from thinking that everything is coming apart and that our collective problems are insolvable, metamodernism advocates hope, dialogue, collaboration, sincerity, and optimism by showing that these latter practices and attitudes need not ignore history to survive. That is, we can be mindful of the complexities of the past<em> and</em> the present without feeling incapable of meeting the challenges they pose; we can create new guiding narratives for ourselves and our communities without falsely pretending that any narrative is altogether “true” or universal. Today, we find metamodernism everywhere along the spectrum of American culture, from “remixing” in music and literature to the half-serious whimsical nature of Wes Anderson films, from the performance art of Marina Abramovic — which challenges us to consider where life ends and art begins — to the dizzying but still coherent “meta-” narratives of TV shows like <em>Community</em> and <em>Rick and Morty</em>.</p><p>The term “metamodernism” has been regularly used by academics since it was coined by American professor Mas’ud Zavarzadeh in 1975 (in <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/27553153?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents">“The Apocalyptic Fact and the Eclipse of Fiction in Recent American Prose Narratives”</a>, published by <em>The</em> <em>Journal of American Studies</em>). But it took many years for the first literary artwork universally acknowledged as “metamodern” to be written. That work is David Foster Wallace’s <em>Infinite Jest</em>, a massive novel which the late author began writing in the mid-1980s and finally published in 1996. In writing his most celebrated work, Wallace was influenced by “proto-metamodern” authors like Thomas Pynchon. Nevertheless, he offered readers an unmistakably unique take on the human condition, a bewildering combination of optimism and cynicism.</p><p>Wallace broke the rules of the postmodern novel by being at once comic and serious, ironic and sincere, obtuse and straight-forward, conscious of narrative and dismissive of the need for narrative. Wallace’s stated aim was not to show how structures (or even meaning itself) deteriorates, but rather to write a book that would be so gripping and entertaining and <em>human</em> that it’d be impossible to put down. And he succeeded. Wallace showed readers that the confusion of contemporary living still leaves plenty of room for originality, pleasure, self-knowledge, and hard-nosed problem-solving. For instance, a chapter in <em>Infinite Jest</em> in which Wallace lists everything one might learn in a 12-step recovery program is simultaneously a hilarious takedown of recovery schemes like AA and an endorsement of such groups’ ability to dramatically improve or even save a human life.</p><p>Scholars and artists continue to debate whether metamodernism is a movement, a philosophy, a system of logic, an artistic practice, a political strategy, a “structure of feeling,” or some combination of all of these. What’s generally agreed upon by metamodernists, however, is that metamodernism is a “post-postmodernism” inasmuch as it, not postmodernism, is now the best descriptor for contemporary culture. There’s also broad agreement that metamodernism encourages the reconstruction of pieces into wholes that can’t be readily deconstructed — which means that metamodern artworks are made up of pieces or ideas taken from multiple sources (some created by the artist, some taken from our increasingly expansive social and intellectual networks) but also hang together as objects that are difficult to describe but clearly original.</p><p>Sometimes metamodernists speak of the metamodern “sublime,” or the metamodern “awesome,” as a way of discussing events, artworks, and other phenomena that capture our imagination and our sense of hopefulness even as we find ourselves unable to easily “deconstruct” them. For instance, much like the very different output of Donald Trump, Donald Glover, and Marina Abramovic, Wallace’s <em>Infinite Jest</em> provoked anger or confusion among many simply by refusing to be readily categorized; in a world in which our inclination is to deconstruct everything into a series of neatly opposing principles, metamodern artifacts continue to thwart our sense that data can be so quickly and easily processed. Likewise, metamodern dialogues and collaborations tend to cross so many lines of affiliation, interest, convention, and (in the arts) genre that they frustrate readers trained in Modernism’s interpretive “close readings” and/or postmodernism’s deconstructive critiques. In this way, metamodernism offers us new avenues for making meaning, reading meaning, and even discussing possible solutions to old problems.</p><p><a href="http://www.sethabramson.net/"><em>Seth Abramson</em></a><em> is an Assistant Professor of English at the University of New Hampshire and the series co-editor of the Best American Experimental Writing, whose next edition will be released by Wesleyan University Press in late 2015. His most recent book is Metamericana (Blaze Vox, 2015).</em></p><figure><a href="http://endofthetour-movie.com/#/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lhkcrAi8iJOjWIHOK1ktzw.png" /></a></figure><p>Recommended</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8cdb8563e0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/just-words/metamodernism-101-8cdb8563e0">Metamodernism 101</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/just-words">Just Words</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why We Write]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/just-words/why-we-write-1b8b3f017e44?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b8b3f017e44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-foster-wallace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[achievement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 20:56:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-13T18:56:43.326Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l5hFIT1lCo3am0byhkCDjw.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>David Foster Wallace and the Education of the Spirit</strong></h4><p><em>by Seth Abramson</em></p><p><strong>I began writing </strong>poetry in 1998 because I deeply resented being a law student. I bristled at the way law school rewires your brain — makes you “think like a lawyer”, a skill-set that’s useful in a few situations and harmful in many others. The first time I was subjected to law school’s “Socratic” instruction, I knew that if I didn’t find a creative outlet and soon, I’d either lose myself in the law or flunk out of law school entirely. Under the law school version of the Socratic Method, you regularly get called on to answer ten or more questions in front of 150 people; it’s harrowing and forces an attention to rationality that’s exhausting. So writing poetry daily helped me keep my head above water. Later on, it helped me to continue practicing law as a public defender even when I’d become exhausted from witnessing tragedies every day.</p><blockquote>When we write, we transmit not just data but our very being</blockquote><p>In hindsight, I don’t think I knew myself very well when I was a law student, or even for many of the years I practiced law. I don’t think I appreciated exactly what writing meant or could mean for my own emotional and moral development. Was it, a little like a courtroom, yet another place in which I could test my courage and will? Was it a chance for me to expose my idiosyncrasies to the world, in the balance feeling either rejected or embraced? Was it just a means to chart my achievements by tracking publications, prizes, and the gradual development of a readership? Looking back on two decades of being a writer, I think writing has been, at various times, all and none of these for me. But I’ve also learned that the best writers are those for whom writing tracks alongside — rather than being only a poor mirror of — their own evolution as husbands and wives, brothers and sisters, sons and daughters, friends and coworkers. A body of writing or a writing style that doesn’t change as its author ages increasingly suggests, to me, a separation between Life and Art that I find alarming.</p><p>I guess my point is that I write because I’m alive, and because I’m afraid to die without having changed myself appreciably. And it’s deeply meaningful for me to undergo this sort of psychological metamorphosis while intimately connected — through reading, writing, and the sort of dialogues these practices initiate — with the communities I live and work in and the people I care most about. As David Foster Wallace once said of his own relationship with writing, “One of the things that’s good about writing is that it’s a great remedy for my natural self-involvement and self-centeredness…really learning how to write effectively is, in fact, probably more a matter of spirit than it is of intellect. ‘Spirit’ means I never forget there’s someone on the end of the line, that I owe that person certain allegiances, that I’m sending that person all kinds of messages, only some of which have to do with the actual content of what it is I’m trying to say.” When we write, we transmit not just data but our very being — and this means that writing well, living well, and using our time here in a way that encourages self-improvement are all inseparable aspects of the human experience.</p><p>So how do writers enhance the self-instructive quality of the writing process? While Wallace once said that a good book makes its reader smarter — and he’s right — an equally important ambition is for the author to figure out what sort of relationship with language makes <em>a writer</em> smarter. Or, for that matter, more ethical and self-aware both on and off the page. Unfortunately, in recent years the question of how writers improve their skill-sets has been considered almost exclusively in the context of creative writing programs. The problem with this is that programs of this sort are geared toward helping students learn <em>how</em> to write, not necessarily <em>why</em> to write. Yet most veteran writers will tell you that there’s no obvious purpose in studying the former question until you have a well-considered — if necessarily ever-changing — answer to the latter one.</p><p>Deeply considering your own reasons for writing, and your own evolving and likely idiosyncratic relationship with language and culture, is as important as writing well. It’s also critical for writers to understand that readers come to literature for as many reasons as writers do. Some of the reasons writers and readers turn to literature are clearly healthy ones — others, a little less so. David Foster Wallace’s life teaches us much, but I think one of its clearest and hardest lessons is that language can be both a boon and a curse for writers and readers alike. Wallace’s very facility with words and facts at times led him to give too much authority to his own thought process, and too little weight to the healing power of good company. Yet what Wallace struggled with in life he seemed to struggle with much less in his fiction. What this means is that readers who treat <em>Infinite Jest</em> as just an ironic commentary on all that’s wrong with contemporary living fail to see, too, the book’s deep empathy for men and women and the human condition.</p><p>In the complicated relationship between Wallace-the-man and Wallace-the-novelist we see the many ways writing and reading teach us to live fuller and more self-conscious lives. And yet this only happens if, across the years, we pay close attention to both our writing and reading processes.</p><p><a href="http://www.sethabramson.net/"><em>Seth Abramson</em></a><em> is an Assistant Professor of English at the University of New Hampshire and the series co-editor of the Best American Experimental Writing, whose next edition will be released by Wesleyan University Press in late 2015. His most recent book is Metamericana (Blaze Vox, 2015).</em></p><figure><a href="http://endofthetour-movie.com/#/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lhkcrAi8iJOjWIHOK1ktzw.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b8b3f017e44" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/just-words/why-we-write-1b8b3f017e44">Why We Write</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/just-words">Just Words</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Teach as
Wallace Wrote]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/just-words/to-teach-as-wallace-wrote-2e38373cb671?source=rss-b76c014fea12------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e38373cb671</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-foster-wallace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[achievement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Seth Abramson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jun 2015 16:51:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-22T23:41:39.687Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8O9xh_82soRGiPYPIadpSw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Teaching Writing and Teaching Through Writing</h4><p><em>by Seth Abramson</em></p><p><strong>One of the most</strong> alluring characters in David Foster Wallace’s <em>Infinite Jest</em> is Madame Psychosis, a mysterious radio DJ whose identity is unknown even to the engineer of her long-running midnight-to-one radio program. Madame Psychosis uses her airtime to read strange texts aloud and offer her opinion on obscure pop-cultural subjects. For instance, she discusses “the home-lab process for turning uranium oxide powder into good old fissionable U-235,” and offers “a critique of the Steeler defense’s double-slot secondary.” There are many other oddities to the format of the program: she begins each episode with five minutes of silence; she introduces guests but never interviews them; and many of her “readings” take several shows to complete. Even so, her program finds a large and devoted audience in the fictional Massachusetts of <em>Infinite Jest</em>. One can easily imagine Wallace himself being a part of that audience. The late novelist found popular culture mesmerizing even as he considered its pace and invasiveness oppressive.</p><blockquote>“The cliché turns out to be true: the teacher learns a lot more than the students.”</blockquote><p>When I think about David Foster Wallace in the context of teaching undergraduates, I recall a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLPStHVi0SI">1997 interview</a> he did with Charlie Rose in which he spoke about his simultaneous fondness for and exhaustion with higher education. “You learn an enormous amount [when you teach],” Wallace told Rose. “The cliché turns out to be true: the teacher learns a lot more than the students. You do for about two or three years, and then the curve drops off sharply.” He went on to criticize universities for hiring writers to teach and then granting them tenure based on their writing — teaching and writing being two things Wallace considered fundamentally incompatible.</p><p>I find myself agreeing with Wallace as to the flaws of the tenure process while disagreeing with him on the question of how teaching and writing interact. And yet, I think both of Wallace’s observations owe something to the author’s fascination with Madame Psychosis and what she represents. Madame Psychosis’ radio program delivers to its listeners far too much information for them to process, but nevertheless they find the ceaseless stream of data intoxicating. Television is much like this, as is the Internet, as is — for introverts like Wallace and myself — too much social interaction.</p><p>For some, Wallace included, teaching creates the same risk of self-exhaustion as a radio program like Madame Psychosis’. When you teach undergraduates, you are buffeted by their seemingly boundless energy and curiosity, and this is a wonderful feeling. But also, sometimes simultaneously, students may resist instruction due to self-doubts, anxieties, and preconceptions that arise naturally during the maturation process. These two extremes, which fill the classroom with an endless stream of contradictory emotional and environmental data, can be exhausting for a teacher. They can even — Wallace’s biggest fear — cause teachers to develop rigid classroom formats as a defense against this exhaustion. Sometimes, it makes writing on the same day you teach feel a little like whiplash.</p><blockquote>“Fiction’s about what it is to be a fucking human being”</blockquote><p>As a teacher whose professional writing is also creative writing, I’m luckier than most. Creative writing, like the best creative writing workshops, is <em>inductive</em> — it’s an exploration both of possibilities and the exciting problems that possibilities generate. It isn’t, or shouldn’t be, merely an attempt to turn abstract principles into a series of hard-and-fast rules. What I mean here is that Wallace probably did his best teaching in his novels, and I don’t know that he’d disagree with that assessment. His fiction is “maximalist” in the sense that it’s ornate both in its language and the volume of often confusing data it offers readers. I think the best teachers find ways to bring Wallace’s radical openness to unexpected juxtaposition — whether it’s an overlap of optimism and cynicism, sincerity and irony, adventure and stasis, or comedy and tragedy — into the classroom. As <em>Infinite Jest</em> demonstrates with Madame Psychosis, fiction permits the creation of data-streams that are mesmerizing even when they’re exhausting and internally contradictory. In this sense, Wallace’s work is deeply instructive: in its desire to look at the whole of a thing without glossing over any of its complexities, it teaches teachers to be tireless and, hopefully, fearless.</p><p>“Fiction’s about what it is to be a fucking human being,” Wallace once said, and, another time, “I want to author things that both restructure worlds and make living people feel stuff.” Both of these comments describe admirably the role of not just the writer but the writer who teaches writing to others — whether it’s in a classroom setting or through his own hard-won narratives. In part because of Wallace’s influence, I now teach and write not as a means of simplifying difficult concepts, but rather to show how vast networks of information can produce exhilaration and illumination even as they retain their daunting complexity.</p><p><a href="http://www.sethabramson.net"><em>Seth Abramson</em></a><em> is an Assistant Professor of English at the University of New Hampshire and the series co-editor of the Best American Experimental Writing, whose next edition will be released by Wesleyan University Press in late 2015. His most recent book is Metamericana (Blaze Vox, 2015).</em></p><figure><a href="http://endofthetour-movie.com"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lhkcrAi8iJOjWIHOK1ktzw.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e38373cb671" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/just-words/to-teach-as-wallace-wrote-2e38373cb671">To Teach as
Wallace Wrote</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/just-words">Just Words</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>