[Jprogramming] Bug/Inconsistency among namelist verbs from z locale

The Geeko theGeeko61 at gmail.com
Mon Sep 26 22:41:03 HKT 2011


Björn Helgason <gosinn <at> gmail.com> writes:

> 
> Try defining a conjunction instead of a verb and then you may use the rest
> of the special letters

I don't think you understand.  I have no problem using any of the letters {m, n, 
x, y, u, v}.  I can successfully use any of the 6.  (In my case I was using them 
to define nouns; but that does not impact what I am experiencing.)

The problem is what 2 verbs (i.e., nl and names) report.  Unlike another verb 
(i.e., namelist), nl and names fails to display x or y.

Besides this exception, all 3 verbs (nl, names and namelist) report all 
variables (including m, n, u and v).

So, the discrepancy is this:  namelist reports all words; but nl and names 
reports all words EXCEPT x and y.

SOLUTION
--------
EITHER
(1) Correct the issue with nl and names to report ALL words (i.e., mimic the 
behavior of namelist);

OR
(2) Modify namelist to have the same defects as nl and names; PLUS modify all 3 
verbs to omit m, n, u, and v, from the result to be consistent with the 
treatment of x and y (thereby, making all 6 words - m, n, x, y, u & v - 
unavailable in their results).  This would be a kludge, however, since none of 
the 3 are preventing USAGE of the word; they are simply failing to report the 
usage of the word.  And, in this case, we are constraining the expressions which 
are permitted by the language, for no good reason.





More information about the Programming mailing list